Hey guys, I still haven't finished moving all my tools to the new house so I haven't posted in a while. I had to drop in though to let you all know about a treasure of tools going up for auction. Stuart Batty has done it again, he's going out of business and everything is being auctioned to the highest bidders, over 4 million in tools for making tools and I believe turning tools as well. Here's a link.
Bill looking at the catalogue is interesting. Nice to see the gear Stuart acquired but I think its out of my league. Wood turners don't have much use for that sort of gear.
Auction Highlights: Stuart Batty Enterprises, the designer and manufacturer of Stuart Batty premium woodturning tools and the Universal Grinding System (UGS), is closing its doors and selling its remaining office, video, recording, and manufacturing assets at auction. Auction Features Late Model CNC Equipment - Doosan Vertical Machining Centers - Doosan Lynx Turning Center - Danobat & ELB-Florida Surface Grinders - Mega Gundrill - Trumpf TruMark Laser Marker - Hyd-Mech S-20A Auto Band Saw - Trak CNC Lathe - Trak CNC Mill - Forklift - Misc. Machine Shop Equipment - Mac Pro Computers - Much More!
Categories: General Auctions, Industrial & Manufacturing, Miscellaneous, Office & Business Equipment
It is interesting what we will spend on a lathe compared to what we spend on tools. (individually, not as a whole.) I didn't realize they were still available. You would think the demand for tools like those would be higher.
On the auction site's main page about the auction, they list under "Misc. Machinery" a Baldor 8" Pedestal Grinder with BCN Diamond Wheels. I assume that is a misprint meaning CBN but I can't find a picture of that unit anywhere. Anyone else see it????
I t may be that the prices of the tools were too high for tuners to consider buying them. I looked at them at SWAT, they were out of my range. It is shame that he has to go under.
I LOVED the idea of the tools, HOWEVER, as I looked at them and watched him work them amd talk about them, it came clear to me that one had to make a MASSIVE commitment to the concept, not just an individual tool or two in order to really get the benefits of his concept.
I didn't win the lottery, so I couldn't afford to convert.
IMNSHO you have to offer a more entry level line along with maybe a mid level line all the way up to the high end of tools. You want to make yourself available to the masses. In addition, as a small business owner, when you get money into your business, you don't have pocket money, you have money to keep the doors open another day. You come last when you own a business & if you don't, you're doomed to fail.
One of his salesmen who didn't know me, made the comment that the Batty line of tools were the Rolls Royces of turning tools. I commented back that most of his market drove Chevy and Fords.
Reed made the Rolls Royce vs. Chevy/Ford comparison, and while true, last time I checked Rolls Royce was still a thriving company. Reed also has some pretty expensive lathes in his studio (I would know !) so he is well qualified to make that astute observation.
Stuart had a great line up, but was way over capitalized for the kind of sales the small, but avid woodturning community can support. A number of us in the woodturning tool business have been watching Stuart since he started this latest venture with interest. It was only through the patient backing of his generous and deep pocketed main investor that he was able to keep going as long as he did.
Stuart is a great turner and great teacher. His innovation knows no bounds. I think all of us wish him the best.
I've also looked on with keen interest to see if Stuart's innovation would be accepted by wood turners. Generally we are a pretty conservative lot with a fair bit of sentimental attachment to the tools we have acquired over a considerable period of time. We also tend to have more tool steel than we will ever wear out in our lifetime.
I guess many of us thought "do we really need a new range of space age SB Tools?" It is sad to see innovation both in tool making & marketing fall victim to an aggressive business model.
I am still confused by the fact that many of us will spend thousands on a lathe but compromise on turning tools. I personally use nothing but Glaser tools & can say, they did make a substantial difference in my skill level. So I do feel the expense is justified. What if you guys could get 90 days same as cash financing with no credit check, would that make the more expensive tools more appealing?
Curious about your statement that tools improved your skill level. Are you saying that setting down a Sorby, and picking up a Glaser increased your skills? Could you explain how that happened?
I recently got 5/8 inh spindle and 5/8 round bowl guge with a 12 and 20 inch handles from SB. The 5/8 round bowl gouge was absolutely fabulous out of the box but I could not replicate the geometry of the cutting edge with my tormek and this reduced the performance of the tool that remained very good. The spindle one if fantastic. Both have practically no vibrations in the worst conditions perhaps due to the "I" profile. I have 5/8 bowl gouges from different manufacturers and in difficult positions the vibration difference is quite evident perhaps due to the profile and the carbon handle material of the SB tool which is known to absorb vibrations while aluminum is terrible at that and steel a good compromise (see racing road bikes).
It is interesting to note that the price of the tools was not that different from that of orher manufacturers but you needed also the proprietary handle, which in my opinion is outstanding, but this might have made the price difference.
I'm no businessman, but feel that to enter in a relatively small market like woodturning one needs more than quality to succeed.
I would describe myself as frugal, or cheap. Now, don't get me wrong, but I will spend good money on good tools if they have an advantage over cheaper tools. Point in case, my two Robust lathes. As for Stuart's tools, I believe they are the same metal, V 10 that Doug Thompson uses, which is also the same steel that Glaser uses. Other than geometry, there is no difference or advantage. I don't use the two Glaser chisels I have. I don't like the geometry of the gouges, and I don't like the exceptionally heavy handles. My arms, would be worn out at the end of a day's worth of turning from the extra weight. No advantage. To dampen vibration, I keep the tool rest close. Personally, I think the shot filled handles are a passing fad. I did pick up one of Stuart's scrapers in Phoenix, and it, like the Glaser tools, is way too heavy for my taste. My favorite ones are 1 to 1 1/4 inch wide, and 3/8 inch thick. Stuart's was 2 inches wide. I can easily stall my Beauty, in low gear with my smaller scrapers. No advantage. Stuart has some great ideas, but in the end, you have to be able to sell what you make. The one product that Stuart made that I would love to own, and has yet to see the market, is his Omni Grinder. For the price he told me it was going to sell for, it would have been a great tool, though more for the industrial world and not the woodturner's world. He is a great turner and teacher, and even though we do things a lot differently, I respect that. He is not going to vanish.
Nice discussion, but I saw one thing. If you say you can stall an American Beauty, Brent will tell you that (and I think this what he said) is that your skills need improvement. LOL
I was talking to Bill Grumbine about it and he commented that he could stall a VB36. Maybe if I could put a 5 hp motor on my Beauty, I would have more of a problem. Mostly when roughing I use a scraper. I cut the wood as I want to cut it, which means a fair degree of brute strength, and a coarse surface. Once the shape is pretty much finalized, then I use nice clean finish cuts with a gouge. I can stall with gouges as well, but love scrapers for roughing, and shear scraping, but that is another story. Videos on You Tube, type in robo hippy. I do have the older Beauty with 3 speeds, and Brent had a different inverter, which I may have to add on to see if it supplies more torque. What it comes down to is how much metal can you stick into the wood at one time and not go airborn, this means the turner, not the wood.
The idea that V10 steelis always the same is wrong. The steel is the basic metal composition but then there is its treatment not to talk to the geometry of the cutting edge. I have V10 tools from three manufacturers, same gouge size, and I feel there are obvious differences in steel performances. I'm not talking about cutting geometry or vibration as mentioned in my previous post.
As far as handle goes I agree with you and believe that a heavy handle is a killer for the operator. A light handle, when not interfering with the cut is a saver. The SB handle are fantastic.