Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Which Thread Chaser

Posts

Which Thread Chaser

#1

Which Thread Chaser

Stuart Johnson

I've been practicing thread chasing with Sorby 16 tpi chasers. For practice I use pvc pipe which takes threads very well plus some Cedar Elm that works but isn't the best. The threads get rather crumbly but work if used with CA glue.

Would 10 or 12 tpi chasers work better in marginal wood? When do should a course thread be used as opposed to a finer one?

Re: Which Thread Chaser

#2

Re: Which Thread Chaser

John Lucas

I think wood choice is the major factor in thread chasing. Not so much the pitch. However wood choice is the main reason I purchased the Baxter threader. I simply don't have access to the really good woods, or at least can't justify spending the money on them.

I will admit that I am not the best hand chaser. I can thread good woods like Blackwood and Boxwood with any chaser. When I switch to maple which always gives me a hard time it doesn't seem to make a difference changing pitch. However that could me my lack of skill or simply that some of my chasers are home made and may not cut as well. They do seem to cut equally well in the good woods.

After fighting hand chasing I purchased the Baxter threader and then made lots and lots of boxes to pay for the thing (it isn't cheap but in my opinion is the best one on the market). I can cut threads in extremely soft woods if I do multiple passes and use thin CA. It cuts very clean threads in the harder woods that are still to soft to chase threads. I love it.

I only have marginal success when hand chasing and using the CA. Possibly because CA is brittle and even though it seems to harden the wood it may require more skill to cut cleanly.

I use larger threads for bigger boxes because you have more room for wood movement. If you use 20tpi threads on a large box the seasonal movement can make the lid fall right off. conversly I wouldn't use 10 tpi to make earring boxes. for that 20 is much better.

Re: Which Thread Chaser

#3

Re: Which Thread Chaser

Craig Daymon

Are you trying to cut threads in end grain (spindle orientation) or side grain (bowl orientation)? Though cutting threads in end grain with dense woods like Blackwood and Boxwood works well, it is not the strongest orientation for threads. Think of the bundle of straws scenario that is often used to describe wood grain. Cutting threads in end grain is actually cutting through the sides of those tubes, slicing the straws. I suspect this is what is happening.

The choice of wood does make a difference. Maybe try to get some Osage Orange? Nice and dense, hard as rock and might be available free in your area if you look around a bit. Also, considering where you are, Persimmon, which is in the Ebony family. Though buying Persimmon can be expensive.

For an inexpensive thread cutter, you can grind the threads halfway through on a bolt. Resharpen with a diamond slick. Won't hold an edge great, but it's cheap and should last long enough to cut a set of threads before resharpening.

Re: Which Thread Chaser

#4

Re: Which Thread Chaser

Dale Miner

16 tpi is a good all around pitch. 20 tpi is perhaps easier to use, but 16 is only slightly more difficult. Softer woods are difficult to thread with any pitch. A coarse pitch has the advantage of providing engagement with a thread is not fully formed. By not fully formed, I am referring to threads that have fairly wide flats on the top of the threads. When trying to chase to a full thread form, the length of cut increases requiring more strength in the thread root. This is where less than ideal woods lack sufficient stregth and fail with a crumbled thread as a result.

I have a set of 12 tpi chasers, and seldom use them. My suggestion would be to stick with the 16's and consider using inserts in softer woods. The best wood for hand chasing in my opinion is blackwood. The best low cost woods for hand chasing are pear and apple. Cocobolo and boxwood are somewhere between blackwood and pear/apple. Blackwood hand threads well without CA reinforcement. Pear and apple respond favorably to a light wipe of CA before the last few light passes.

Re: Which Thread Chaser

#5

Re: Which Thread Chaser

Phillip Medghalchi

John, you mean this one?

BAXTER'S THREAD MASTERThis Baxter's Thread Master was designed for all lathes from 9" swing to 12-1/2" swing. For milling threads to 3" diameter.

BAXTER'S THREAD MASTER

BTM-12.5$399.99

Re: Which Thread Chaser

#6

Re: Which Thread Chaser

mo'wood

There are two tricks that I have learned make a big difference with hand-chased threads, and they will allow you to cut consistently clean threads on domestic woods such as hard maple and walnut-as long as the annual rings are fairly dense. (tighter annual rings will work better than more open grain).

1. Most new chasers are ground with too much bevel relief that rips out the cross grain. Try grinding / honing a small negative rake angle on the top of the chaser teeth- it slows down the aggressive cut of a typical chaser, and prevent the grain from ripping out as much. An included angle that is around 90 degrees seems to work just fine. Be sure to set your tool rest so that you are cutting exactly on center line- the handle of the chaser should be nearly horizontal in use.

2. Prior to chasing both interior and external threads, try soaking the surface of the wood with a mixture of about 90% Dawn dish-washing liquid cut with 10% denatured alcohol. Let it soak in for a few minutes, and using a sharp chaser carefully strike the first thread. The soap acts as a lubricant in a similar way to how dense resinous woods cut, and produces more of a ‘slurry’ rather than chips or dust, but the resulting threads are crisp. The problem with chasing threads in kiln dried wood is that it like trying to cut a cracker- the grain breaks and chips. The soap solution makes the wood less brittle (and also gets your dishes sparkling clean).

I agree that 16tpi is a good general size down to about 1 ½” diameter, and the 20tpi is easier learn how to use. I prefer the nice double-end chasers that Mark St. Leger sells.

I have a bunch of other tips that I have collected for when I teach thread chasing- drop me an e-mail and I will send the handout to you.

-Michael