Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Dust Collection

Posts

Dust Collection

#1

Dust Collection

Steve Criscenzo

Trying to head off a long term health problem so I considering upgrading my dust collector to a HEPA rated cyclone type. Looking at the Oneida V Series. Not the cheapest but it is made here and seems to have good reviews. Anyone have any experience with Oneida or any other cyclones.

Thanks

Steve

Re: Dust Collection

#2

Re: Dust Collection

Don Evans

Yes to Oneida. Best unit made in my opinion. I've had one for about 15 years and it is still working like new. Only problem I have ever had with it was the remote start unit that came with it. Back then they were providing X10 units with their cyclones but it didn't last but about a year. Replaced with another brand and type and all working well since then. I went the whole route and piped it to all my machines with metal pipes. When I purchased they would design the system for you and I when with their plan. I don't know if they still do that or not.

The company is first rate!

Don

Re: Dust Collection

#3

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Dust Collection

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Steve, unless you are a pro, just adding a new dust collector may not give you what you really want. Oneida has a design service that will analyze your shop needs and recommend a complete solution. I found it very useful when I set up my system several years ago. At that time, the service was free and did not obligate you to buy from them.

Dennis

Re: Dust Collection

#4

Re: Dust Collection

robo hippy

I have had my Oneida for 12 plus years, and love it. Probably as important as the filter is sealing the joints, and hoods to enclose any dust sources. A 3 hp system for my 24 X 36 shop will allow me to run 2 machines at once with good air movement.

The only other 'highly rated' system I have heard of is Clear View, but don't know about them.

robo hippy

Re: Dust Collection

#5

Re: Thanks for the info

Steve Criscenzo

Thanks for the feedback guys. You have confirmed what I have been thinking. I have a system that functions well as far as air flow but it is the two bag system but I want to get HEPA filtration. Based on your recommendations I will discuss duct design with Oneida to be sure I am doing it right.

Steve

Re: Dust Collection

#6

Re: Dust Collection

steve worcester

I didn't know they had HEPA rated filters, but my Oneida has worked like a champ for the 10+ years I have had it.

Re: Dust Collection

#7

Re: HEPAFilters

Steve Criscenzo

The canister filters on the current Oneida models are HEPA rated. Certified by a third party. Supposed to capture something like 99.7 % down to 0.4 microns. Much better than the advertised 5 micron bags (but not sure they are) on my current unit.

Steve

Re: Dust Collection

#8

Re: HEPAFilters

Don Evans

Steve, don't compare a bag collector with a cyclone. The HEPA rating is not a factor with the cyclone as much as it is with a bag unit.

Remember the most dust with a cyclone is going into a drum not the filter. But with the bag unit ALL the dust is in a porous bag with air blowing out of it back into the room you are in.

Of course the cyclone absolutely needs a high rated filter as the air that reaches it also goes back into the room but with much less dust in that air.

The first time you clean (back blow the filter) on the cyclone you will be amazed at what comes out of it. If you have close neighbors don't do it on a day they or you have your house windows open. Your yard will look like the Kansas dust bowl back in year 20th century. It's very fine stuff.

Don

Re: Dust Collection

#9

Re: HEPAFilters

Randy Johnson

I could be wrong, all wet, whatever, but something I seldom, if ever, see mentioned is how much height from floor to ceiling is needed for a good cyclone set up.

My shop has eight foot walls sitting on (I think) an eight inch poured foundation. With the cyclone mounted so the top of the motor touches the ceiling, one of Oneida’s tall drums is only a few inches under the bottom of the cyclone. I have doubts that there is enough space for the cyclone action to work properly. I base this statement on the amount of dust that falls into the pan at the bottom of the filter. Others talk about the small amounts they have. Mine is usually pretty much full, with many times more the amount on the walls of the filter. I would like to have at least a couple of feet between the bottom of the cyclone and the top of the drum, and if I had it to do over again I would have dry walled the ceiling so the cyclone was mostly in the attic.

Something else I should have done – and will eventually – is install a series of four way switches near each machine to do away with the remote. Mine will not work if I have any lights with a T-8 ballast turned on.

I bought my cyclone when I started work rehabbing the former two car garage that was to be my shop. The job turned out to be a lot more difficult (termite infestation) than planned, and it was over a year before I started work mounting the cyclone. I found that they had sent me the wrong center section. A phone call to Oneida resulted in the information that, due to design changes since my unit was shipped, they didn’t have anything that would work. They had to make a new center section for me. It was delivered in a reasonable time frame, especially under the circumstances. I think that says volumes about their customer service.

Re: Dust Collection

#10

Re: Dust Collection

Josh Bowman

Steve,

I live in the country and several years ago removed the bags from my grizzly DC. Then mounted the blower in my attic. The discharge angles into a 12" metal duct that is vertical down to a garden wagon. When the wagon gets full, I pull it out to the woods and dump it. Here's the positives : All dust that goes in goes out so it's 100% efficient. Next is the noise is less. The biggest plus is the suction pressure increased a lot. The only negative for me is a very slight exchange of air into the shop, but I haven't noticed it effects temperature much. ....and my shop is heated and ac'd.

Re: Dust Collection

#11

Re: Dust Collection

robo hippy

I figure my dust collector can replace all the air in my shop in about 5 minutes. Not good in the hot summer, or cold winter.... If you live in a very mild climate, not a problem.

robo hippy

Re: Dust Collection

#12

Re: Dust Collection

Steve Criscenzo

Interesting thought but not really an option for me for two reasons. 1. I do not live in the country so blowing it outside will not work from a noise (I tend to work early in the AM) and/or mess standpoint. 2. As Reed said, at 500 cfm, my collector would change the air in my shop in about 10 min. The makeup air has to come from somewhere and at the times when I am heating or cooling the space I would want to recirculate rather than replace the air in the shop.

Steve