Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

Posts

Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

#1

Aage Rendalen

Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

Aage Rendalen

I finished a threading jig the other day and decided to put it to the test today. Since I didn't have a threaded collet chuck to hold the Dremel tread cutter (no. 199), I put it in my jacobs chuch and slid it into my headstock spindle--only to see it wobble.

Would this be caused by the chuck or the spindle? I hope it's the chuck.

PS. Do you place the thread cutter (in the headstock) to the left inside and outside of your box/lid?

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

#2

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle? *LINK*

Bill Boehme

It sounds like you might have put the fly cutter a bit crooked in the chuck. With small diameter shanks, it can be a problem. Also, if you have ever had a drill bit spin in the chuck or if the chuck is old, the jaws may be worn or have burrs. Also, check the Morse taper socket in the spindle and the Morse taper shank on the Jacobs chuck for any damage like galling or rust. If the shank is bad then toss it and get another one. They don't cost much. If the spindle socket has galling or rust, it is more serious, but still repairable. It will require the use of a Morse taper hand reamer plus a Spin-L-Mate tool. The Spin-L-Mate website has instructions on how to go about repairing a spindle socket.


Spin-L-Mate

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

#3

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

John Lucas

Bill answered it pretty well. You probably have grit or something between the surfaces or on a bit with a really small shank may have it off enter in the jaws.

As for cutting the threads I try to cut with the bit spinning into the wood like you would with a router bit. The cutter is probably ground to cut cleanest in this direction

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

#4

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

George Hurlburt

I have had the drill bit body separate from the Morse taper itself. Check for that, it can get kinda of hairy if it happens.

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

#5

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

John Lucas

I don't know what your thread pitch is but the 199 is a flat cutter and will probably simply give you a round shaft instead of a thread pitch unless your threaded rod is maybe 8tpi our coarser. I'm guessing here. In theory that would give you a square shoulder thread but the pitch would have to course enough so each revolution wouldn't cut into the last one which I think is what would happen with a 16TPI thread.

Ideally you a 60 degree V cutter. They aren't inexpensive but will last a very long time. www.bestwoodtools.com sells them in 3/4 and 1/4" sizes.

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

#6

Aage Rendalen

Dremel 199 is a flat cutter but it works

Aage Rendalen

John, you're right, the Dremel 199 gives you flat thread, but on 10 tpi it works. I'm basically copying a design by a Richmond club member, Bruce Robbins, who demoed the jig last month. He even used it to cut double entry thread. Still, I may by and by buy the more conventional cutter. At this point, I just wanted to try out the set-up.

Instead of investing in a $90 collet assembly which I won't be using except for holding a thread cutter, I took the chance of ordering a screw-on jacobs chuck from Penn State (and an adapter from 1 1/4 to 1")--all of it at about $50.

Re: Wobbly Jacobs chuck: chuck or spindle?

#7

Re: Dremel 199 is a flat cutter but it works

John Lucas

I use an inexpensive #2 morse taper collet in the headstock to hold the cutters. I make a draw bar for it to keep it in place. You can buy the #2 morse taper collets very inexpensively in a lot of different sizes.

Glad to know it works with 10 TPI. I didn't do the math so was guessing at 8TPI