Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

hollow forms shape study

Posts

hollow forms shape study

#1

hollow forms shape study

Dick Coers

Well not exactly a shape study, but more of a series on a theme. Getting ready for the holiday gift show and artist studio walks. Thought I would try some small forms to get to a gift price point. Largest is the spalted maple in the back row, 5" sphere (almost). Back row, left to right; curly maple, European white poplar/walnut finale, spalted soft maple, 2 more white poplar, box elder, and double dyed curly maple in front. Keeping the finish at a satin level to really feel soft to the touch. These are fun to hold, at least for the artist. We'll see what the public thinks really soon. Critiques and comments welcomed. Okay me first, photo composition looks like I'm getting ready for hollow form bowling!

Re: hollow forms shape study

#2

Steven Antonucci

They're all pretty nice!


Re: hollow forms shape study

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollow forms shape study

Lyle Jamieson

Great series, we learn a lot doing a series. Spheres are hard to get right, you are nailing it. Id be interested in the sequence which one is first, second...last. I like the mouth opening in the front piece. That shape also lets you get into small mouth openings easier.

Re: hollow forms shape study

#4

Re: hollow forms shape study

Dick Coers

Thanks Lyle. Box elder, double dyed curly maple, back left curly maple, center middle white poplar, left center white poplar, white poplar with finale, spalted maple, in that order. My favorite one to play with on the coffee table is that box elder. There is no foot, and there is just enough weight in the bottom that you can pull it all the way over and let go. It rocks back and forth until it comes to rest. Only one of my forms can be set into motion. I've done a couple bowls with no foot, and they can rock back and forth, but this thing can be really dramatic. While rocking, it also rotates a little. Quite fun. I plan on keeping it moving a lot during our First Friday Studio Walk. If nothing else, good conversation starter!

Re: hollow forms shape study

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollow forms shape study

Lyle Jamieson

I was hoping to see a transition in shapes from start to finish. There are subtle differences Im sure you notice as the series progressed, but I don't see a pattern. Its hard to choose, they all look great, but I like the shapes of all three on the left side of the photo.

Re: hollow forms shape study

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: hollow forms shape study

Brad Vietje

I agree that they're all very nice! Any chance you can post a photo of them lined up so we can pick the guilty party from behind the one-way mirror ?

I like the one in front best so far, and mostly because I like that type of raised lip opening, and the one in the far back with the more complex shape. Sure would be nice to see them where they're not blocking each other -- PICKY, eh?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: hollow forms shape study

#7

Re: hollow forms shape study

Dick Coers

You're right Brad, a much different perspective.


Re: hollow forms shape study

#8

Re: hollow forms shape study

John Lucas

Now that's cool. Love the second from the left as far as form. One thing I learned years ago was if you want to make something sphere shaped it had better be perfectly round. If not your eye picks it up immediately. In most cases you are better off purposely making it out of round so your eye can easily detect that it wasn't meant to be a sphere.

Great job on turning those. I'll bet it was fun.

Re: hollow forms shape study

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: hollow forms shape study

Brad Vietje

Interesting...

I still like the second one the best, both for the shape of the opening as well as the overall form. The last one (#7) also has a very pleasing form, but in addition to the more complex form, it's off on its own with the finial, too.

Looks to me like the 3rd and 5th (from left) are closest to spheres, and thus, to my eye at least, the least interesting shapes. John is, as usual, spot on; a sphere has to be right on the money or it looks like a mistake. This applies to hollow forms as well as items like hollow ornaments. If it isn't going to be perfectly spherical, better to make it obviously not a sphere, so the curve looks intentional.

Good comparisons are 2/3/4 and 5/6, since they are similar sizes and species (or at least colors) with different curves.

I like #4 and #6 better than #3 and #5, simply because of the fuller, wider form. If they are all displayed for sale at the same time, it would be interesting to see which elicit the best response, and the order in which they sell.

I tend to like shapes that are wider than tall, but I've noticed that lately I have turned more that are taller than wide... hmmmm... Gotta make some fat ones!

Very nice work, Dick -- let us know how things work out.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT