Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Posts

Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#1

Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Hi folks.

Her eis a bowl that I manged to finally to put a finish on and show it to you guys. I am not sure ,but I checked with Robo, and we think it's WA apple, the only thing I ma sure of it's origin from WA. However, working with it was abear since everytime I wanted to finish it-it would crack on the rings in the grain and I had to keep using CA to get it finished. It was finished with Myland friction polish which my wife likes it a lot. Dimensions are 4 3/4" at the belly (widest width) by about 4"tall, and the rim about 4" dia. I like the shape and the finish came out good.

Comments or are welcomed.




Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Keith Tompkins

Nice job Phillip.....very clean cuts!

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#3

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Dick Coers

Just asking, but based on the last couple you have shown, do you have any wood without cracks? Seems that you need to get to know a tree guy so you can get some fresh stock.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#4

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Dick, this was a piece which was (not quietly wet) moist. I got it last year when I went to WA and it was jt fine without any cracks. As I mentioned in my post darn thing started cracking as I was sanding then I had to figure out a way to reverse chuck it. the interim time that passed coincided with summer and we have had over 100 F in San Antonio which dried it quite a bit and I did not pt any protection on it with the thought of coming back to it and finish it, however it didn't' happen and when I finally got to it was too dry and as i was sanding it--it started to open up around those grain lines and then I got a catch in one of those cracks. Over all, I think it came put OK, it may not meet some of you guy's standard, but I finished it never the less. to me at this point I am trying to work with what I got and have tried to talk to tree guys and they take my no. but San Antonio is pretty big and spread out, so they don't bother to call me to go and get the logs. I may not be that good looking for them to give me some of the trees they cut down :D . Also, I do not speak Spanish and that can cause some problem too. I have been getting some wood form my friends on line and they have coated them with anchor seal. bt for me to get to them ai have to finish what I already have. Wair few days until I get to take pictures of what I have finished and soem haev worm holes in them that came out very cool.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#5

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Thank yo Keith, I have been taking the tips to heart and I am coming along very good. My cuts and sanding have improved and my eyes are getting better in detecting flows. Thanks for your words of encouragement.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#6

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Rum

Very nice looking piece of wood, glad you managed to save it. I have a few pieces that I'm pretty sure were almost as much CA as wood once I was done; I kept those because I'm pretty sure the CA will eventually fail but they're a nice reminder of where I've been. I suspect that the knot in the side wasn't helping you here either.

disclaimer: I haven't turned a shape I've been 100% happy with yet and my set of attempts is still relatively small in the grand scheme so take this for what its worth based on that 8) Also this is all subjective and just my eye so I'm sure others would/should disagree or have better suggestions ;)

I really like the bottom and center part of the form, it has really nice continuous curve and draws the eye around the wood nicely. Its also a great for for a piece with that much grain since it really shows it off nicely!

I might have tried to round off the foot into more of a bead, but it looks pretty nice as is (and there's always the possibility of there being no foot left when attempting that).

I think it ends up a smidge to straight near the top side, but not egregiously so. The main area where I'd have probably tried to mix it up (and odds are failed and blown apart the interesting bits so I can understand why you were more conservative :O) is around the rim and the transition from the side to the rim. If that transition had been eased I think it would have alleviated some of the perception of flatness on the upper side of the form as well. I like beaded rims on some bowls but I think they distract some on natural edge pieces unless you're really really good at them.

I've taken the liberty of lightly photoshopping one pic to show what I was thinking of on the transition (only did the sides because my photoshop skills are.. stale is an understatement). I spent a bit more time on the right side than the left so if it looks uneven.. its because it is :D


Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Brad Vietje

Phillip, you've come a long way since working with Jamie. Much better surfaces and shapes!

Now, I have to agree with Dick that you need to find some better wood. These things really can come flying apart when spinning, and gluing them with CA might not prevent a catastrophic accident.

Read about Lynn Yamaguchi and you'll see that even a 6" to 8" piece of wood can do terrific damage, and could potentially kill you if its spinning fast enough. Lynn's web site is here: http://www.lynneyamaguchi.com/ and the recent article about her injuries is here: http://lynneyamaguchi.com/Yamaguchi_SafetyMatters.pdf

If you become better at scrounging for wood, and learn how to handle green wood to minimize checking, you'll have nice pieces without cracks, and avoid a trip to the emergency room, too.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Lyle Jamieson

How long did you take to turn and sand this, start to finish?? How long was it on the lathe??

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#9

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Brad, thank you for the advise. I'll share with you what happened to these pieces. In a past post I mentioned that I had about 30+ pieces which were done about 2/3 ways to finishing stage. For me it takes maybe 20 to 30 min. at the most and in some cases even less than that to shape and cut the pieces to what I want that shape to be. Some of these were done months ago and since I did not have enough knowledge as how to preserve them, so theye don't check or cracks develop or anything else that may happen to them. And hoping that when I come back to them they would be in the final shape that I originally intended. Some of these were done way before even taking Jaime's' class and I did them way months ago. Like in the case of natural edge it was done in April of this year then I could not figure out how to reverse chuck a natural edge to finally to get the foot off. After discussing the issue here on WC and figuring out how to finish it, and all the while bowl was sitting on a shelf w/o any protection on it which in our type of weather it doesn't help. Some of the cracks that you see which were CA glued; in case of the apple calabash bowl happened when I put it back on the lathe and start sanding it (I did not use power sanding and did it all by hand holding a back up pad pith sanding disk attached to it) and i ahve not sanded anything beyound 365 RPM almost about a year now. So, like in the Apple case those opened up along the grain rings and as I was sanding them then I did not finish them or applied any finish to it all in one setting, which in this case resulted for extra drying. When I originally shaped it I remember that I was getting shavings from it and I saved some so if I needed to repair it I have it.

All and all, these are the pieces that I am finally getting around to finishing them and all along I am learning all aspect of turning with these. Yes indeed I took more time to finish them, than most of you do and this is the way I am improving my turning. I started getting more careful about picking out the logs I want. A friend here was gracious enough to send me a fresh cut Russian Olive that he sealed for me and then he sent it, so I hope I can mange to rough it and finish it w/o any further checking and cracking. I am looking for better logs these days and will try to pick up what i can get and immediately seal it and also mange my timing of picking it up and putting it on the lathe. and try to get it to a finished stage.

Meanwhile i appreciate all of my friends here who take time to reply and give me tips and positive feed back as well as comments. This is the only way I can get better each day. I appreciate every one's patient while I am growing in this process.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#10

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Lyle, first of all I appreciate you taking time to comment and help me in my process of learning. I didn't record the actual timing of this piece. It took me a good while, however, it was not done in one setting and I had to learn different techniques to finish this. Please see the explanation I wrote to Brad. This piece as well as some of the ones that I am finishing are actually my learning pieces, what I mean is that they are helping me with different steps of the turning process, So in the interim I did not take time to preserve them properly, so when I come back to them most are very dry and I have to be careful with working with them. As, you can see in this piece most of those cracks happened as i was sanding and the delay of leaving it sitting w/o being protected of elements until I came back to it and finally finished it. On crack happened in the process of reverse chucking when I tried to tighten the tail stock and I went too far. the others happened as it was drying and sanding it. the main purpose here was to try to take it to the finishing line and keep it so I can see how far I go in my journey to becoming a better turner. This piece will stay with me. Not for gift or selling.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Lyle Jamieson

Looks like you're on the right track. I turn start to finish in one setting. If you want to double turn then discard the pieces that crack. Its not worth getting hurt as others have warned you many times. Its a good thing to see a crack - - -learn from the drying process - - - discard it - - - work on something safe.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#12

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

indeed Lyle. soon as i am growing more in this hobby I am looking for better quality of wood and hopefully try to employ all the tips I am learning from my friends to apply. I am coming to conclusion that my lack of knowledge about good wood preservation and preparations lead me to all this chaos I was dealing with. then again I hear form every one that most turners have gone through what I am going through and they just didn't' have the nerves to ask or too embarrassed to ask about it. I am a firm believer that if don't ask yo don't receive and in our case if I don't ask the qsn. i will never know that I do not know and don't have the knowledge., until when people just come out and say I am asking too much. Thans again for your support.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#14

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Rum, originally ther was a curved transition form the natural edge rim to the body and i had a beautiful foot on the bottom. However, I think I explained to Brad that I had lots of challenge with this piece, as everytime I was sanding it- it would open up at the grain rings. then at the end when I was trying to take the tenon off and finish off the foot I ran into the problem of the foot tearing up, because it was too dry and no matter what I did I was getting tear outs. then I thought I amy change the design and that's what worked, so, what you see is not the original design I started with. this piece taught me lots of tricks. like I mentioned at another reply, this one is staying with me, for my future reference and reminder of the things I learned. After I talked to Reed about WA apple he gave me lots of information which I was not aware of. Like you have to turn it when it is wet and almost to the finishing line then put it away to dry, but it's going to crack and twist. then other thing is that there are different types of apple tree and that one is just decorative one. so, when I make it back to WA, I am going to see my freind whom I go this one from and try to learn about it and maybe try to get some more from him. But, this time seal it before i even put it in the box to ahul it back to San Antonio, and as Lyle said finish the darn thing in one setting and then put it aside to dry for second turn.

Well, you see you guys are making my head go dizzy learning these stuff every day. I am hoping that one day i can pass these info.s to some one else when I earn that right. :)

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#15

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Rum

:D Completely familiar with how that goes :D

I'm offering the design critique purely in the "this is how I see it might plausibly be better in a perfect world" perspective with the understanding that perfect is rarely the world we live in (baring the work of some of the pros here). So please take my comments with that in mind as purely an abstract point of potentialities.

I've turned a couple of similar pieces to completion in one pass and let the warping land where it may which turned out... interesting.. in most cases (better in some than others, but interesting either way). The faster you can finish the rough turning the better imho, don't let the blanks sit around to long or .. well .. cracks and sadness >(

Also do keep your ears open for chainsaws in the neighborhood for opportunities, I've gotten some really decent wood that way (loml finds it pretty hilarious when I hear a chainsaw and say "that's the song of my people" as I run out the door :b). Even mediocre wood gotten fresh are better than the best wood gotten stale imho.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#16

barry rockwell

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Barry Rockwell

Phillip,

From your posts it sounds like you are concentrating on finishing up a lot of older pieces that have not been properly preserved, and may be already cracked or compromised. I suggest you leave the older pieces a little longer, or even discard some of them. The block of Russian Olive you got was totally sealed with Artisan Sealer from Craft Supplies within an hour of when it was cut on the bandsaw, but I would not let it sit for very long without turning it, especially in your climate. Where I live in Montana, it is also very dry, and everything will eventually crack if not sealed, and given enough time. My suggestion is that you either turn the Russian olive to finish thickness soon, no more than 3/8", let it dry, then finish sand it when dry, or at the very least, rough turn it to about 1-1/4", seal the entire bowl with Artisan or Anchorseal, store it in a cool area for 6 months to a year, then finish turn it. You are going to lose it if you wait very long, and then you will have just another piece of cracked, crappy wood. IMHO all wood needs to be sealed in your climate, as well as being sealed after rough turning to slow down the drying process. If I had your email address I would be happy to respond to you directly.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#17

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Lyle Jamieson

Agree, get over double turning for especially natural edge pieces. The natural edge masks the fact it is no longer round anymore.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#18

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Lyle, I am sorry,but I am not following your comment. Can you clarify please?

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#19

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Lyle Jamieson

My advice is to "get over" double turning. Its firewood. Your climate and wood handling methods have failed you over and over again. Just turn fresh wood to the finished wall thickness and give it a few hours to dry enough to sand. Yes it will not be round when it dries. Its OK, I cherish the character pieces receive from the drying process. Reverse it, clean the bottom up and sand it, put some finish on it - - - done deal, no cracks to fill and most importantly its not going to blow up in your face and hurt you.

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

#20

Re: Apple Natural edge Calabash bowl

Phillip Medghalchi

Thanks for the explanation