Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

About to go optical with my hollowing

Posts

About to go optical with my hollowing

#1

About to go optical with my hollowing

Dick Coers

Just about ready to turn a hollow form by camera. I had gotten interested in the 2 new systems out there. I then got some help from Josh Bowman from here, and now ready to make chips for less than $20. The USB endoscope camera I bought was on ebay for $13.99 shipped. It is 1mm larger in diameter than the laser pointer I use, but with a longer bolt, works great. Then add a fine point dry erase maker for less than $2. A good friend gave me an ancient laptop, and I had some transparency film. I'll see how it goes really soon. Small money for an experiment. Forgot to mention if it doesn't work out, the camera has LEDs and a 15' cord on it and can be used for looking inside home walls or anything that has a 15mm hole in it. Don't go there, no DIY colonoscopies!


Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#2

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Phillip Medghalchi

Dick, I was about to mention the other possibilities for your camera. But, I honor your request. Won't go there. However, it'll be cheaper though. :D

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#3

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Phillip Medghalchi

Ok, beside the joke above, how did you come up with that (contraption) clamping deal to hold the camera on that shaft, then also, what software are you going to use to see and measure the thickness of the wall? Please, elaborate.

I have a old lap top (Compaq) that is 256 processor, would that work? I think it ran on windows 97 if I am not mistaken.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#4

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

bernie feinerman

Hello Phillip,

check back to this thread

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/turning.pl/page/3/md/read/id/481465/sbj/not-fair-john/

which was about a camera hollowing rig seen at the Georgia Symposium by John Lucas. Tucked away near the bottom of the thread is a reply by Josh Bowman that sort of explains how the camera system works as a hollowing indicator.

Bernie

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#5

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Dick Coers

That is a Jamieson laser holder. To clarify, I make a LOT of my tools. Yearly tool purchases are based on yearly sales. (No need sending all that profit to the Feds, my expenses need to go up those years.) I had a good year in the past, so bought the Jamieson hollowing system, another year was leaner, so I made my own articulated system, but made an adaptor on it to carry this laser holder. What I really know about computers will just about fill a thimble. The camera comes with a mini cd and it says that with xp you can watch it directly, Vista or Win 7 need the software on the disc. I used the disc. To set cutting distance, you set a scale up next to the cutter so you can read a scaled distance on the screen. Read the distance on the lap top screen, and make a mark on a piece of mylar or transparency taped to the screen with a dry erase marker. Make a couple of marks if your eye isn't that good, then trace a line all around the cutter. If you are using a round carbide cutter, use a circle template to encircle the cutter. The camera is fixed in relationship to the cutter, the marks are then fixed to the camera position, so when the cutter disappears into the vessel, you still see the lines you made on the mylar taped on the screen. Almost like magic until you see it for yourself. There are youtube videos on the ones being marketed that show this cutter/line drawing theory.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#6

Am I missing something?

Ron Bauer

It seems that a laser does the same thing quicker, cheaper and just as accurately. I have four cutter adaptors that can be used when hollowing. A straight, a 22.5 deg, a 45 deg, and a 90 deg. Each requires a re-set of the laser. I presume each would also require a re-set of the camera which includes a screen overlay and new cutting lines to be drawn. Are we embracing technology just for the sake of technology? Just wondering. Ron.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#7

Re: Am I missing something?

Dick Coers

For me, it's a test to see if the transition areas go easier. I am guilty of not moving the laser enough, often going by feel and sound instead of taking the time to reset. I will have a complete envelope around the cutter tip. I should be able to have more confidence going from the undercut at the top, into the side, without moving a laser. Same at the bottom transition. I wouldn't say $20 is too much of a leap, and who ever said woodturners don't like new technology? Why use a laser if you don't like technological improvements?

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#8

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Hal Taylor

I, like you and Josh, are tinkerers. I looked on eBay and could not find the camera like you showed. How is the image?

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Am I missing something?

Lyle Jamieson

Very observant, right on. Another issue that has not been addressed is accuracy. We get a hard cue, a hard marker, fine feedback when the laser drops off the vessel. The laser shouts "STOP"!! We don't get that accurate feedback from the camera and line on the monitor. It just will not be as accurate when you want to do thin walled vessels like needed for piercing.

Those folks that are setting it once, to do a vessel, are not taking full advantage of what the laser can do.

On setting the laser often, that's the good news, again for accuracy it needs to keep the measuring perpendicular to the vessel wall. It takes 3-4 seconds max to reset the laser.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#10

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Dick Coers

If you send me a private message Hal, I'll tell you the ebay number. I don't want to take away from the guys that are marketing these too much. I think the image is just fine, my bifocals may be the problem with the screen positioning.

Time will tell Lyle. If the laser you sold was a pin point, instead of a more oval shape, I would agree more enthusiastically with you. My laser pointer has been working intermittently lately, and I have to fiddle with it just about every time I use it just to get any dot. I have to unscrew the lower section and barely snug it up to get it to light. If I tighten it to much, the light goes out. That's not why I am tinkering of course, just mentioning that the laser is not iron clad.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#11

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Phillip Medghalchi

Bernie, Dick,

Thanks both of you for your replies. Bernie, I was following the thread, so I was aware of that. Dick, thank you for elaborating the details.

Now, sometimes we as woodtrners like to reinvent the wheels, but when the cost of a new technology is little too hard to bear then I think our efforts can yield a satisfying results, and sure it won't cost $1000+.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#12

Ric Taylor

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Ric Taylor

Dick,

Would it be possible for you to take a pic of the image you are getting on your monitor and post it here?

Thanks,

Ric

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#13

pic of laptop screen

Dick Coers

Maybe not the best picture, but hopefully you get the idea.


Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#14

tighter screen pic

Dick Coers

closer image of the laptop screen


Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#15

Re: tighter screen pic

Stuart Johnson

I'm lost. How does this show you the location of the cutter tip?

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#16

Re: tighter screen pic

Dick Coers

I just took that picture to show the image quality of the camera. I did not have a line traced for the cutter. Here is one that I set an envelope around a tear drop scraper with dry erase marker with the tool outside the vessel, then moved it inside, and took a picture of the laptop screen.


Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#17

Lyle Jamieson

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

Lyle Jamieson

Sounds like you have a problem with the laser. Send me an email with your delivery info and Ill send you a new laser.

Its not the size or shape of the laser dot. It uses the gap between the laser and the cutter to measure the wall. Go back to my DVD for the tips to use the laser correctly.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#18

Very generous Lyle!

Dick Coers

Thanks for the offer to replace the laser Lyle, that's very generous of you.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#19

Re: tighter screen pic

Guy Bratt

I've read all these posts and looked at the dry erase picture. I still can't tell where the cutter really is. All I see is the outside of the vessel.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#20

Re: tighter screen pic

John Lucas

Those are not very good pictures to show how it really works. With that style system you won't ever see the cutter when its inside the vessel. You draw a line around the cutter when its outside the vessel. The line should be away from the cutter the distance you want the wall thickness. This is what you see on the screen when the cutter is inside. Depending on the magnification of the camera it can be very accurate. I think with the JT system he showed us it could easily show less than 1/64th accuracy. That's easily as good as the laser. With home brith home built systems I'm sure it would depend on the quality of the camera and the magnification

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#21

Lasers don't require a monitor

John Lucas

I might sound like I'm putting down laser systems and I'm not. They are very effective and easy to use. On simple forms it only requires moving the laser a few times once e you get close to your final wall thickness. When doing really thin walls for piercing it does require more adjustments if you need a really eve wall thickness.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#22

Lyle Jamieson

Its all about the fun

Lyle Jamieson

If your turning or making your own tools enjoy the process. If the laser is not working the fun cant happen. Should I use the address in the AAW book from 2013??

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#23

Re: tighter screen pic

Dick Coers

The dry erase picture shows where the cutter is at. Move the camera, it looks like that outline is moving. Watch the videos from Trent Bosch and JT Tools and it will show this more clearly.

Re: About to go optical with my hollowing

#24

Re: Its all about the fun

Dick Coers

I sent you an email, but that info in the directory is the same. Thanks again!