Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

food safe or not food safe?

Posts

food safe or not food safe?

#1

food safe or not food safe?

Mike Potts

When I first started turning bowls in Jan all my bowl where traditional shape and I used food safe finish. I gave a lot of these away to family and friends. now when I asked if they ever used the bowls for food purpose, the answer has always been " No It's on display maybe fruit, candy or other decoration in it" So I have turned the the Beal waxing system on all the pieces I turn now. My Question for you guys that have a lot more experience than I, what does the general public prefer. FOOD SAFE OR NOT

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#2

Re: food safe or not food safe?

don stephan

Because of the possibility that your bowl could be used for food purposes, I would want to use a food safe finish and not bother asking people what they prefer. Whenever this has been discussed (often) one or more responses has said that almost every finish, once fully cured, is inert and hence food safe. No doubt this is assuming the finish is not so thick that it could come off in flakes.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#3

Re: food safe or not food safe?

steve worcester

The traditional answer is if the finish flashes off long enough, it is safe.

The reality is if the manufacturer has had it tested it is food safe. I stick by that path because some of the finishes I shoot I would not want to eat. But I don't use them for products (bowls) that I would think would be used for food.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Re: food safe or not food safe?

Lyle Jamieson

Its all about litigation. Finish manufacturers do not want to go through the cost of testing to prove that it is food safe and turn around and have somebody sue them down the road anyway. Its easier to stay silent.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#5

Re: food safe or not food safe?

John Lucas

Not to mention we are a really small user of their products for this purpose and it simply doesn't pay for them to spend the money to have it listed as food safe.

Most surface finishes are basically plastic (for our purposes) so it's like eating off a styrafoam plate or plastic plate. If it flakes off it simply passes through your system. Other than shellac which is actually what many pills are coated with.

that being said, I use thin oil type finishes for bowls that will be used and washed. I use the surface type finishes for showy bowls simply because it stays looking "shiny" or more satin longer. Oil finishes tend to dull with age but they are easily rejuvinated with applications of more oil. They just don't tend to stay looking really nice for long without some sort of buffing.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#6

Steven Antonucci

do you know what finish is on your dishes?

Steven antonucci

I think this topic is overblown?

Do you know what finish is on your dishes? How about when you eat out? What kind of ink was used on the McDonalds wrapper? Plastic isn't always safe...

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Oh, what a wonderful world....

Jesper, Denmark

1. You are not supposed to eat your wooden turnings.

2. Whatever you put on you turnings is probably healthier to eat off then whatever you consume at (insert your favorite fast food emporium here).

3. If enough warnings are put on finishing labels, manufacturers hope to avoid being sued? Does it work? $22 million for a hot cup of coffee at McDonalds some time ago.

4."Waterbased" is supposed to be safe? Toxic and flammable solvents sre replaced with glycol ether compounds - some of which have been shown to cause birth defects if pregnant women are exposed to them in the semiconductor industry - are the rest "safe"

5. BLO seems very benign, right? What about the Cobolt in the Japan drier?

6. In reality, none of the stuff we put on turnings have been shown to harm anybody in their intended use.

7. You decide what "safe" means. If there are unscrupulous lawyers around, nothing is safe.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#8

Re: food safe or not food safe?

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Not sure will be allowed to link this article on “Food Safe Finishes by Jonathan Binzen.

www.finewoodworking.com/how-to/article/food-safe-finishes.aspx

Whether you use old and tried finishes or new low VOC finishes not a bad idea to keep in mind recommended personal protective equipment to don before using a product found on product container label and after reading section 2 & 3 Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) or Safety Data Sheet (SDS).

Then scroll down to the bottom of the page and look for “Disclaimer Statements,” like these;

The information contained on this MSDS has been checked and should be accurate. However, it is the responsibility of the user to comply with all Federal, State, and Local laws and regulations.

This document has been prepared using data from sources considered to be reliable. It does not constitute a warranty, express or implied, as to the accuracy of the information contained within. Actual conditions of use and handling are beyond seller's control. All materials may present unknown hazards and should be used with caution. The user's obligation is to evaluate and use this product in a safe manner.

Yes, our government list toxic chemical as safe for food contact, but do not recommend one wood finishing product as food safe. Even products listed by manufacturers as food safe have not been tested by any government laboratory. Other parts of government & manufactures cautions us about wearing PPE while working with a finishing products and warns us about creating indoor pollution.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#9

Joe Fleming

Re: food safe or not food safe?

Joe Fleming

Mike,

To me, food safe means two things. First, can the product leach out, chip, or contaminate such that it is consumed? This means, if I eat it, I'll be OK. Several of the finishing experts have all said what has been repeated in this thread: any finish that has fully cured will be food save. The driers are the bad actors here. The remaining materials are inert.

More important to me, however, is that "food safe" implies day-to-day use, which translates to wear. So, to me the real issue is surface renewal by the owner - not me. For this, I go with walnut oil or mineral oil. I apply something that the final owner can easily apply without worry. Any of the solvent finishes, like the General finish, will be difficult for the average user to obtain and use.

Joe

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#10

Well said

Dick Coers

My favorite is eating chips of finish. When is the last time a piece of finish fell off one of your bowls?

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#11

Re: food safe or not food safe?

Barry L Elder

Mike, the next time someone asks you if an item they are interested in purchasing, tell them the bowl, platter, etc. is NOT EDIBLE! :D

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#12

Back to the original Question

Mike Potts

As always a lot of good info and varied opinions from the people " the more politically correct, sorry for the (GUYS) for the lady turners" on this forum. I guess

I wasn't clear are people really looking for a bowl or plate to eat off of, or a piece of home decor? but once the piece leaves our hands (sold or gift) there is no telling who the end user will be and what they will use the piece for. I personally like the harder finishes, so I guess from here on out if I use a finish that there is a possibility of being sued for I'll sign my new stage name " John Lucas " on the bottom.

Again thanks

Mike

PS.

Barry we might need a new disclaimer for the people looking for extra fiber in their diet and try to eat the bowl.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#13

What are they gonna get if they sue me

John Lucas

They would have to be pretty hard up. It's like a friend who used to teach Rock Climbing. Someone asked him if he had insurance for this. He said no, what are they going to get my backpack and my 65 Nova that has 200,00 miles. It's all I actually own.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#14

if your selling bowls

John Lucas

You have to ask yourself. What can I tell the customer that doesn't turn them off. If you have to explain about all finished being food safe then you better have a palatable explanation that sounds better than, well if ingest it it's just plastic. That doesn't work.

I run into the same thing with my Mahoney's oil. I tell them I chose it because it's a good long lasting finish. I choose it because it has the nut alergin remove however I try not to tell them that because if the ones that do won't believe what I say and won't buy it anyway.

I use lacquer on many of my bowls and when asked I tell them I use the same finish applied to quality furniture and even your table. that satisfies most people. Those who question it's food safe qualities are really just looking for a way to get out of the purchase. Most people pick them up, say I love this it's wonderful, how much and we make a deal. Very few people have asked me about food safety.

I research it simply because I want to choose something that at least in my opinion and research won't hurt them. Except for little bratty kids. I have toys dipped in curare for them. (just kidding folks)

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#15

Point taken, make sence


Re: food safe or not food safe?

#16

Re: if your selling bowls

Dick Coers

Just tell them it's safer than red Fiesta dinnerware. They used uranium oxide until 1944. After that, they reissued the color by using depleted uranium in 1959.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#17

Re: food safe or not food safe?

Ron Bauer

A lot of good info here. My "go to" finish is a mixture of mineral oil (recommeneded as a laxative to be taken internally), beeswax and carnauba wax (on lots of food and meds you take). All are ok if ingested. It is easy to apply, easy to make, easy to repair, durable and leaves a superb satin finish that is pleasant to the touch. I had one lady at a show, after feeling the silky smooth finish on one of my bowls, tell that she "could just stroke my wood all day long". Hmmmmhhh. Anyway, I agree with most of the other posters here that just about anything reasonable you choose to use is "food safe". IMHO. Ron.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#18

Steven Antonucci

a good answer for you:

steven antonucci

If someone asks you if it is food safe, respond that it wouldn't be very useful as a bowl if it wasn't?

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#19

Ellis Walentine

And see how far that gets you 


Re: food safe or not food safe?

#20

Generally "cured" finishes are safe ...

Geoff Whaling

However there is no warranty that any given finish is going to be safe for every single individual. I remember a turner saying "I just haven't met the individual who maybe allergic to the products I prefer to use".

If you stick to recommended finishes that manufacturers state are "food safe" products like butchers block oils, etc for daily use bowls, and "cured" finishes for show pieces then the risk is quite low.

In reality wood turners are very caring responsible manufacturers, not like some very large scale toy manufacturers who recently were caught out using paints containing lead on toys.

So my response to questions about how safe a finish is

"Personally I don't drink the stuff :-) but I care about my safety and yours. So I only use finishing products that are widely recognized and published as being safe to apply and food safe when cured. If you prefer an unfinished bowl I can supply one however you may find it difficult to maintain an acceptable look to it over time."

On the other hand you could read http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/cfrsearch.cfm?fr=175.300 to make your own informed decisions.

Re: food safe or not food safe?

#21

Mike Peace

Re: Generally "cured" finishes are safe ...

Mike Peace

After reading a few lines of the FDA document, my eyes started glazing over. :D