Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

discrimination

Posts

discrimination

#1

discrimination

Phillip Medghalchi

Today I had a very interesting conversation, about acceptance to another forum and the person I was talking to mentioned that he has heard and seen my postings on some other forums, including here. So I do not fit their criteria base on my interactions on this forum. when I asked the specifics, he could not answer it and he said that I write long posts and he mentioned since I am new, I shouldn't comment on other's turnings. I got the impression that since in my bio, I mentioned where I was born and my original nationality. He did not like to have someone like me on that forum. I mentioned that ones who know me in person can tell him who I am and what kind of interactions I have with other turners. My whole impression was that of more of discrimination than anything else. I thought that these forums are free from discrimination and specially if someone is new to this trade, but I found out otherwise. Like they want you to keep your mouth shut, because you just came into this. Have you ever felt this way when you were new to this trade, were you ever treated like you are new so you keep it quiet.

Re: discrimination

#2

Discrimination

Tom Colligan

So sorry to hear this, Phil. That seems like a real odd character, to say the least. I hope you don't let it get to you. I'd try to somehow relay your experience with him on that forum and let his colleagues see what a poor representative he is.

Re: discrimination

#3

Re: Discrimination

Phillip Medghalchi

Well, Tom he said he doesn't get paid to create or maintain the site and he is only doing it for his friends, and they will not tolerate my interactions on that site, so evidently he did not think I was worthy of the other turners company. Tom, I lived in US long enough to build a thick skin for this, but I thought to let new comers to this trade know that this is happening so they wouldn't get their feelings hurt and completely turn their back at this trade. After all there are lots of creative minds around that can create some outstanding forms of art that will need to get into this trade and take it to the next level.

Tom, I appreciate your offer, I'd rather that you do not mention anything to him. I have respect for elderly and I do not think that you can change his mind at his age. I am fine with all the friends I have made here and all they have ever offered to help me grow in my pursuit of this trade. This will not deter me from my goal. it was just awakening to be more careful around some people. I am hoping that when I see him at SWAT this year I can shake his hand and thank him for this experience. I think that he is a member here too.

Re: discrimination

#4

ebd

Re: discrimination

ebd

Wow!!! Who would have thought. I'm so sorry to hear this. Doesn't this guy realize that it's 2014 and there is no longer any room for that kind of nonsense?

Re: discrimination

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Easy solution......

Jesper, Denmark

Don't put up with it - leave that forum. There is no point initiating a discussion on the subject, as their minds are plainly already made up.

It needs to be said, that I have never experienced any discrimination here or on the now defunct Badger Pond. Differences of opinion, yes, but discrimination No.

Re: discrimination

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Easy solution......

Mike Stafford

Just because something is said by someone does not make it so...

Re: discrimination

#7

Mike Peace

Re: discrimination

Mike Peace

I am on several turning forums and fortunately I have not run into that forum. This is supposed to be a fun hobby so when you run into a group, whether a club or a forum, where your interactions with others is not fun, vote with your feet and don't look back. Keep it fun.

Re: discrimination

#8

Re: Easy solution......

Phillip Medghalchi

Jasper I can appreciate your input. That''s exactly what they want me to do. so, I guess not every one whose name is little different is welcomed at all times.

Re: discrimination

#9

Re: Easy solution......

Phillip Medghalchi

Mike, you are absolutely right. Look at the other forum and you tell me what you read the way they criticize my posting. There is an animosity that I do not understand how it has come about. Mike read the bellow excerpt form the email that was sent to me

" If you decide to study how others, particularly newcomers, conduct themselves and conform to the culture of the forums you are on, I will be happy to reconsider at a future time".

This was in writing, I can not write what was said on the phone.

Re: discrimination

#10

Re: discrimination

Phillip Medghalchi

I can appreciate that. I pray for those who feel it's OK to discriminate that they do not get treated that way. At end of the day, you have to answer your won conscious.

Re: discrimination

#11

Re: discrimination

Stuart Johnson

I am part of three turning groups, Wood Central, WoW and Segmented Turners. At no time have I seen any type of discrimination on these three based on race, religion, gendre or country of origin. I have seen discrimination when rules are regularly violated on WoW or when the poster regularly argues or challenges others.

This is the internet and many times items are posted in a hurry. They might be worded in a negative manner when the intent is make a statement and then taken way out of context. If you truly feel you are being discriminated by others you should take it up privately with the owner (Ellis, Herm or whoever). Trying to debate the issue especially on a different forum I don't feel is the correct way to resolve the issue.

Re: discrimination

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Easy solution......

Mike Stafford

I am sorry Phillip, you misunderstood my meaning. In your original statement you said, "I got the impression that since in my bio, I mentioned where I was born and my original nationality...My whole impression was that of more of discrimination than anything else."

That is your impression but is your impression based in fact?

Did the person you talked to and are now accusing of discrimination ever say anything about your ethnic origin? Did he somehow object to the fact that you are living in Texas? What exactly did he say that makes you think you are being discriminated against because of your nationality? I happen to know the individual you spoke to and there is no way that I believe that he said anything discriminatory with respect to your national origin. I think you may be the only one who is making an issue of your nationality.

I don't believe there was anything said that was discriminatory. I think he merely stated that he had seen posts of yours on Wood Central where you berated a sandpaper vendor at length and also posts on another forum where you decided to complain about the rules of that forum because you had difficulty registering and following the directions. I believe those are the references to your difficulties as a beginner.

The turning community is a rather small community, particularly the on line community is small, and some of us participate on multiple forums and see all that goes on.

I believe every operator of every forum has the right to decide who can participate. Administrators and moderators do not want to have their lives complicated by people who are difficult and do not follow the rules.

Re: discrimination

#13

Re: discrimination

Herman de Vries

Phillip. I was advised about this thread, and that you were quite obvious that you were referring to Wow when you "got the impression" it was being racist.

Since I have never spoken to you on the phone, you could not have been referring to me personally, but you made it sound that way, and people are inferring, from your comments, that you are talking about me. After reading your post I went to your profile on WoW, and that is the first time I realized where you are from. That has squat to do with how you are perceived, but your willingness to play a vicious race card over a perception leaves a bad taste.

I just want to set this record straight. I don't care if someone is from the moon - they are welcome on WoW and I'm sure they are welcome on Wood Central too. But if they troll for a flame war, as this has the potential to become - then they are not welcome anywhere.

Herm

Re: discrimination

#14

Re: discrimination

Phillip Medghalchi

Herman, there was no name calling or any names of any forum being mentioned.

you wrote, "Since I have never spoken to you on the phone, you could not have been referring to me personally, but you made it sound that way" how my posting here can be you?

We will discuss this in Your forum. This is in reference to some other site. As long as no rules are violated here. I like to leave it at that.

Re: discrimination

#15

Re: Easy solution......

Phillip Medghalchi

Mike, if you wish to know the details, you can call me.

Re: discrimination

#16

It's a free country.

Ray Carson-Lawrenville, NJ

.....last time I checked.

Re: discrimination

#17

Re: discrimination

Phillip Medghalchi

Please disregard this thread as it is creating controversy with other sites that are not even involved in this discussion. There was no names mentioned and it was a mere an observation that is being informed by some folks here to others that are not even in this discussion and thread is being attacked and threatened.

This is what it means to be a new comer.

Re: discrimination

#18

Re: It's a free country.

Phillip Medghalchi

You mean how, can you be specific, please? You mean treating people in this manner?

Re: discrimination

#19

Re: Easy solution......

Phillip Medghalchi

Mike that wasn't you on the phone, the details of the email was not to be brought up in this forum and I am not sure how you know the details unless it was passed on to you by other party, or you made that decision too. I did not insult the vendor here, just expressed how I was treated as point of business. So, that was resolved. That issue should not have any bearing in other forums. It was not discussed there. It sounds like country club that are exclusive of membership, so if the new member is not of certain status, they don't join.

Re: discrimination

#20

Re: discrimination

Herman de Vries

Phil, I said "people are inferring", and I am correct in that, since I was contacted by folks about your post. They thought you were talking about me. I know the truth, that I have never spoken to you. Regardless, your words are harming me, since people are assuming it is because you spoke of "doesn't get paid for making or administrating a site". Most people would infer that is WoW, and me.

Stop digging a hole for yourself, and tell them which site you are talking about.

Re: discrimination

#21

just my observation/opinion

Mike Potts

Dealing with people and dealing with wood have a lot in common. If you use a dull tool and push hard enough you will cause friction, under the right conditions this could even cause a fire. If you take that same tool and go against the grain it will cause tear out and a rough surface. Once you have created this rough surface it is very hard if not impossible to make it smooth again. There are times when you have cracks that it is much better to walk away, than to continue on and have the piece explode on you. Again this is just my observation and opinion.

Mike

Re: discrimination

#22

barry rockwell

Re: discrimination

Barry Rockwell

Phillip,

Your diatribe leaves me speechless. I would like to defend you but your numerous attacks and denunciation of others on this and other forums makes it impossible. Your claim of discrimination is probably prosecutable given the fact that you insinuated who the probable perpetrator is, and I would be willing to testify to that. I would suggest, publicly, that you back off, take a good look at what you're doing, and change your attitude. Nobody gives a husky f__ck what your nationality is, or where you where you were born. You are the only one who is making this a discriminatory issue!

Re: discrimination

#23

Re: It's a free country.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Not what I meant. My apologies for any misunderstanding. So sorry. I meant you shouldn't have to feel discrimated against. It's just wrong !

Re: discrimination

#24

Time to clear the air?

Geoff Whaling

Phillip,

To label the actions of one participant allegedly a member of a forum as "discriminatory" is perhaps a fair call. To advance that line of thought to include the forum and its members as actively discriminating against new members or against one member from one particular nationality is stretching it a bit.

In the circumstances I think most fair and reasonable people would draw the inference that you were writing about Herm and the WoW site. Your post above “he said he doesn't get paid to create or maintain the site and he is only doing it for his friends” and after you went and deleted your posts along with many others posts on WoW did not leave much to the imagination about which site and which person you were inferring.

I feel Herm & the members of WoW, who also happen to come from diverse back grounds and nationalities, are a very fair and tolerant group. I must admit I have found it difficult to follow your reasoning and purpose for many of your long posts on WoW (and other sites) but like most members I accept your desire to participate and extend to you the courtesy of having a fair say.

Perhaps it is time to sit back and have a think about your interactions with others on WoW and perhaps other forums.

If you are indeed writing about another forum please at least clarify the situation and offer to Herm an apology for the drama and hurt caused.

Re: discrimination

#25

Re: Time to clear the air?

Barry L Elder

I agree!