Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Soft maple burl urn

Posts

Soft maple burl urn

#1

Soft maple burl urn

Dick Coers

Had to take a break from the holiday production to do an urn. Sad for their family, and I thought about that all the time I was turning. Her best friend commissioned the piece. Sure wished I had made the neck shorter, but it's only 1/4" tall. Looks like a half inch in the picture! I think I'm going to make a new lid with a recess in it to take it closer to the body of the vessel. Luckily I picked up several PVC fittings for future work, so don't have to make a special trip for a $0.97 fitting. Only one coat of oil on the piece so far, but I get excited when I get to pop the color and figure on a piece like this. 7 1/4" diameter, 11" tall. Critique and comments welcomed.


Re: Soft maple burl urn

#2

Re: Soft maple burl urn

Mike Potts

very nice work, Dick

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#3

with the new lid

Dick Coers

I like this better, but the lid is a little thick. Had to be to take the 3/16" recess, but it's better than the long neck in my opinion.


Re: Soft maple burl urn

#4

Re: Soft maple burl urn

Phillip Medghalchi

Dic, its very beautiful. I think you are fine the way you designed this. the beauty of the figures ans the spots int he maple takes your eye away form any distractions form the lid. It is very well done. Thanks for sharing it. I wish you could have and instruction as how you do it or even just the top with the pvc fitting or did you have one before?

I am sure this lady wold be very proud to present this to her friend. Very well done.

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#5

Re: with the new lid

Don in Central Illinois

I agree. I like the second lid better. Grest job.

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#6

Re: with the new lid

Phillip Medghalchi

Dick, this one makes it look little top heavy. Could you maybe go little deeper the tenon on the first lid to make it sit deeper. the curvature on second lid breaks the continuity of the main vessel. Hopefully I explained it right?

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#7

Re: with the new lid

Barry Irby

The second one is a big improvement over the first.

The Urn is beautiful and very well executed. My opinion is that the lid, both of them, are a little jarring. Too stark a contrast. How about a very simple lid like the one on a ginger jar, made of the same wood as the urn?

(I really should stay out of this)

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#8

Re: with the new lid

Dick Coers

I've beaten myself up over that lid all afternoon. I thought about taking the top nub off, trying cherry, hoping to match some other soft maple, etc..... The customer replied with "gorgeous" when I sent her a picture, so I'm going to let it go. I still think if it was much thinner, with no or a very short neck, it would be fine in walnut. I guess my next study will be on urn lids.

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: with the new lid

Brad Vietje

Beautiful job -- very pleasing shape and I like the 2nd lid better. Anyone would be pleased with such a fine tribute to a loved one.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#10

Re: with the new lid

Phillip Medghalchi

Dic, I think only a turner like you will fuss over that lid, I thought evrry thing was fine. Like you said you beat your self to death.

it kept you busy in the shop, but I think you would have been better off turning another urn for someone else with your time. this one was beautiful as it was and you got the right feed back from your customer. We all thought so, too.

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#11

Re: with the new lid

Barry Irby

I beat myself up over my own work much worse than other people. In this case I might have taken the top knot off and lowered the profile of the lid and reduced the neck, just as you said, but if the customer liked it, let it go. It is beautiful and there is always next time.

Re: Soft maple burl urn

#12

Re: with the new lid

Phillip Medghalchi

Dic, now you have picture of both lids on your computer and you can print them and look at them side by side that way on the next project you can decide easier which way you like to design it. that way you finish your project faster.