Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Activator musings

Posts

Activator musings

#1

Activator musings

John Lucas

As some of you probably know I use activator on my CA joints for my hand mirrors. The reason I do is it makes the joint brittle and I can break off my scrap wood mounting blanks without damaging the good mirror blanks. If I don't use accelorator it will almost always pull wood away from one of the blanks instead of breaking at the glue joint. That's why I know it works.

What I'm finding (except I don't know how to really test this) is that some activators seem to make the joint more brittle.

I was using insta-bond aerosol activator in my class this last weekend and several students had problems with the joint breaking and they weren't getting catches. I never had the problem at home using E-Z bond accelerator. I also have some Stick Fast activator and it seems to work similar to the E-Z bond.

Could it be the Aerosol or is the chemical makeup of that brand. I've also had bad CA cause the same kind of brittle joint but I know my CA was good because I had been using the same bottle just before leaving for the trip.

I can't think of a good way to test this theory without getting really complicated. I suppose some kind of swinging hammer so it would hit each piece with the same force. increase the height of the swing to increase the impact. Don't know if I'll actually do this but it's an interesting thought. There would probably be too many other variables such as the amount of glue applied, how flat the mating surfaces were, etc.

Re: Activator musings

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Activator musings

Lyle Jamieson

It could be just a single bad accelerator. For decades I have used CA (I don't use chucks) and only had one failure over all the years and a LOT of turning. It was at a class I was teaching at Arrowmont. We tested all the possible problems to find the cause of the failure and is was the accelerator. Got a new bottle of accelerator and no more failures, same brand just a new bottle. Could not tell you the brand but not the aerosol.

Re: Activator musings

#3

I believe your final statement is correct


Re: Activator musings

#4

Re: Activator musings

Phillip Medghalchi

John, for you to do the the same fair test you have to the same exact thing with the same wood material and same CA and different CA and different accelerator and God knows how many other variables. to get a reasonable answer.

If you have that kind of money let me know and I can set up a fun thing for you to do. I believe even the Mnfr.s wouldn't go to that length. I know for sure that I have bought different brands and I even mixed and matched accelerators and had different results.

I have had better luck with the green aerosol can (I can't remember the name), it's too cold to go to the shop, but if you need it I can get it for you tomorrow.

I like it over the sprayer, because you can give it little wisp and not worry about wasting that much or over spraying.

Re: Activator musings

#5

Re: Activator musings

John Lucas

INsta bond is the green aerosol can and that's the one that's giving me problems. I don't remember having problems when I used it before so it could be that particular can although it's fairly new.