Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OK actually I did get some tools

Posts

OK actually I did get some tools

#1

OK actually I did get some tools

John Lucas

I know we talked about this before but it's really important to have a plan on what to do with your tools if you pass on. A fellow local turner passed away about a year ago. It took a while for his wife to decide what to do with them and possibly the heartache of needing to do that. Some local turners helped her sort things out and priced everything. Then put out the word to the rest of us that she was selling things.

I purchased a belt sander that I had been thinking I needed but then purchase several other items I didn't really need but could use and then a few items that I knew would be hard to sell. I'll sell those myself later probably at cost when I do a demo using those tools.

I know my son would not want the tools and my future wife won't have any idea how to price things and I wouldn't want to put her through the hassle of trying to sell them. I talked to a friend who runs an auction company about how they handle it and he said they do it all the time. They take a percentage of course but it's all handled professionally and quickly and I think that's probably what I will put in the will after I talk to my family.

this comes to mind because I just had a good friends husband pass away and just heard of a turners husband who passed away unexpectedly. And we all heard about David Nittmans passing. At our age these things can happen quickly so it's important to have your affairs in order before if possible so as not to put undue stress on your family.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#2

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

Phillip Medghalchi

John, this happened to a friend of mine just a month ago, while he was battling cancer and at the time he asked me to figure out a way to price his turning tools. Unfortunately, we couldn't do it because i came down with some upper respiratory infection and did not want to get his condition more worse.

Plan I suggested was to create a spread sheet with all the items listed and the original price, and the current market values of each. However, I could not think of ways to figure out the current market value of those tools.

Any thought on how you and your friends went about pricing those tools? And how did you all arrive at those prices?

Also, is there any programs anyone can think about to use to compile these info.s to make it easier for the spouses of woodworkers or turners.

I think this a very good subject to discuss, and get input as how we really like to have our turning affairs be handled by our surviving loved ones when that time arrives. I am sure that many of us even have children that would not know how to handle this situation.

After all we spend so much money on our hobby and it is a shame for loved ones to be taken by some smart people for cheap.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#3

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

John Lucas

Phillip my friends tried to look up list prices if they could find them and then cut the price in half. If the pieces were old they went to ebay and just made a guess since most things on ebay are showing only current bid not selling price.

In my case I'm just going to have my hiers auction off the shop. It won't bring as much money but will be worlds easier for them.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#4

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

Skip Beardsley

John,

I agree with Phil about this being a good topic of discussion. Have thought about it many times and done nothing about it. With 75th coming up in January it seems as thought I should get going.

Another aspect of the topic is getting rid of all those tools, many bought at turning demos, that one never, or no longer uses.

At what point does having three lathes, Four chucks, four grinders, two wolverine sharpening gigs,two termite tools and a five drawers of assorted chisels, seem to be too much? I am going to use this post as a reminder that there is some definite cleaning out of my lathe area to be done.

One option I will take is to donate some things to my local club, Eastern Maine Woodturners. I am going to ask other members if they know of a beginning turner who could benefit from a donation to their tool collection.

Thanks for the prod.

By the way, loved the article on wood bending in the current journal. Lots of food for thought even thought I am not sure when I will get to bending.

Skip

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: OK actually I did get some tools *LINK*

Brad Vietje

John,

As Phillip already mentioned, a very good topic to discuss. I'd only take issue with one thing. You wrote: "if you pass on", which I might change to when you pass on.

As the Onion occasionally reminds us, the death rate has been holding steady at exactly 100% for many generations ;) Just for fun, and to add a little levity to this solemn topic, read their article -- complete with charts, here:

http://www.theonion.com/articles/world-death-rate-holding-steady-at-100-percent,1670/

As a friend of mine says, "it's a pretty good picnic, but their ain't any of us get'n out of here alive"

Since turning is such a specialized field, we will all do our families a great service by keeping an inventory with the approximate new prices and purchase dates. I think a good figure for used stuff would be 50% of the new price, at least as a conversation starter.

A Happy & Healthy New Year to all,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


Death Rate Holds Steady at 100%

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#6

Don't Forget The Benefit Auction *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

Some of those extra tools could find new homes and Ellis would have a little help with the upgrades if they were listed on the Benefit Auction page.


Benefits Auction

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#7

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

Skip Beardsley

I think a good figure for used stuff would be 50% of the new price, at least as a conversation starter.

Brad,

I know this is the usually accepted figure to use but I take exception to it in some specific cases. I have a shop full of tools which are only two years old. Table saw, 3520b, large band saw, drill press etc. Sure wouldn't want my wife to sell these for fifty percent of their new price.

What about things like chucks? Is a used Vicmarc 150 only worth fifty percent of new, and if so, why? I don't think they wear out unless they are abused.

I am glad the topic has come up as it will definitely get me going on planning for the future.

Skip

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#8

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Col Smith

Very good subject for discussion here.

I have spoken to my Little Lady about this & we have decided to donate all my turning & other wood work tools to my local turning club. What the club http://mandurahwoodturners.com/ can't use they can pass on to novices or sell them.

I feel that I owe them so much for the knowledge etc that they have passed on to me over the years.

So many members that are willing to share their experience to make the hobby more enjoyable for me.

Just my 2 cents

Col

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#9

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Phillip Medghalchi

Col, your wishes are certainly appreciated, if your spouse is in a financial situation who can do that. Although that this has to be declared in your will, as if there are any one who inherit this will not contest the will. (let's hope so)

In most cases the money coming from sale of our tools will help the surviving spouse to offset some of the expenses involved even to move the tools out of the way, or to pay for some of the unexpected expenses.

I think even having such a lost with approximate values is an important help to the spouse.

Also, when some one passes away there are still taxes which have to be paid that the sell of the tools will help to off set that too.

The other scenario is that if you wish to donate your tools to the club which you belong to, it still a good idea to know the approximate value for tax deduction as well.

Of course, I am not an accountant and hope that someone will clarify this for us.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#10

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Phillip Medghalchi

Stuart, I may agree that it's a good idea to do this, but shouldn't the spouse take advantage of the tax credit she/he can get. After all it's the asset being reduced.

Or in this case the net worth.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#11

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

Phillip Medghalchi

Skip, here is the scenario that happened to my friend who passed away two month ago. He bought a tool ( I can not remember what it was) in Dec. of 2013, before he found out that he had the kidney cancer and had to go in Jan 2014 to have 2/3 of one kidney removed. then he fond out he could not be around dust becuase of the lung.

the bottom line was that he never got to use the tool and I bet when his wife calls me to help them out I will find that tool in the orig. box. I think in this case the 50% of the orig. price is unfair to the wife.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#12

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

John Lucas

I do agree but in reality your simply trying to remove the tools and give the family some money in return. You don't want this to drag on and have to haggle over price. Granted a product like a new 3520B would easily bring more than half price and that's what should be decided early on. Ideally before you pass on. However the other side of the coin is to take as much stress off the family as possible and if you didn't leave a list then it's up to someone to set a price.

Also are you going to reestablish prices every year or so due to wear and tear. that would be a hassle. I'm not advocating anything here I'm just saying we need to do something up front to remove as much heartache as possible for those left behind.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#13

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Stuart Johnson

when some one passes away there are still taxes which have to be paid that the sell of the tools will help to off set that too.

I'm not an estate accountant but for the biggest majority of us estate taxes won't be much of an issue when you start figuring JTWROS and Community Property laws. If selling tools is required to meet any expenses that do come about because of a death then it's possible those tools should not have been purchased and better financial discipline should have been used during the lifetime.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#14

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Don A. DAvis

You're kidding, right?

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#15

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Stuart Johnson

Would you care to explain what you mean by kidding?

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#16

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

John Lucas

I think what he meant was many of us just sort of get by and don't have large savings. End of life expenses especially medical bills could easily wipe out most savings. At least for people on my income.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#17

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

Skip Beardsley

Phil,

I agree. That is the type of case I was talking about. Here is the problem, however. When someone comes to look at the tool, even in the box, new, what is their motivation to buy the tool? If it is priced to reflect that it is new,or nearly new, why not just buy a new one. If it is priced to attract a buyer then it is probably not fair to the owner.

On more than one occasion I have pointed out to sellers their price was too low and have offered more. That way I don't feel as though I have benefited from some's plight or ignorance.

It is a two edge sword and so much bigger when an entire shop is involved.

I would like to hear from folks here about auction experiences. That might be the way to go.

Skip

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#18

barry rockwell

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

Barry Rockwell

Great subject Skip, and admittedly not one I've given much thought to. Guess I better start thinking about it also. To me, it seems that the financial position of the immediate family/heirs would be of paramount importance in making a decision about it. In my case, it would be impossible to burden my wife with the responsibility, and if I left it all to my son it would be an incredible burden to him to take care of it from1300 miles away. Even if he wanted it, he would have to hire a semi to haul it all, and probably buy a new home to have a large enough space to put it in. Seems to me that a prior arrangement with an auction house might be a very good answer, not only for the shop, but for other toys/possessions also. The proceeds could be divided up or assigned in a will just like other assets. Certainly food for thought.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#19

  a funny afterthought

John Lucas

I had a dream one night and I was in heaven or somewhere looking down on my shop while they were selling everything. I was totally frustrated because people didn't understand what jigs went with the router and they sold the some lathe parts in a box with drill bits. Some guy was explaining to his friend how to use one of my lathe accessories and he had it all wrong. My hand planes that I worked so hard to recondition, true up and sharpen went for almost nothing because they weren't brand names. Even worse than than that they had put everything out in the yard and it was raining and the table saw and lathe beds were starting to rust.

Maybe donating the tools to a real woodworker or club is a good idea after all. At least someone with a desire to really do good work would get the tools. Or have a contest where future woodworker wannabees write in and say what they would do if they won the tools and then donate them to that person. Of course we all know if you get them into woodturning there goes their retirement income.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#20

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Stuart Johnson

John, my post was in reply to Phillip's concern about selling tools to pay taxes. Very few of us need to worry about estate or other taxes coming due when we pass. Expenses such as medical and burial are something different. If the surviving spouse needs to sell tools to make the house or utility payments then there is a problem that isn't going to be resolved easily.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#21

Gotcha-hate the web

John Lucas

It's just too easy to misunderstand what people are saying on the net or take it some other way. We all need to give everyone the benefit of the doubt.

Yea in reality our shops are actually worth much less than we think. Or at least others think. I had a friend over the other day and he say man you must have $100,000 in tools. OK I know I have a lot of tools but I got to thinking about it and for insurance purposes I only took out $15,000 to cover replacement. It probably wouldn't actually replace all the files, carving tools, router bits, drill bits etc but if you total those up your insurance premium runs too high so you gamble a little. I'm covered well enough for tornadoes, floods, and theft but if I have a fire and lose everything I'm kind of screwed. Just can't justify paying that much extra each month. Of course you can't put a dollar amount on all the jigs you build and how many hours you have in tuning up handplanes, chisels and carving tools.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#22

Re:   a funny afterthought

Rum

Auctions are a crapshoot. John's eloquent dream description isn't too far off of a lot of auctions I've been to.

Sometimes things go for near retail or even above and other times they go for pennies on the dollar. Depends a lot on the crowd and the auctioneer, a good auctioneer can really get things moving and sometimes position products for best sale. One example I saw was they sold a brand new box with a couple of amana bits that were with maybe $120 new and enough folks bid that it got up to about $90, the next lot was a $30 HF bit set, none of the folks bidding on the amana set bothered but some other folks had gotten excited and bid it up to around $100. The supplies for the glass studio on the other hand had few bidders and went for maybe 2-3c on the dollar.

Another option is to bring in an estate sale manager. There's a gal near us who basically makes a living doing that. She'll come in, price things with her crew and hold basically an advanced yard sale. Takes some of the hassle out and folks are more likely to show up to one of her sales in general. The main downside (for the family, upside for me) with her is that she doesn't like grease so I've gotten some good deals on things that looked icky.

Loml said that if I croak first, she'll just put an ad on the woodworking forums "have nice shop, looking for good man able to use it". More practically we have a spreadsheet where we record date bought and original purchase price for tools and other items of significant value (both for this and insurance purposes).

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#23

John needs to shop around.

mjonesrdg

My shop tools and goodies had been insured for $15K for many years. My State Farm agent did a "Double Check" of my insurance needs last year and suggested increasing the amount to $50K. The annual premium increase was just like $35/year.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#24

Re:   a funny afterthought

Phillip Medghalchi

Rum, that's what I mentioned on one of my replies, to have a spread sheet that enlists every tool purchased and the orig. price. Also, the purpose of the tool for a specific job. Like if a wood worker comes and not knowing what the chuck is for and the lathe was already gone then he will low-bid the chuck and it will go for pennies on the dollar.

Of course, as John mentioned the provisions to lift the burden from the spouse and/or heirs should be considered into the detail of the will.

Then it comes down to the antique tools that some of you guys collect. Those have to be clearly identified so no one comes off the street and try to by them for cheap. because of the looks. Just like if someone has stamp collection or even baseball cards collection.

Re: OK actually I did get some tools

#25

Re: Don't Forget The Benefit Auction

Phillip Medghalchi

Stuart, I agree with that point, however, as John said some of us are still operating on somewhat careful budget. although that some of tools for turning started costing me money, bu they were accumulated from 2010 until now, at that I was careful not to put too much pressure on our finances,s o they were bought little at a time. However, by now they are worth something and still considered assets.

On the other hands you may want to look at some of the financial affairs of some of the friends you had to get an idea of what happened to their spouse or their heirs after their death. It may surprise you with all the things that takes place after death. For instance in my case I only have one daughter and she will not have any idea what to do with my tools should she become the beneficiary. she is very trst worthy person and she trust anything people with tell her when it comes to dealing with this kind of stuff (not a naive person) just different interest in life.. It would be only fair to give her some guide lines as how to deal with this issue of selling my tools. ( trust me if I even look form above, and figure out someone is trying to rip her off, no matter how much I yell whe will not hear me) (at least that's what i have heard) :D

That's my 2 cents. lets hear what yyou r thoughts are.