Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Shipping Green Wood

Posts

Shipping Green Wood

#1

Brad Vietje

Shipping Green Wood

Brad Vietje

The recent post about tree diseases of Walnut, Chestnut & Elm trees (plus Ash, Beech, Hemlock etc...) reminds me of how quickly we can spread tree diseases by shipping green wood around the country -- or world.

With the Holiday season coming on, and the usual gift/wood exchanges being contemplated, I have a request of all the good folks here at WoodCentral:



Please do not ship green wood anywhere, ever.

Any wood shipped should be kiln dried, completely air-dried (over 1 year), boiled, fumigated, or otherwise treated to kill invasive pests and their eggs living within. Trees or logs cut a few months ago are NOT dry. Bowls roughed out 12+ months ago should be fine. Tree diseases spread best when we think least, so please think first, and please do NOT ship green wood anywhere, ever.

This is just a request from someone who cares; let your own conscience guide you.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#2

I agree 100%


Re: Shipping Green Wood

#3

Re: Shipping Green Wood

robo hippy

Aren't there some woods that are safe to ship green? Madrone and Myrtle I would think, and some of the maples at least....

robo hippy

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Brad Vietje

There probably are some -- maybe many. But by the time we find out there's a problem, it's too late -- the disease has spread like wildfire.

Emerald Ash Borer is a great example; it spreads about 20 miles per year if left to its own devices, but any one of us could spread it 3000 miles if we ship an infected piece from New England to Oregon.

I just don't think the benefits outweigh the risks -- just one man's opinion, and worth what you paid for it, but I hope we can set a good example and only ship dry or treated wood (even though turning green is very close to my heart!).

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#5

Thank you, Brad!

GaryG in MD

I'm with you all the way.

It's a matter of short-term gain for long-term devastation. ...GG

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#6

Re: Shipping Green Wood

sergio

In my experience air dried alone (without killing heat) is not sufficient. I turned a living creature in a piece of wood that has been air drying for more than a year and by the look and feel is seemed absolutely dry.

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Brad Vietje

Thanks for the head's up, Sergio.

I suspect a piece that was rough turned at least a year ago will be fine, but an uncured block of wood ? No Way. Good point.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#8

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Hugh Buttrum

Madrone, Bay, Oaks, etc. in California all get Sudden Oak - so I do not think I would ship them around green. The powder post beetle loves Bay wood - even dry.

Hugh

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#9

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Phillip Medghalchi

Dang, there goes all the good wood then. I was building my hopes, to get some wood from the friend I just met in person on my last trip to LA two weeks ago.

Now, all my hopes went out the window.

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#10

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Phillip Medghalchi

Ok, Brad, here is a qsn. for you.

i fyou get a piece of Ash form your general area that you knew it got hit with 1000 canker disease, so you bother turning it? waht ar ethe hazards for us turners coming in contact with these kind of issues? or yothink when you turn it then it's safe.

Then again waht do yo do with the shavings. do you burn them, if so what are the chances of spreading that disease back into your yard by the way of shavings?

or if we manage finishing it, then what are the chances for the buyer to spread that in the different environment?

Some of the turners buy exotic woods that are known to have allergic properties. should we worry about eh buyer showing reaction to the wood is yo finish it with wax that is going to wear ot eventually, therefore the wood be exposed?

sorry I did not bother to search on the form here. If you know antoher thread that this issue was discussed, please let me know.

Very much appreciate.

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#11

Re: Shipping Green Wood

john Veerkamp

The disease is spread by insects not by the wood itself. Kiln dried wood kills the insects and their eggs. I don't think that shavings from killed trees poses a risk, but maybe Dale or some of out other arborists can shed some light on the subject.

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#12

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Phillip Medghalchi

John, remember about a thread we had not to long ago that we discussed the walnut shavings and why it wouldn't be good for spreading around the flower garden. I think form that thread these qsn. came to mind. I may be wrong. I hope our friend Rob Wallace, who is scientist on plants can shed some lights on this one. He hasn't been on line for awhile.

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#13

Re: Shipping Green Wood

john Veerkamp

Walnut is a special case. It contains a toxin that inhibits other plant growth. It is mostly produced in the roots and released in the root zone of the tree. There is some debate on whether the shavings contain enough of the toxins to inhibit plant growth. I've used some in my garden without adverse effects. That being said, it doesn't cause a poison in the plants that do grow in the environment. The biggest warning from walnut is not to let horses around them.

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Brad Vietje

I agree. The issue in spreading diseases is that we will transport live larvae or viable eggs. There would be no problem with burning the wood, and the disease issue is entirely separate from allergic reactions. Walnut can hurt horses, but it's the presence of jugalones in the live roots that inhibit the growth of most other plants.

A diseased piece really ought to be bagged and then burned to contain and kill the live bugs, but boiling, fumigating, and other methods will kill the beasties. Pressure cooking would do it, too. A bowl that has been air dried for a year or so should not be a problem -- any bugs that survived the turning process would have exited stage left a long time ago. EAB produces neat little "D"-shaped holes, so if you see those, you are in trouble.

Someone brought up Powder Post Beetles, and I'm not sure these fall into the same category as infectious diseases that can wipe out an entire tree species. They could eat enough of your timber frame to wipe out your barn or house, but then again, so could termites. I'd quickly split and burn any infested wood, or fumigate an infested house to save it, though. If they are native to your region, then they will damage what they can get access to. If you ship PPB-infested wood to an area where these bugs don't live, and they escape alive, then bad on you!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#15

happened just this week

Ralph Lindberg

dry wood with live grubs :(

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#16

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Dale Bonertz

Wood can carry pests wet or dry. That is why some woods are required to be kilned dried to ship across lines. As a side note the wood should be kiln dried at 130 degrees for at least 24 hours to ensure all pests are dead.

Re: Shipping Green Wood

#17

Re: Shipping Green Wood

Hugh Buttrum

It has been a couple of days since I had time to visit this site. But in that time frame, I thought of another problem.....What about all the burl collectors/sellers? I know in Northern California - they go out and collect all the Madrone and California Bay burls they can and they ship them everywhere...both in country and out of the country. Then there are the Walnut burls - where they take down complete mature orchards and just take the burls and send them all over too.

What about the people who chip up trees and haul the chips across the state to burn in some power plant?

Just some thoughts I had is all.

Hugh