Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Spindles and spindle display

Posts

Spindles and spindle display

#1

Steven Antonucci

Spindles and spindle display

steven antonucci

One thing leads to another...

Talking to a weaver about an inkle loom at Millbrook Days, and we get onto drop spindles. I showed her some tops I 'd made, and she calls another weaver over drooling at chatter work. I suggest that I could make spindles with chatter work...

Turns out she lives around the corner from me.

So I make a couple, open an Etsy store, fill a basket... need to find a better way to show them, since she talked me into showing them at the Jockey Hollow Weavers guild holiday fair. So I made this...


It's all cherry, but the flat parts were sawed in 1996 and have been in the shop for a long time. The upright is a cut-off from some firewood. Going to need to set it in the sunroom for a long time to tan up. The top is a loose tenon so that it spins.

Comments welcome.

Steve

Re: Spindles and spindle display

#2

nice, useful work!

GaryG in MD

And clearly fun. Good stuff. ...GG

Re: Spindles and spindle display

#3

Re: Spindles and spindle display

Rum

Nice looking stuff!

LOML does a lot of wool spinning so I've ended up making a small collection of drop and supported spindles for her (a few dozen of each, she mostly uses one of her wheels).

You might also consider adding some nostepinne (literally "nest stick", functionally a hand ball winder - google search will yield lots of examples but if you want measurements I can measure some I made when I get home) to your collection before the sale. They're quick and easy to make from scraps and they're really handy for spindle spinners. If you make some of these wind a little yarn on one or two so their use is obvious. Functionally there are a few things to note on these:

- make sure the yarn-winding section is nicely and evenly tapered and not to large.

- handle should be comfortable (especially consider that most women have somewhat smaller hands but a couple of sizes is nice)

- the groove by the handle and the groove by the tip are both useful for different winding techniques. I put in two grooves by the handle because it seems to make it easier to get the yarn "set" in them, but only one at the tip because otherwise it tends to catch more when you pull the ball off.

- bevel the end of the shaft so that the groove at the tip is definitely smaller than the rest of the shaft to make removing the yarn ball easier.

- these are most excellent skew practice.

A couple notes on spindle functionality from what I've found so far that might be useful (although it seems like a lot of spinners collect pretty spindles regardless of functionality so its a nice market to be in since it seems more or less unlimited if you get some regular clients :D).

- Balance is critical. I roll my spindles on a couple of beams and mark where they stop and then carefully sand a little off of the heavy spots then repeat until it doesn't have an obvious heavy side (roll three times marking the low spot and then adjust). Takes a few minutes per but really makes a difference - especially with top whorl spindles like you have there - bottom whorl are MUCH less fussy (and supported are a different beast altogether).

- Subtle differences in weight distribution can make a huge difference in how (and how well) they spin. More weight to the center = faster but shorter and more weight to the outside = slower but longer spin. For a given yarn and spinner there is an "optimal" (or approaching optimal") weight distribution to get what they want. Some spinners will adjust the speed of their draft (yarn feed speed) and others (most) prefer to adjust the speed of the wheel/spindle to get thicker/thinner or harder/softer twisted yarn. The ones in the latter case are nice because they can easily want a few dozen spindles for functional reasons :D

- Learn to spin a little, it makes designing them a lot easier and you can impress people (I was recently at the chinchero weaving cooperative in Peru and the gal was quite impressed that I could not only make yarn but fine thread like yarn at that - the fact it was top quality alpaca top made it a bit easier ;) )

If you find other practical feedback on making better spindles I'd love to hear it. My focus is mostly on functionality here with pretty as a side effect (my tact would be different if I was selling I suspect) but am interested to see what you run into/figure out doing them more at scale.

Re: Spindles and spindle display

#4

Steven Antonucci

Thanks for the feedback (Gary too!)

steven antonucci

I have a little bit of fleece, so I sort of know how to spin. In no way, shape, or form would I consider myself a proficient spinner, but I know how to make sure the spindle works?

I know what a nostepinne is and does, and I debated making some, but I am afraid that they will sell too, and I'll have to make dozens :)

I'm sitting on a couple of dozen, and a show this weekend will tell me how many more I want to make... I am pretty certain that they work better than a dowel in a toy truck wheel or a couple of AOL CDs glued together LOL

Report back Monday.

S

Re: Spindles and spindle display

#5

Re: Thanks for the feedback (Gary too!)

Rum

Rock on, looking forward to your event report!

heh, yeah I'm about in the same boat as you with spinning, good enough to look good but not good enough to actually be good :D

You're right about the "risk" on the nostepinnes, last year I made a bunch for the folks at a spinning class loml was going to/helping at as giveaways and had ~10 more than I "needed" (for a class of 15) which all mysteriously seemed to disappear as well over the week (several asked me if they could have an extra in a different wood or whatever). Not that I minded that much, just funny.

Speaking of better than truck wheels and aol cds (indubitably!)...

While you're at the show take a look around at some of the other tools for sale. Spindles are imho one of the better represented yarn processing tools quality and appearance wise (well and spinning wheels but looking more at the smaller end). Some of the other stuff is perhaps functional but not very pretty (and much is of dubious functionality). Since you've got a willing co-developer it seems like a potentially profitable and severely under served market.

Personally I find a lot of the tools in use for spinning, weaving, and related arts rather fascinating to make since they are an interesting place to overlap art and science. There are serious functional requirements (which appeals to my nerd side) but still lots of room for embellishment (which appeals to the other side).

Re: Spindles and spindle display

#6

Steven Antonucci

Science and art

steven antonucci

I like the idea of combining the two.

The science says that you want to have a rotating mass around a central point, and that the stability will increase if you put the mass outside, resulting in a longer, smoother spin. However, the time it takes for me at 6'1" with dubious spinning skills to create a fiber on that shaft is usually something I can do on even the lightest spindles I've made..sitting or standing. In my mind, spinning longevity is nice, but after 3-4' of yarn, I need to stop the spindle and wind the yarn anyway.

If you cannot turn a spindle that can spin for 30 seconds, you should sell your lathe :D

After a bit of yarn has been wound, it is no longer the weight of the spindle that matters (or the physics), but the mass of the yarn. So even the best spindles get trumped by yardage.

So then, what matters?

Pretty colors. Folks buying these are like turners and their tool racks. Do you really need 5 bowl gouges? Probably not. So you got to make them pretty to sell them. Spinners are buying craft/art. Not craft/engineering/science.

Steve

P.S. what I like does not equate to what is selling.

Re: Spindles and spindle display

#7

Re: Science and art

Rum

Apologies since I've probably exhausted any normal persons interest in this topic already :D

You're correct that eventually the fiber on the spindle mostly overwhelms the spindles characteristics, some of the spindles I saw in rural Peru were quite roughly made compared to what you have (that's sort of my baseline at this point for "functional spindle spinning" because they each make thousands of yards per year with their spindles). The things those gals could make those roughly made spindles do was impressive and interesting to watch. Supporting your hypothesis I don't believe I ever saw a spindle there without a goodly sized wad of yarn already on it - probably partially because of the initial imbalance and also probably just to add some weight for a faster spin. They were all bottom whorl spindles as well (which as previously noted are a lot less fussy to use) and were sometimes used in sort of a "self supported" fashion where they were let to spin with the point on the ground for re-spinning (to even and/or tighten the twist) and while plying (a skill I still haven't really got the hang of).

That certainly doesn't stop me from over engineering them for my own personal satisfaction though 8) It also somehow seems more impressive when you get a spindle with 5 minutes of "hang time" (and enables amusing stunts like spinning off of the balcony). I can't claim it would help them sell in a significant way or indeed that they would be any more functional in the long term.. but they are somehow more satisfying to make.

I also think you are 97.2% right on what matters for selling them as well. Based on my observations probably 80-90% of the pretty spindles sold don't actually get used (or maybe are used once) and then are used as decorations in the craft room. On the flip side I have heard some of the more serious spinners recommend certain spindle makers when giving classes because they "work better" and against some because "they're pretty but don't work at all". This can certainly be a nice sales boost especially if you're at a show where the class is concurrent with your sales (and behoves you to perhaps spiff a few nice spindles to the teachers - not to mention that they'll often give you useful feedback on areas to improve for free). Most of the ones I've seen though from loml's friends were bought more on the impulse buy side from "ooooh shiny".

Hmm... That leads to another thought, adding some "spindle storage and display" items would make it easier for folks to buy more spindles and also some extra sales (if you decide to do another show..). I know I keep making more work for you - its a special skill of mine ;)

FYI: In fairness of sharing, here's an older album with a couple of the first spindles I made - I realized I haven't taken any pics of any of the supported or newer ones.. These aren't perfect of course but were reasonably functional.

https://plus.google.com/109155963402491302285/posts/WSwzk783SGt