We are going to build a static play on train in the local park. I have volunteered to turn the wheels (about 24 @ 4.5 inches dia. We want to use a "plastic lumber" and HDPE (high density polyethylene) appears to be a good choice. Has anyone turned HDPE and what were the results??
Got to agree with Barry, the wood filled composite plastic lumber like Trex will machine a lot nicer and not have the same problem with the stringy shavings that 100% HDPE plastic lumber will have. Trex and the other materials like it consist of about 50% wood particles or fiber (think of fine sawdust) that have mixed with melted plastic. Each wood particle is encapsulated in the plastic matrix. The cut surfaces will expose wood that can then be glued - which is probably not important for wheels, but might be for other parts of the item. The wood that is exposed from cutting will of course weather and change color a bit overtime, so it is not as color fast as 100% HDPE but it has proven to be very durable in the field. Back in the 90's I worked for the USDA Forest Products Laboratory in Madison, Wisconsin and helped industry develop and manufacture these products.