Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Round carbide insert source?

Posts

Round carbide insert source?

#1

Round carbide insert source?

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

I have an Eliminator (from Packard Woodworks and designed by a Seattle area turner) round carbide lathe tool.

I am looking for a reasonable source for replacement inserts. It is a 10mm (nominal 3/8 ths inch) sized insert.

Any suppliers you all know?

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Round carbide insert source?

Lyle Jamieson

Mike Hunter, if you want to continue with the best Nanograin carbide.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#3

Be aware that the Hunter tips........

JamieDonaldson

...are real cutters, not scrapers like most other brands. Hunter tools are a cut above scrapers! ;)

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#4

Re: Be aware that the Hunter tips........

John Lucas

The eliminator and hunter tools work in similar fashions. The eliminator has 3 sides to the shank which helps get the tool in a shear cutting angle. The hunter tool shanks are round ( except the Hercules). The round shank lets me rotate the cutting edge to the angle that I prefer which is really helpful when turning the inside of boxes

The Herculese and osprey tools have the cutter tilted forward so it can be used like you would use a scraper but it will cut cleaner

Mike hunter was a carbide salesman before be retired and his cutters are made from a carbide material that he designed so other cutters only look similar

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#5

Re: Be aware that the Hunter tips........

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

The Hunters were introduced in 2006, I believe. On this and several other turning sites many of us have tried to get cheaper substitutes. After hundreds of attempts, I have yet to see a substitute. Pay the price, don't waste your time looking, keep on turning!

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#6

Problem With Hunter

Stuart Johnson

No, I don't have a problem but have a sobering question. Mike is retired, that makes me think he's at least 55. What happens in 20 or years when he stops production? Should I stockpile cutters or let my heirs worry about it?

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#7

I sent Mike an e-mail so he could answer


Re: Round carbide insert source?

#9

No, these are scrapers ONLY

GaryG in MD

These cutters are flat, like washers.

Mike Hunters CUTTERS are shaped like a shallow coffee cup.

The fact that they are both made of a carbide material is irrelevant. ...GG

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#10

Re: No, these are scrapers ONLY

Josh Bowman

I ride the bevel with the Capt. Eddie's and the Hunter. John Lucas showed me. The finish is like glass. However, I'm not certain what the elimator is.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#11

Steven Antonucci

Capt Eddie is recovering from serious medical issu


Re: Round carbide insert source?

#12

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Problem With Hunter

Lyle Jamieson

Mike is a master marketer. He has a wide distribution network all over the world. His tools will be around if he exits stage right. It is a sobering thought but I would have to guess all of us have done succession planning to keep our business going for our heirs.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Re: No, these are scrapers ONLY

Lyle Jamieson

The original Eliminator tools used Nanograin cutters. People use carbide cutters in scraping mode as well as with bevel supported slicing cutting mode. The difference is not how they are used. The difference is the size of the carbide particulate used in the manufacture of the tools. The shape of the tools are different too as the old carbide is usually flat and the nanograin cutters are slightly cupped. Another way to tell them apart is the surface of the old carbide is dull or satin, where the new Nanagrain carbide cutters have a shinny chrome like shine on them. They are manufactured under high heat and high pressure to be razor sharp. They leave a much cleaner surface on the wood and that helps reduce sanding.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#14

Re: No, these are scrapers ONLY

Ron Bauer

I use these. Shiny, present a cutting edge, not a flat surface. I do not know about the nano grain metallurgy. The drawing does not accurately show the cutting edge profile.

http://www.carbidedepot.com/detail.aspx?ID=151057.

This link may not be hot, you might have to paste it to your browser. Ron.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#15

Mike Hunter

Re: Problem With Hunter

Mike Hunter

Lyle's earlier response indicates that well run companies document succession planning in their annual business plan. The Hunter Tool Company is no exception and has provided for future continuity.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#16

Mike Stafford

Hunter Tools

Mike Stafford

It is no secret that I am friends with Mike Hunter but I have no financial involvement in his company. I also have been using Mike's tools for almost as long as they have been available. I have virtually every tool he makes in my arsenal. He will also tell you I have been critical of some of his designs as I don't hesitate to criticize his product to make it better.

I use his tools a lot. Not for every job because in some instances the size of the cutters slow down the wood removal process. But when it comes to finish cuts and hollowing it is hard to get a better finish than you get with a Hunter tool. This is particularly true with hard domestics and exotics which yield near polished surfaces when cut by a sharp Hunter tool. No one likes sanding and Hunter tools help reduce sanding.

I used the Hunter tools in all of my classes and allowed my students to use all of my tools for everything from roughing burly, gnarly blanks to fine cuts inside hollow globe ornaments. The Osprey tools are some of the finest spindle tools I have ever used and leave a near burnished finish on small icicles, finials, drops etc.

The cutters last a long, long time particularly if you take care of them. Don't bump the rather brittle carbide cutters against each other or you will get chips in the edges. I always cover the cutters with an appropriately sized section of polypropylene tubing from the hardware store. This protects the cutters and me from getting cut which you can easily do if you carelessly run your hand over these razor sharp carbide edges.

The #5 straight and swan neck tools are my favorites for hollow boxes, deep vases and medium sized hollow forms. Their tapered design allows extended reach into turnings and over the tool rest. Likewise the tapered #1 set are useful tools for smaller boxes, ort bowls, hollow globes and Christmas ornaments.

They are relatively easy to learn to use and like any tool practice makes perfect. On the 2011 Woodturning Cruise we had literally hundreds of first time users try out the tools and in a matter of minutes they were able to use them successfully. We were able to sell a lot of tools and in fact sold out of several models.

The cutter on a Hunter tool cuts better and lasts longer than any carbide tool I have used. The finish off the tool is like what you would get from a sharp skew.

I use Hunter tools every time I turn these days and continue to find more and better ways to improve my turnings with them.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#17

Lyle Jamieson

ditto with my hollowing system


Re: Round carbide insert source?

#18

Is this reasonable?

mjonesrdg

http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/bcl/52/7/Eliminator-Hand-Tools

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#19

Re: Is this reasonable?

John Lucas

That's seems to be the going rate. The Hunter cutters run about the same thing.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#20

You sure this isn't an advertisement?

Dick Coers

I'm glad you like Hunter Tools Mike. I have a few, but have mixed feelings about a couple of them. Some haven't been out of the drawer in 6 months. I would also like guys that give these kinds of testimonials, with disclaimers to fiscal connections to the companies, also mention if they paid retail for their tools. I worked for a woodworking magazine, and know how tool companies "work" with the writers if given a chance. I also know a turner that got a bucket full of free tools, and they instantly became his "favorite and recommended" tools. Please note that I appreciate people sharing what works for them since it's hard to make a good judgement on so many internet reviews. Hopefully no hard feelings, I just like to see full disclosure.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#21

20 years from now I won't care..

Stuart Johnson

But would like to see the new Hunter Atom Spliter.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#22

Hunter & Eliminator cutters: Interchangeable??


Re: Round carbide insert source?

#23

Re: Hunter & Eliminator cutters: Interchangeable??

John Lucas

I can't say. I it would depend on 3 things. The size of the cutter, the size of the screw that holds cutter, and how the cutter sits in the slot where it goes. The Hunter cutters require a special screw that has a taper that matches the taper on the cutter. If these two mate properly they lock the cutter very securely. If not you can crack the cutter. I do not know how the eliminator cutter goes on. I've held one and used it to cut but never measured the cutter or the screw.

Re: Round carbide insert source?

#24

Re: You sure this isn't an advertisement?

John Lucas

Dick I hear you. As a frequent demonstrator I do get tools from time to time from various vendors to try out. Can't say about the others but I will not report on or say bad things about tools I don't like. I will report honestly about tools I do like. I have purchased quite a few tools from the same vendors who have given me tools. It's simply because I like their tools and use them frequently.

Like Mike I don't use the Hunter tools for everything. Mostly because I learned on the bowl gouge and I'm pretty darn good with it. Consequently I do most of my turning. However I do use the Hunter tools for a lot of my finish work because they leave such a fine finish. As Mike also said I am rapidly becoming a fan of the Hunter Osprey. That is a fine tools for all finish cuts and for lots of spindle cuts.