Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

comparing turning projects

Posts

comparing turning projects

#1

Dan Jechura

comparing turning projects

Dan Jechura

So last weekend I went to my 1st juried craft show to compare my work to someone else. I do not know if I am ready to sell at a juried show. Others say I am ready.

I saw two different turners there. One turned high gloss and thick ( 1/2 inch), did not finish the bottom and had missed a lot of run's and drips.Bowls where in the 8 to 12inch range Looked like he was selling well. Made every day bowls.

The other one turned green, dried the bowl in a microwave and did not turn again, looked ruff but oil finished. Did not finish the bottom. Turned a lot of natural edge bowls . Did not sell anything while I was there. Both have been turning for 6 some years.

My question is: Do you go to shows and compare your turnings to others. As a test to your ability. Not to cut the other turner down.

Re: comparing turning projects

#2

Steven Antonucci

yes...sort of?

Steven antonucci

Did the set my price right?

What is selling?

Am I out of my league?

Is the venue any good?

I'm not worried about the quality of my work anymore. I have questions about what marketing will get me in front of the right audience, and if I see bad work, it's usually a bad venue.

S

Re: comparing turning projects

#3

Re: comparing turning projects

robo hippy

The jury process is strange, and differs a lot from show to show. I have seen horrible stuff allowed, and great stuff rejected. I do visit other wood guys to check out and compare prices. I don't want to undersell any one, and if they are too cheap, I still keep my prices up to where I think they should be. Like the art of retail sales, jurying is an art to learn as well.

robo hippy

Re: comparing turning projects

#4

Re: comparing turning projects

John Lucas

I was a photographer for many years and helped many artists get into juried shows. I've also been a juror and did a few shows. You don't need to compare your work. It should be as high quality as you can make it. No sanding marks good quality finish and good shapes

The jury process is based purely on photographs. Jurors can't see small

Things like scratches and runs. They look at forms and things like fancy wood. N are in mind that they typically aren't woodworkers so look at your work as though a glass artist or jeweler or fiber artist would see it. Above all else use high quality photographs In some cases the juror may not be an artist at all. Simply someone who runs the show and is looking for work that they think will sell.

That's where comparisons come in. You aren't necessarily comparing your work to other turners. Every artist in the show is your competitor so to speak so you should be saying is my work good enough when compared to the other artists

It helps if the photos you send in show maturity as an artist. A sense of style and good form and hopefully fill a niche that will sell. Pick pieces that go together dont pick one candlestick one bowl and one hollow vessel. Pick a group that shows you understand form

So to answer your first question yes compare your work to other turners in the show it better be as good or better its a competitive world out there

Re: comparing turning projects

#5

barry rockwell

Re: comparing turning projects

Barry Rockwell

Dan, when you say they "didn't finish the bottom" what did you mean? Were the bottoms actually without a finish, or just had no detail? Just curious because I usually don't put a lot of detail on the bottoms of my bowls but they are finished exactly like the rest of the bowl.

Re: comparing turning projects

#6

Re: comparing turning projects

Ron Bauer

Dan, In my opinion the customer is the ultimate juror. It is they who will be comparing your presentations to all others. That being said John's comments on the jury process are what get you in front of prospective customers. I agree that you need to put out the best that you can. After that the pocket book gets all the votes regarding value. R.

Re: comparing turning projects

#7

Re: comparing turning projects

Ralph Lindberg

I don't do Juried Shows, well, most just 'cause.

Shiny sells, dull moves slower.

At a show, if a customer is looking at our stuff I explain why "this" piece is really shiny (it's made as a display piece) and "that" piece isn't (it's made to use).

A shiny high gloss Poly/Lacquer looks really good on the shelf, but using that piece nicks up the finish and it soon looks crappy. While a lower gloss oil/wax finish will retain it's look.

Last month I was at a mid-grade gallery and looked at the "shiny" wood bowls. The shop had put some salad (wood) serving tools in the bowls, and the finish was already marred simply by people handling the bowls with the tools in them.

On the other hand, at the last show we did we sold almost all our "shiny" display pieces and almost none of our "working" pieces. Well, except for rolling-pins, we sold all but one.

Re: comparing turning projects

#8

Re: comparing turning projects

Rum

Yes!

I don't sell anything but I especially like looking at work by turners that are better than me. Its pretty much always interesting to see what styles, forms and (where I can figure it out) techniques others use.

Its certainly helped me figure out some of the shortcomings in my finish and design processes and make nicer work.

Even when I think my work is "nicer" (subjective of course) there are often a bunch of things that are interesting to see how people do it differently.

Looking at prices is fun as well from an abstract interest in marketing techniques (and the application, misapplication or lack of application of them).

Re: comparing turning projects

#9

Re: comparing turning projects

Bill Jacksonville, NC

I have been both overwhelmed and underwhelmed at other people’s woodturnings at shows. Whether a show is juried or not never compare other peoples work or price with mine. So never discuss other people's work or price with customers or other turners while a show is in progress. I am there to sell my stuff and looking forward to a successful day!

Re: comparing turning projects

#10

Dan Jechura

Re: comparing turning projects

Dan Jechura

I'll get a couple of pictures of what I mean. They will be of my bowls.

Yes there was a finish but they had no detail.

dan

Re: comparing turning projects

#11

Re: comparing turning projects

Sergio

Yes I do shows and like interacting with people. Interactions is by itself a sort of comparison becouse people come and check what they like even if they do not buy them. Since before buying they browse around their reaction to my turnings is important. I also check other turners' work eventually present and talk to them. If I believe their price is too low I tell them, and their usual answer is: I'm here to sell I'm not a collector. I check their quality, there is always something to learn.

In the end what sell is what people like and perhaps need but unless of a quality far superior to those of the comptition priceing is an important factor in sales.

Re: comparing turning projects

#12

Re: comparing turning projects

Randy Johnson

Recently I had the chance to spend a little time in the most incredible craft/art venue I've ever been in. Tamarack, just off the West Virginia turnpike near Beckley.

There are well over 100 turnings of various quality. When I checked the prices on pieces I thought were comparable to what I make, the prices were three to four times more than I would have asked. Granted, there is a mark-up, but I doubt it is over 100%.

On at least one occasion the difference between what places like Tamarack can ask and what I can expect at small craft shows cost me a sale. I ran into a lady a few weeks after the show who had really liked a large spalted maple bowl I had. She told me that she had really wanted it, but knew it would be over $200.

I told her see should have looked at the bottom for the price or asked. It was one of my higher priced pieces but the price was $60. I even offered to unpack it and bring it to her in a few days but by then she was no longer interested.

Re: comparing turning projects

#13

Re: comparing turning projects

Don in Central Illinois

I visited Tamarack on the way to Virginia Beach earlier this year. Wonderful turnings. After seeing some of the work, finally decided to apply to a similar venue in my home state. Pricing sermed very fair for that venue.