Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Off center or multi-axis

Posts

Off center or multi-axis

#1

Joe Bradshaw

Off center or multi-axis

Joe Bradshaw

My girlfriend and I were discussing the differences between off center and multi-axis turning. We were trying to come up with a definition of the two. I told her that I was going to ask the experts at Wood Central.

Joe

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Brad Vietje

Interesting question. I've used the terms interchangeably, but maybe they are different?

I'm wondering how to differentiate between offset turnings in which both axes are shifted the same amount in the same direction (think oval like hammer handle), versus those with one axis shifted (?) Then there are the oval turnings mounted in a drum or cylinder configuration to turn many pieces at once, etc...

If held between centers, I suppose you could make the case that a turning is never off center, just placed on a different center, since it still rotates around a center... Interested to see what others come up with.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#3

Therming

John Lucas

When the objects are turned off center by placing them on a carriage. Not sue how that differs from say, Inside out turning where you are basically turning 4 or more off center turnings at once.

My split turnings are really two pieces mounted off center.

I think Off center, multiple center, off axis, are all somewhat interchangeable.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#4

Re: Therming

Craig Daymon

Just to add to the discussion, inside-out might be considered one form of split turning, though a paper glue joint is rarely used to do it.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#5

I use a paper joint on almost all of mine

John Lucas

It holds the wood together much tighter for the first turning. On some projects I can use things like hose clamps, strapping tape, or CA glue on the ends but I find the paper holds the joints so much tighter.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#6

Ken Vaughan

Re: Off center or multi-axis

ken vaughan

Off Center -- in more classic turning sense; is illustrated on the cover of Keith Rowley's book Woodturning Projects. The illustration is of a plate turned with 7 different centers. One for the plate and 6 for recesses to hold 6 egg cups. All these centers are in relationship to the headstock.

All the axis of the turning are parallel, but individually are headstock to tailstock in the same orientation.

I put the pendant jigs, blocks sliding between jaws, multi-screw-chuck-holes approach (Arnull) . Ransom jigs, the off-center jigs such as the one sold by PSI into this bucket. Lattice top boxes (Hans Weissflog and Hans Finsterwalder).

Then --

Multi Axis describes a turning where through a variety of methods turnings operations are manipulated to use multiple axis that are not parallel. These can be the classic change the tailstock for a screwdriver or hammer handle, to some produced with some fancy iron that lets the turner change angles.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#7

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Barbara Dill

This is a great discussion. I've been focused on this area of turning since 2006. So far there is really no agreement on how to define these terms.

I think that multi axis, eccentric turning, off center turning are referring to the same idea, which is using more than one axis while turning an object, whether it be face plate turning or spindle turning.

The only 2 ways that a new axis can be made RELATIVE TO THE CENTER AXIS, is either parallel or not parallel.

I define an inside out turning as a split turning that has been glued together. A split turning is 2 or more pieces of wood attached and turned between the headstock and the tail stock. A thermed turning differs from a split turning in that no part of the pieces of wood being turned contacts the center axis of the lathe.

Comments???

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#8

Re: Off center or multi-axis

John Lucas

Just as a mild reference. I view inside out turning as an offcenter turning. I haven't tried off axis with inside out turning yet although I have turned handles for boxes. These are turned as inside out turnings to get both sides of the handle. Then I mount each handle on center and turn tenons. So it's basically turned on 3 axis. 2 for the inside out turning and one for the tenons. I get 4 handles at once.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#9

Ellis Walentine

How about some visuals, John? 


Re: Off center or multi-axis

#10

Ken Vaughan

Re: MultiAxis Handles

ken vaughan

John - is the outcome a set of 4 handles that are approximately oval in shape??

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#11

You asked and you recieve

John Lucas

These were turned using the inside-out technique. 4 square blocks about 7" long were clamped together on the ends. I rotated the wood 4 times instead of just twice as in the typical inside-out technique. Rotating it 4 times gave me the basic handle. Then I took each individual block that still had the square ends, mounted it between centers and turned a tenon on each end. This particular one was used as a handle for my son's combination drafting table and a box for the drafting tools. It has that soft rubber healable top which is the green stuff you see.

This came about after noticing that I could rotate the blocks more than twice and produce 4 identical turnings. I turned tenons on the ends and used them to support 2 other turnings. I left the insideout spindles loose so you could rotate them. I may have a demo piece I did to illustrate this technique. I'm headed to the shop in a few minutes and will look in my demo box to see if I still have the sample piece.


Re: Off center or multi-axis

#12

4 identical turnings

John Lucas

This is what I was talking about above. Glue or clamp 4 square blocks together. Turn the concave profile. Rotate the blocks 180 degrees and turn the convex profile. then turn the blocks 90 degrees and turn one of the sides. Turn 180 degrees and turn the other side. You get 4 curves to each piece but all 4 pieces are identical. Then mount the each block individually between centers and turn a tenon on each end.

This allows you to have 4 identical spindles to put between turning to elevate them or to add something (such as an hourglass) inbetween. I think you can imagine how hard it would be to turn 4 identical turnings individually that can be placed this close together and not show flaws.

On the left they are rotated out, the middle is rotated in, and the right side has 2 rotated in and two out. Have fun with this process. I don't think I can find any photos of finished pieces using this technique. Lost to many of them when i moved off my work computer.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#13

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Barbara Dill

John, I agree that split and thermed turnings are all multi axis turnings. And they are all arc type turnings with parallel axes as long as the glued up spindles are centered on the lathe.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#14

Re: Off center or multi-axis

John Lucas

Wow another option. Therming with multi axis on the holding carriage. Too many options here to even begin to fathom. My head hurts just thinking about it. That may add a 5th column to your multi axis handout. :)

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#15

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Barbara Dill

That gives me a headache. I've seen Mark do it using 2 rectangular pieces glued together and using twisted axes along the glue joint. I've tried to play with this idea and all I got was a brain cramp:)))

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#16

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Craig Daymon

Might talk to Neil Scobie as well. I'm pretty sure he's done this sort of thing. His Squibs come to mind as something similar.

Personally, I find the usual 4 piece inside-out rather boring and more of a novelty than generating anything worthwhile. It's only when it is taken a step or 2 further that it gets more interesting, like when Mike Kehs used 2 matched inside-out turnings to create asymmetrical negative images. I've also had some ideas of doing inside-out turnings with 16 pieces, rather than 4, to generate somewhat asymmetrical negative images, for example, a face with one eye winking.

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Keith Tompkins

This is a piece I did a while back...if you look closely, you will see the classic offcenter technique used to form a club foot has been incorporated, plus a different center for the foot. I turn a cube during some of my demos using three different centers, which initially seems impossible. A teaser: I have figured out how to turn on two completely different centers at the same time :D

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#18

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Barbara Dill

I want to be a fly on the wall!!

Re: Off center or multi-axis

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Off center or multi-axis

Keith Tompkins

OK Barbara, but you'll need a very tiny lathe :D thanks!