Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Posts

Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#1

Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Rik, WI

Greetings all.

Here's my dilemma:

Keep two full sized lathes or take a beating on selling a month old G0733?

It's taken four years for my arm to fully heal.

Foolishly I sold my PM 3520B and other machinery during this down time.

I'm restocking the shop and for the most part the new machinery is nicer/safer than their predecessors. A couple of weeks after buying a G0733 an opportunity presented itself to buy a priced to move PM3520B which I jumped on.

With Grizzly releasing the G0766 for less than what I paid for the G0733 I'm going to lose my shirt if I sell it. Need of money isn't the driving factor but if it's only going to collect dust then this may be the best option. I'm also toying with the idea of donating it to school or wood turning club.

My shop is plenty large enough to have two full sized lathes. I'm thinking the Griz could be setup for my kids to use since they are just getting into turning. We also have an older midi lathe.

The real kicker is had I known about the G0766 I may have purchased that rather than the G0733 or 3520B.

Thoughts?

Thanks,

Rik

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#2

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Dick Coers

As far as I am concerned, take the bath and move on. I personally have no use for any Grizzly machinery. I guess since you have the room, you could turn it into a buffing machine.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Rob Wallace

I'm with Dick, and wouldn't advise going the Grizzly route for any of their lathes. If you can get a buyer, sell it, even if at a loss. Its value will only get lower and lower over time. I decided to keep my Jet 1642-2 when I got my Robust American Beauty in Sept. 2012 since I had so many accessories for it that I would never get as much for it as I valued its extra capabilities; even if I pieced-out and sold all of the stuff that went with the 1642 lathe, it would be quite a loss. I still have long-bed capacity for turning spindles to 42", and having the Jamieson hollowing system still works OK for tall vessels. It certainly wouldn't hurt to have more than one lathe - I have 5, not including the little 1880's treadle lathe that I restored!

Try to find a buyer, but if not, use the Grizz for non-critical work.

Rob

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#4

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

terry quiram

I agree with Dick and Rob. Unload the Grizzly.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#5

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Phillip Medghalchi

2nd that. I had hard time to get parts for mine then when I got them they were as inferior as the ones on the orig. lathe. when I called them they said that they can replace them which would have ended up in same place again. I finally got rid of it telling the buyer that they buy it as is.

They may be good at higher end commercial stuff, but not for turning. That's my 2 cents. Others may not agree.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#6

Bill Blasic

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Bill Blasic

Well I'm on the other end of this spectrum. If the lathe runs without problems and your happy with it keep it as it is nice to have multiple lathes. It is nice to be able to have different systems like Alan Trout's hollowing system, the Baxter Treading Jig, the Monster Hollowing System and Ruth Niles Bottle Stopper or Pendant Jig set up at all times. While not being a fan of Grizzly lathes the new 22 inch, 3 HP 600 lb plus lathe does have me intrigued.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#7

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

John Lucas

I'm with bill I like having two lathes although you already said you have a midi

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#8

Lyle Jamieson

ditto, dump the G


Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#9

Is this just an ad for Grizzly?

Craig Daymon

He dumped his 3520B for a Grizzly? Really? There are more than a few here that have been very happy with a 3520. Now he's talking about replacing the Grizzly with another Grizzly, stating that money is not the issue. If I was dumping a 3520, my first consideration would be an American Beauty from Robust. Maybe a Oneway, though my personal preference would be the Robust because the 3520 has the same spindle size as the Robust.

This sounds like a promotional attempt for the Grizzly.

Sorry, just my opinion. Maybe just the flu talking.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#10

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Roger Chandler

What a lot of people fail to realize is the Grizzly lathes on the upper end have improved dramatically over the last 5 years or so! In fact there is a manufacturing connection with the Powermatic, Jet, and Grizzly lines and a couple of others as well.

The Burt Group manufactures for different vendors, and some like the PM are made to specs, but my Grizzly G0698 has the same features as the 3520b as far as 2 hp, reversing, vfd speed drive and has been a reliable performer for the 5 years I have had it.

I am taking advantage of the new 3 hp G0766........and have it on order. Things change and past problems can be solved, so whether you care for a Grizzly lathe or not, that it totally up to you. My experience has been very good, and I know a number of other turners who speak highly of their G0733 models.

I have turned on 9 different 3520b machines, and one Robust American Beauty, and the Robust AB is my dream lathe. Until I can see myself set to invest in that model, the Grizzly that I have compares well in performance and has the same features, with the 3520b and I think the 3 hp G0766 will do a great job and is actually a little bigger than the 3520b with the 22" swing.

Some people would not drive a Ford. Some would not drive a Chevy. Some won't drive an import of any sort. Some won't like a Grizzly lathe no matter how much they have improved.....some won't purchase a lathe made in China, just like some will only buy a made in America automobile.......all good! Just know that those who are driving Hyundai or a VW get to where they are going and with in pretty good style! ;) of course, your mileage may vary!

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#11

Re: Is this just an ad for Grizzly?

Rik, WI

Craig,

Reread my initial post.

I bought another PM 3520b after selling my mine 4 years ago.

Is it an ad for Grizzly? Quite the contrary it has become a Grizzly bashing thread. In hindsight I should not have mentioned manufacturers.

My question was whether or not to keep two full sized lathes. Had I know folks were going to rip on Grizzly and not answer the question, I wouldn't have bothered to post it.

We've made our decision of what to do but sadly this thread was of no help and I regret posting it.

Rik

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#12

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Rik, WI

Thanks Bill and John for answering my question!

I will be doing a fair amount of bowl coring and hollow coring.

Using both lathes side-by-side at a friends shop, they perform equally.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#13

I was waiting for you to comment Roger

Dick Coers

Because there is no cheer leader for Grizzly lathes like you. Plenty of folks know that Grizzly has improved their lathes, but we also realize they had a long ways to go! What does surprise me about the enthusiasm shown on this new one is that I don't think anyone knows the bearing arrangement, or the real motor hp. The banjo appears to be way undersized for a machine with that capacity as well. Most don't buy their lathes to resell them, but I bet selling a Powermatic is a lot easier than selling a Grizzly.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#14

You asked for thoughts Rik

Dick Coers

and that's what you got isn't it? I was burnt and wasted weeks trying to rebuild a brand new Grizzly band saw. It should have never been shipped since they went to extraordinary efforts to unsuccessfully balance some horribly bad cast wheels. My opinion for Grizzly won't ever be the same.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#15

Re: I was waiting for you to comment Roger

Roger Chandler

Hi Dick........my analogy on import cars and preferred brands is valid, I think. I think we will find that the hp rating will hold up.......that remains to be seen, but from my own personal experience with my current G0698, power never seemed to be an issue, and others who have the G0733 have spoken in very positive terms as well.

My experience on 9 different 3520b units and a couple of Jet 1642 evs 2 hp models leave me with at least a valid comparison on a personal basis.....I can only assess from that and what others I trust tell me about their units. I used to think that I would never, ever even consider driving a Hyundai, or a Honda. One of my sons has a 2013 Honda Accord, and the other a Hyundai Sonata. Man have they ever improved on features and quality! My view from several years ago is no longer valid......that being said, I would still rather have a Cadillac! But a Honda Accord will certainly get me where I am going and in pretty good style to boot!

Same with these lathes......I have no reason to cheer lead on the Grizzly, but my own experience with it and the 3520b's and even a Robust AB, have given me insight that tells me that these new lathes are way above what used to be offered by Grizzly. Heck, as far as I know, Grizzly does not know me or anything but a customer number when I called and ordered.

The price point and features are the values of the market at the present moment so that is the only reason I even brought it up on the SMC thread. Just thought that some turner might see it and it would be in his budget for a much desired upgrade from a mini lathe, or be a suitable substitute for someone who might not have the bucks to shell out on a 3520b, but could still get a pretty good ride!

All meant in good will.........nothing more, nothing less. At least, I hope my posts have been helpful to someone along the way! :)

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#16

Re: I was waiting for you to comment Roger

Roger Chandler

Dick, I forgot to mention, I actually had someone come over today and look at my present G0698 and is seriously thinking about purchasing tomorrow. I don't generally purchase wood working equipment to sell either, but this person who looked at my G0698 today owns a 3520b, and is one of the units I have turned on......his comment was......."this has the same features of my Powermatic!"

Yep, just a little lighter in weight than his, but he still thought it is a very nice lathe for the money!

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#17

Re: Is this just an ad for Grizzly?

Craig Daymon

Well, that being the case, then it depends if you intend to teach classes or if more than one family member has an interest.

The other scenario would be if each offers meaningful benefits over the other. For example, a dedicated bowl lathe or a lathe with an exceptionally long bed if either would prove useful to you.

Both your 3520 or the Robust American Beauty have sliding headstocks, so they can function very much like a dedicated bowl lathe, even for very large diameters given a lower mounted bed extension or outboard rest.

Having more than one would allow you to keep turning large should one need repairs (replacement bearings, motor, etc.), but maybe a mini can keep you occupied during those typically rare occasions. (If they turn out not to be rare, then it's time to look at a different lathe.) Minis are also nice for demos and for turning group get togethers. Very portable.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#18

Re: You asked for thoughts Rik

Rik, WI

You are correct I did ask. It's a shame you had a bad experience. I have Grizzly tools mixed with PM, Delta, Rockwell, Jet, etc. I guess I've been lucky to not have an issue since they all do what they were designed to do without issue.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#19

An interesting problem with Grizzly posts on SMC

Dick Coers

Is that you can't get both sides of many Grizzly stories on SMC. I was banned from the sight for telling the story of my bandsaw too often and too aggressively. I was warned to lay off, then banned for being "unfriendly". So any strong pro-Grizzly posts mostly go unchallenged there. Advertisers are aggressively protected.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#20

Bill Blasic

Re: Is this just an ad for Grizzly?

Bill Blasic

Sorry Craig but I think you need to reread what you are talking about.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#21

Re: I was waiting for you to comment Roger

Roger Chandler

Just to update this for Dick........I sold the lathe today!

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#22

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Rum

If you're happy with the 733 and have plenty of room then keep it. Having a second lathe could be handy for a handful of things (buffing station, leave your reverse turning chuck/setup on it, etc) and no lathe is infallible so if your main one goes down...

You've (IMHO) already taken the larger depreciation so the marginal loss of keeping it for another year or so isn't likely going to be that bad.

If you find you haven't used it in a year and still have no plans to then ditch it. Otherwise it seems like your just churning money out and if you decide between now and then you wanted two well... There you are back where you started.

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#23

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Dan

well, this is weird since i was the one emailing Rik about buying his 733 on Craigslist...

i am glad he was honest with me when i asked his opinion on how to move forward with purchasing a new upgrade to my Harbor freight 1236 lathe and suggested that i take a look at the new Grizzly 766 lathe.

the thing that i don't know is how much of a risk i am taking by per-ordering it now in case there are issues that come out in some initial reviews.

if February rolls around and the lathe is not getting reviewed well, will Grizzly have any problem with me canceling their order? does anyone have any experience with this?

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

#24

Re: Multiple Full Sized Lathes?

Rik, WI

Rum,

You came to same conclusion that we did.