Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Can anyone explain........

Posts

Can anyone explain........

#1

Jesper, Denmark

Can anyone explain........

Jesper, Denmark

The mechanics/physics or any other technical justification for the negative rake scraper (NRS) ????

Seems to me that putting a 5° bevel on the top of the scraper is no different to raising the handle by 5°.

Barring the relative ease of not having to raise the handle, I fail to understand the difference - yet a number of well respected turners swear by it??

Re: Can anyone explain........

#2

Re: Can anyone explain........ *LINK*

Dick Coers

Cutter geometry and angles at play here. In this case, it's the angle of which the burr cuts. I think you would have to raise the handle something 30 or 40 degrees to present the same angle. Probably still not cut the same.


http://woodturning.org/files/2013/01/nrs-article.pdf

Re: Can anyone explain........

#3

Re: Can anyone explain........

John Lucas

My take on it is this. If you raise the handle its almost impossible to not put some forward force against the work. With a negative rake scraper the handle is horizontal and you would put the minimum amount of pressure against the work. At least that's what I think. I may be wrong

Re: Can anyone explain........

#4

Re: Can anyone explain........

Dick Coers

It seems like it has to be more than that John. For instance, consider a conventional scraper being used on the inside of fairly thin side grain bowl, up near the rim. Nearly certain to explode. Some will say the scraper will self feed in that area. Negative rake will work just fine in that area. Based on your work with the Hunter tools, I think it's about the same as laying the cutter in a horizontal position, vs twisting the handle so you present the cutter at an angle in a scraping cut. Different angle of the burr, same as different angle of the cutter.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#5

Neg Rake = Misnomer  ???  (long) *LINK*

Doc Green

Jesper, First of all, like you, I'm convinced that the top bevel does nothing more than alleviate the need for raising the handle to achieve the negative rake at the point the cutting edge contacts the wood.

What I find to be the critical difference is the included angle between the top and bottom bevels. As it becomes smaller, the nature of the burr changes. At angles of 70 degrees or so for normal scrapers, the burr will be well defined and can be very strong, depending on how it is formed. As the angle gets down to about 35 or 40 degrees (included angle on most skews) the burr will be more pronounced as it comes off the wheel, but it will be very weak, similar to the "wire edge" that knife sharpeners speak of.

I'm a recent convert to the so-called negative-rake scrapers. For years I have heard of turners using a skew as a NRS, but I would not subject my skews to that treatment for fear of ruining (or at least dulling) the cutting edge. However, I reground another tool (M2 HHS) to the same angle as a skew and gave it a try. I was amazed. With the tool flat on the rest and horizontal, it removed fine shavings from the workpiece and left a surface almost like glass. That tool is now my go-to tool for final finishing cuts inside and outside of bowls, etc.

Further, I'm convinced that with an included angle of 35 - 40 degrees, the burr is not all that important, even if it exists. What is important is the small angle and having a keen edge. By keen edge, I mean one that is razor sharp, or almost. The tool works best (fine shavings and leaves a smooth surface) when it is razor sharp, but I do not often go to the trouble of producing a cutting edge that will "shave the hair off your arm."

So instead of the emphasis being on the negative rake, I think it should be on the keen edge. Therefore, the term "keen edge scraper" would be more descriptive than "negative rake."

Another consideration is the grit of the wheel used to grind the tool. I use a 120-grit wheel to shape the bevels (as required, but infrequently) but rely on a well-worn 120-grit diamond wheel or a hand-held diamond card to hone the cutting edge, which is critical. If you use a coarse wheel to form the cutting edge, the burr produced will be very prominent but also very weak. It will only last for a few seconds of actual cutting. With an edge formed by honing, the edge needs to be touched up only every now and then, about like what you do with a bowl gouge.

I'm not sure the honed edge even has a burr, but if it does, the burr is extremely small. To get a razor edge (when I go to the trouble), I actually polish the bevels with a compound on leather, which is like stropping a razor. In this case, no burr can be detected by rubbing a finger across the edge, but the tool works best when treated in this manner.

Here is a link to the first of three articles on scrapers on my website:

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/scrapers1.html

In the article following this one, I describe a "negative rake scraper" that has an included angle of more than 90 degrees. In this case, you can grind the scraper without producing a burr. Such a scraper is of limited use, in my view.

In the articles, I make the point that a burr from a grinder is far inferior to one produced by hand, by honing with a diamond hone.

What I believe (and have written) is contrary to what is advocated by a lot of well-known and experienced turners. But I came to my convictions over a long period of time and after a lot of experimenting. Further, I can demonstrate the techniques and results in my shop and have made several "keen edge" scrapers for other turners.

So, this is my $0.02. Your mileage may vary.

~Doc


Doc's Website

Re: Can anyone explain........

#6

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Can anyone explain........

Dennis in Southern Oregon

This issue has come up before. An examination of the forces involved at the cutting edge and the tool rest for the two cases shows that there is a very slight difference between the two. Assume that the negative rake scraper is horizontal and cutting directly into the wood at center height and that the conventional scraper has its tool rest adjusted to present the tool edge in the same position and its upper edge at the same angle to the wood as the NRS. In addition, assume that the bevel angles and burrs are the same in both cases.

Then the conventional scraper with raised handle will experience a slight component of force drawing it toward the turning whereas the negative rake scraper will not. The magnitude of this force f is proportional to the downward force F on the cutting edge caused by the cutting action and it is equal to F sin(angle) where "angle" is the rake angle of the NRS. As an example, if angle = 5 degrees and the cutting force is 1.0 pound, the force f will be 0.087 pounds or 1.4 ounces. As to whether this small self-feeding force actually affects performance, I cannot say.

Dennis

Re: Can anyone explain........

#7

Re: Can anyone explain........

Bill Boehme

The primary thing is that a regular scraper is less than 90° while a negative rake scraper can be greater than 90°. I made one with an included angle of about 105°. Of course, this means that the bur will be more fragile. I create a stronger bur by first grinding the bevels on my Tormek water stone and then using a burnishing tool to create the bur. Anybody who uses this technique on cabinet scrapers knows that produces a bur that lasts far longer than one made with a dry grinder, but it still is somewhat short lived. I think that John Lucas has a good insight into the physics behind tilting scrapers.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#8

Re: Can anyone explain........

mo'wood

Here is a different opinion about what makes a negative rake scraper cut so fine:

As the shaving leaves the wood off the sharp edge- bur or no bur- the top surface of the tool forces the shaving back towards the surface of the spinning wood and causes it to break off closer to its point of attachment, so that there is no tendency for the shaving to rip out in advance of the cutting edge or self-feed the way a sharp chisel at a positive acute angle does. Having a negative rake compresses the point of attachment so that the shaving will not detach at an obtuse angle to the material surface.

This cutting dynamic is the same reason that cabinet scrapers are tilted forward in the direction of travel- compressing the shaving so that it immediately leaves the surface in a perpendicular direction and will not rip out in advance of the cut.

Tilting the cutting edge at an angle –instead of keeping it horizontal- adds a shearing action that I find provides the best surface quality on both end grain and side-grain, as long as the fibers are in compression at the point of departure from the wood surface. It has a lot to do with the characteristics of the material being cut, but shear scraping also works on all sorts of materials- I’ve used in on plexi, brass, plastics, etc.

There is also the factor of proportional surface area of the tool in contact with the wood in relation to the vertical forces acting on the tool, as they are transferred into the tool rest. Raising the handle alone does not produce the same cutting action as a negative rake due to the behavior of the cutting edge in relation to the forces action upon it, and the fulcrum point on the tool rest in relation to center-line where the wood is moving (just about) vertically.

All this understanding of the principals of cutting dynamics of a particular material sort of disappears as you develop a feel for the best cutting action, and listen to that little nuanced voice in your ear that says: “stop now and sharpen the tool”.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#9

one further thought...

GaryG in MD

People above have covered the topic much better than I could, but I have one very simple reaction that I'm not sure has been fully covered, and that is the height of the cutting edge. Depending on what we're doing, we may want the cutting edge to be on center, or a bit above, or a bit below. Tipping a standard scraper down (raising the handle) lowers the cutting edge, requiring raising of the tool rest. It's harder to maintain some random angle (and hence cutting height) as opposed to keeping it quite flat on the rest. For me, the ability to keep the tool flat on the rest and control the height of the cutting edge quite easily, is important, and one of the reasons I've ground ALL my scrapers to a negative rake. ...GG

Re: Can anyone explain........

#10

Re: Can anyone explain........

Bill Boehme

The only reason that I might not agree with your theory would be that that is not what happens when I use a NRS or a cabinet scraper. In either of those situations when the scraper stops producing shavings and begins to produce crumbs and/or dust that means that the tool is dull.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#11

Re: Can anyone explain........

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Stuart talks about bevel angles and demonstrate using conventional & negative rake scraper in his “Overhang Scraper,” video at his site. Just go to his site, “Resources,” Videos, and scroll down. Video does have a problem with sound.

Stuart addresses tool steel and why he prefers using A10/A11 steel tools over M2 HSS tools in that article. He also talks about wood species, when to use a negative rake scraper and when not too! While his tools come from the factory with 50 degree bevel angles also said bevel angle not critical in his video.

Two YouTube videos Mike Waldt, “Woodturning-Beginners Guide #8 The Negative Rake Scraper,” Sam Angelo WyomingWoodturner: Negative Rake Scraper. Both talk about different bevel angles and how to hold your tool.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#12

Another point of view...

Ed Davidson

Here's a different take on the physics: a negative rake on the scraper results in more metal at the cutting surface (30/30 degree bevels for example verses 30/90), and therefore...less vibration, which yields less chatter and dig-ins.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Can anyone explain........

Jesper, Denmark

Thanks for all the input. There is quite a lot to digest. I will have to grind a few and try it out.

It seems quite clear that the ability to hold it level is an advantage - without really changing the cutting geometry.

Following Doc Greens extensive experience and very thorough descriptive papers, a 75° grind (70° primary and 5°) should work and produce a durable burr on a V10 steel from Thompson.

...........more to follow.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#14

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A little "aside".....

Jesper, Denmark

While Mike Waldt produces a well shot and commented video, I have some reservations:

He advocates rubbing the bevel on a scraper with the handle down to start - not a very safe practice in my opinion. At the same time, his videos tend to be advocating tools supplied to him by various manufacturers - so as I see it, advertizing in disguise.

In the videos, the easy tasks are shown, but the difficult bits tend to have been edited out.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#15

Re: A little "aside"..... *LINK*

Doc Green

Here's my take on the scraper Mike was using. With a top bevel of 30 and an end bevel of 70 degrees, the included angle at the cutting edge will be 100 degrees, according to the math.

At about 3:50 into the video, he shows a profile view of the bevels and as best as I can measure on my computer screen, the included angle is very nearly 90 degrees. This is reasonable, I think, if there is some inaccuracy in either grinding or measuring the angles.

Either way, 90 or 100 degrees, grinding will produce only a minimal burr if any at all. Therefore, his scraper is one where a blunt but sharply defined (keen) cutting edge is applied to the wood. It will cut and produce shavings, but the cut is not aggressive and I would guess he was applying considerable force pushing the tool against the wood. In hard wood, the surface produced will be clean and smooth.

As far as approaching the work with the tool handle held down is concerned, it is the large included angle that makes bevel rubbing possible without getting a catch. For an included angle of 70 degrees (standard scraper), the practice is risky, and for an included angle of 60 degrees, a catch is almost assured.

I now grind my "regular or standard" scrapers at 77 degrees, more or less, and form the burr with a diamond hone (after grinding and then removing the burr produced by the grinder). I approach the workpiece with the handle held low to rub the bevel, and then slowly raise the handle until it begins to cut. Raising the handle more causes the cut to become more aggressive.

This is for scrapers used flat on the rest; sheer scraping is a whole different matter. Also, scrapers (or skews used as scrapers) where the included angle may be only 35 to 40 degrees fall into a different category.

Here is the link to Mike's video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdXxkr1hEPE


Mike's video

Re: Can anyone explain........

#16

Re: A little "aside".....

John Lucas

Doc what about a skew. the included angle on my favorite skew is 70 degrees and one skew has 50 degrees. Obviously I rub the bevel on these for a handle down cut. Not taking you to task because I know you were talking about a scraper rubbing the bevel just confused by your numbers, or maybe I read them wrong.

I did a test for Betty Scarpino a year or so ago where I took my scrapers and cut with them held flat on the tool rest and then ground off the burr and used them as a bevel rubbing tool. Of course they did cut and didn't get a catch but obviously the cut was not very clean due to the blunt nature of the edge ( i believe the included angle on these was something like 120 degrees. They cut about as clean when held flat on the tool rest and used as a scraper with a fresh burr. Then I did the same cuts using them as shear scrapers. Of course they cut cleaner then.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#17

Re: A little "aside".....

Doc Green

John, I was thinking of a skew where the length of the bevels is about 1.5 times the thickness of the body. This translates to an included angle of about 40 degrees. I have no experience with skews having a larger included angle.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#18

Re: A little "aside".....

Wally Dickerman

Stuart Batty, who is largely responsible for the increasing popularity of the NR scraper recommends an included angle of 45 deg to 75 deg. His article in American Woodturner some time ago shows a tool with a 50 deg included angle. I've ground a NR at 45 deg with a top grind at about 20 deg. I like it.

Stuart claims that an included angle of over 90 deg won't cut well at all.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#19

Re: A little "aside".....

Wally Dickerman

I should mention that my NR scraper is made from a Thompson 1 inch scraper. The harder steel holds a burr much better than M2 steel. I've also found that the burr from my CBN wheel lasts for a longer time than from an AO wheel

Re: Can anyone explain........

#20

Doc, I am a convert

Ron Bauer

Doc, after reading your several posts here a couple weeks ago regarding this topic I ran straight out and ground (~77deg) a Thompson scraper, honed the top and the bevel then raised a burr on the honed edge. Wow, incredible finish and friendly to use. Now I will try to do the same on a NR and see how that works. From the comments it should be better. Thanks, Doc.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#21

Good Deal!  Thanks for the comment.


Re: Can anyone explain........

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Doc, I am a convert

Jesper, Denmark

I grind my scrapers at 70° on a blue 80 grit wheel, but do not remove the burr and re-hone. There is a world of difference between my older Sorby et. al. scrapers and the Thompson 10V.

I believe the differences are both in the steel and that the Thompson scrapers are thicker than most other brands. Hence they are stiffer and the steel making process seems to make the scraper not have a dominant natural frequency - so no resonance.

I have re-ground some of the older scrapers to NRS - and they are not as good as the standard grind Thompsons.

Re: Can anyone explain........

#23

Re: Doc, I am a convert

Ron Bauer

Jesper, far be it from me to go on about Doc's edge preparation since I am only a convert, not a disciple. The key to whatever edge geometry you choose to use, whether it be conventional at "X" degrees or NRS at "Y" included angle, is honing and burnishing the edge. The edge left by the traditional grinding alone is a nasty, irregular jagged mess that lasts only until the wire has been torn away (and some of it is probably deposited in the wood). The edge produced by honing then burnishing is a true cutting edge of solid steel. Its quality is determined by the job done in honing. This of course is IMHO. Ron.