Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Woodriver Turning Tools

Posts

Woodriver Turning Tools

#1

JL

Woodriver Turning Tools

JL

Was thinking about getting these for my B-I-L.

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/145913/WoodRiver-High-Speed-Steel-Beginner's-Turning-Set-5-piece.aspx

He is inheriting his father in law's lathe (and drill press).

But the turning tools leave much to be desired.

Thoughts?

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#2

I still dislike beginning with a "Set"..

JamieDonaldson

...of tools like this, as several are not what would be most useful for a beginner. Buy less expensive individual tools and practice grinding on them, then specific better quality tools can be rotated into the collection as needed.

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#3

Re: I still dislike beginning with a "Set"..

Donna Banfield

I'm with Jamie. Sets seem like a good deal but rarely are. They often have at least two tools that, after some experience, you would never, ever, buy (which might explain why they keep showing up in sets).

Starting out, a 3/4" SPINDLE rouging gouge, a 3/8 spindle gouge and 1/2" bowl gouge will be a better investment. Throw in a turning class -- any class when starting out will be a benefit - and you'll have helped a new woodturner more than you can imagine.

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#4

JL

Opinions about Woodriver?

JL

As turning tools that is.

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#5

Re: Opinions about Woodriver?

darrin hill

don't like them.. they're a store brand… cheap.. not as well made as others…

far better than harbor freight though..

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#6

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

Bill Jacksonville, NC

The 8pc red handle woodturning set #61794 from Harbor Freight for $80, less with coupon a better value over $120 Woodriver toolset at Woodcraft.

HF's red handle tool set gets higher marks than Woodriver on message boards.

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#7

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

Mike Potts

For what it worth, I'm a fairly new wood turner, just a little over a year. I started out with a set of tools, "Benny's Best" there was 8 tools in the set. A couple I never have used. But being new I didn't know what direction I would take once I started turning, so a set made sense. From looking at the link the set your looking at is a much higher quality than what I started with. One thing you didn't say and nobody has asked, what size and make of lathe will he be getting. If it's a midi or full size lathe these tools would seem to be a good starting point. If it's a mini (small) lathe well you might what to look in a different direction. I have since bought high quality tools that fit the style and type of turning I like. but I don't regret the the set.

keep it safe

Mike

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#8

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

Cyril Griesbach

I'm also not a fan of "sets" for the reasons already given. That being said it's not unreasonable for a beginner to start with the less expensive tools such as harbor freight, Ben's Best or the Wood River because one needs to learn to sharpen them as well. Sharpening being a skill that must go hand in hand with learning to turn, the new turner doesn't grind up expensive tools learning this skill.

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#9

WoodRiver NO NO

Don Evans

Anything that is made to cut and has the brand Woodriver on it is NOT worth bring home!

I have given them a try on a couple of things: Router bits, full set of Forstner bits and cannot remember the others -- BUT they all went back for a refund.

I will not waste my time with anything from Woodcrafts Brand namely WoodRiver.

It was really unbelieveable how bad the forstner bits were with pits in the cutting edges.

Guy at store said I needed to sharpen them!! I told him that wasn't going to happen and he could spend his time doing it. Understand I'm talking about bits that had NOT been used.

The other thing that needs to be considered with the limited information we have on this is are you sure your BIL will even like turning?

Search out a club before expense of lessons and there should be someone in the club who will work some with him and let him learn some before a lot of expense.

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#10

Jim Evans

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

Jim Evans

I started out with single tools from Penn State and found their natural colored handles to be higher quality than the red handled ones.

I had a cheap skew that came with my lathe but was scared to death to use it. After taking a hands on class with Alan Lacer I have now upgraded my skew and use it all the time.

Re: Woodriver Turning Tools

#11

The other view

Bill Howatt

The tools referenced seem to be a bit on the small side.

As far as sets go, you must see what is included and at what price. I started with a set and have used every tool in it from the parting tool to the round nose scraper, the bowl gouge and the spindle gouge and even the roughing gouge and skew.

IMO, there is not really all that much to chose from in terms of the steel quality. You want HSS and the hardness varies little in this price range; often the difference is cosmetic or more importantly, the overall length.

While they certainly don't compare to my Doug Thompson tools, Benjamin's Best along with some others in that price range work pretty good.

Bill