I have been reading all the good reviews about the Hunter tools and like the idea of a replaceable TC cutter. But am unsure what the first tool should be.
I mainly turn bowls, some hollow forms and thinking about some boxes.
Initially, was thinking I would order the Osprey #2, does this make sense?
The two tools I use the most are the Osprey #2 and the Hunter #5.
The Osprey is good for just about anything you would do with a bowl gouge. It's not as quick for roughing out a bowl but pretty darn good if you use it like a scraper. Then do your finishing cuts with the nose just like a bowl gouge.
Because of the tilted tip on the Osprey it's not as good for finishing the bottom of boxes. Same reason you can't do that with a bowl gouge. Well OK you actually can using it in scraping mode and it leaves a decent finish. However if you want a really really good finish use the #5 to finish the bottom. It will let you rub the bevel on a deep square sided box and get an extremely good finish. I then use that same tool to shear scrape the sides or if it's not too deep use the Osprey in a push cut down the sides for a cleaner finish.
It's a 3/8" cutter. I use it for boxes that aren't much over 1 1/2 at the bottom and about 2" deep. It could go deeper easily. In fact I use the #4 for many of these and it's a larger cutter, I believe 1/2" I don't see why I couldn't finish the bottom of a 1" box using the #5. Probably the better choice for really narrow boxes would be the #1 straight tool. It used to come with the ornament hollowing set. I don't remember if it's sold separately but it's a great tool.
The only thing I might add to what John said is that if you do a lot of undercutting you might like to use the #5 Hunter Swan Neck. It, like the #5 straight tool has a 5/8" shaft that tapers down in the last 3 inches to a 3/8" cutter. It is a wonderful tool that I use for undercutting my squat hollow form type boxes, ginger jars and smaller hollow forms. I have been able to use that tool on boxes down to about 2" in diameter. Below that size I switch to the #1 tapered set.
I love Hunter tools and about all I can say is that they love and respond well to hard and dense woods. They can cut any wood but the finish you can get off the tool on hard maple, cocobolo, kingwood, ebony, blackwood, tulipwood etc. is so smooth that sanding if required will be started at a much higher grit than which you are normally accustomed. The carbide cutter also responds better for me at higher RPM's but everyone should turn at speeds where they feels safe and in control.
There is a learning curve associated with these tools. They have a very small bevel on the carbide cutter and learning to find and ride that bevel takes a bit of practice. Take care of the cutters and they will last a long, long time.
"There is a learning curve associated with these tools. They have a very small bevel on the carbide cutter and learning to find and ride that bevel takes a bit of practice. Take care of the cutters and they will last a long, long time."
+1 on learning curve. Never used Hunter tools until I used the #1 cutter that comes as an option with the Carter Hollow Roller system. First tried it to make a few clean up passes on a soft poplar vase I was doing. Put a little pressure on the hollowing bar and thought I was going to plunge right through the side wall. Boy does that little bugger cut!
David, one of my first gripes to Mike Hunter was that his cutters when cutting did not give a telltale warning when getting thin while hollowing like a traditional scraper. Until I learned to pay closer attention I unfortunately turned a number of items with the inside and outside diameters equal.
The small #1 cutter is particularly bad about running through the side. The cutting action is both effortless because of the small diameter and the cutter's sharpness and mesmerizing because of the ease in which wood is removed.
There is a learning curve and many people have some difficulty making the adjustment from scraping action to cutting action.
All you have to do is rotate the tool. I start at the middle of the bottom and cut out toward the left with a bevel rubbing cut and the cutter at about 45 degrees or even steeper. As I approach the side of the box I rotate the cutter further so it's almost vertical. This way you can make a square corner if you want. It's not dependant on the radius of the cutter. Then I keep it in this position and shear scrape up the side of the box.
With the handle parallel to the side and the cutter facing the side you are scraping with the 6 oclock bottom portion of the cutter. If you move the handle to a slight angle to the side (moving it to the right) the cut moves from the 6 oclock position to about 7 or 7:30 on the cutter. This becomes a shear scrape and cleans up the inside very nicely.
If you need an even cleaner cut use the Osprey and start the cut at the lip and do a push cut down the box. Of it's a closed in box like Mike Stafford does the #5 curved tool in a pull cut will clean it up very nicely.
I use the Hunter tools for boxes more than any other tool. I dont use them for bowls as much simply because I learned with the bowl gouge and I'm very comfortable with it. For me it's just too comfortable but I do use the Hunter tools whenever I need a cleaner cut. That 27 degree edge just flat out cuts cleaner.
It might take a while. I may get brave and try a video which will take a lot longer to edit and download. We'll see what I feel like when I get to the shop. It's a bit chilly out there.
put this together in a hurry because I promised Lucy we would go Christmas shopping.
The first photo is a bevel rubbing cut with the cutter at about 45 degrees. We'll call that open.
The second photo is where I close the cutter by rotating it almost vertical. This lets the tool cut the bottom but starts a shear scrape on the corner
Next is scraping on the side. It this position the tool is scraping with the 6 oclock portion of the tool and is a scrape similar to using a skew on it's side. Pretty clean but not as clean as it could be.
In this shot I pulled the handle away from me which rotates the cutter so it's shear scraping at about 7:30 on the clock or up the side. This is a pretty good cut. This box is lousy wood with work pockets and a knot and it still cut pretty good.
Sorry I didn't have time for a video but I would have needed lights and a sound system and mikes and I just don't have the time right now.
Thanks, John. You truly excel at instruction on your photos and videos. When I teach students and they ask me about YouTube videos, you and Reed Gray are on the top of that recommended list.
That's a lot of twisting, rotation, and handle movement to make those cuts. I prefer an offset square end scraper. The length of the side grind on that scraper gives me a gage to cut vertical walls on the box. It also allows a fine radius in the corner. I know you hurried the box, but it shows what can happen with the #5 in the transition in the bottom corner. You can see a slight undercut where you moved the handle over, or maybe rotated the handle. I have the #5, but only use it to turn diamond wood necklace pendants.
Well there are a lot of way to turn a box. No one would notice that little dip at the bottom it only shows up when you cut a box apart. I used scrapers for years and even have one of those scraper tool rests for doing boxes. However I always had to sand and sand with 220 grit to get a nice finish. With the Hunter tool on exotic woods I can usually just touch it up with 400 or 600 grit. On crappy woods like this one I do have to start with 220 but it just takes a touch.
As far as rotation of the tool goes I rotate all of my tools constantly for better cuts. It's a subtle thing but makes a lot of difference. I finish off the inside of bowls using my bowl gouge. I start with the flute up similar to a cut that David Ellsworth uses. As I go down the bowl I rotate the tool to about 45 degrees. Depending on the shape of the bowl I may rotate the flute back up a little to keep the bevel rubbing across that transition area. Then as I get close to the middle I rotate the flute to the right so the cutting edge is vertical. This way it simply stops cutting when you hit dead center and won't give you that little dip that can easily occur with the flute facing more up.
I have been away from WoodCentral for a while now, having sold all my tools a while back (not that I ever was much of a contributor - more of a reader). But I have come to the point where I miss turning very much, and I am looking to move back into it. Part of that process is returning to WoodCentral, and in doing so, looking for familiar names that I have known to be helpful and knowledgeable - among those being John Lucas. And this thread has significantly reinforced my own thought processes as to the tools that I need to be purchasing - I have had Hunter tools in the past, and loved them, and I find this box example/tutorial to be very helpful. Thanks - and Merry Christmas !
I don't think Dick is interested in learning about these tools. He has his ways of doing things and he is satisfied with that. And that is okay.
I still use a square scraper to cut square corners in my boxes. I have a couple of different square scrapers that I have relieved along the left side and then I sharpen the the left corner at the end to be longer so that only a small portion of the edge actually comes in contact with the wood.
Like John, I don't think anything cuts end grain cleaner in the dense exotics than these carbide cutters. I do most of the hollowing and all of the finish cuts with Hunter tools on my boxes with curved interiors.