I have started using glue blocks following a recent thread about their benefits. I have been having trouble getting the CA to grab a wet (damp) blank. I use "Stick Fast" CA Thick and KWIK-FRAME activator. The surfaces are flat and well mated. I have glued the block and activated the blank and vice versa, both to no avail. Am I asking the system to do something it is not able to do? TIA for helpful comments. Ron.
Ron, CA is helped in the curing process by moisture. CA and wet wood were made to work together. Look at the process in my YouTube clip for the details. Thick CA, concave surface and accelerator, wait 2 minutes and it will never come off while turning. Don't leave the glue block on for long. If the wood dries it will weaken or break the glue line.
Accelorator makes the glue joint brittle. If you get a catch it can fly off. Use medium ca without accelerator and just give it a while to cure properly
As Lyle mentioned the moisture will catalyze the polymerization of the CA -- usually without any accelerator. If you can use the tailstock or other method to hold a piece where you want it, you may get a more secure join without the accelerator, as John wrote.
About 12 years ago I bought a few small bottles of accelerator, but I haven't used any in at least 8 years; the wood moisture and a little more time, perhaps, should do the trick.
I've been using Lyle's method for the last 8 months, in that period I have turned over 100 bowls and never had one come off. I've gone through 16 oz of the accelerator, just ordered more this morning. Yes it does make it brittle that's how you get it off the glue block when your ready to finish the bottom. Take the time to go to the link Lyle put on, it does work.
John, have there been tests to prove that accelerators will make a glue joint brittle? Or could this be one of those stories that get started and then be accepted as fact. Just wondering. I've used accelerator when attaching a glue block for many hundreds of pieces and I don't think that I've had any flying bowls. Not in a lot of years anyway.
Wally, it may be one of those myths that started somewhere, and it became norm of the trade. Oh,well, /i can not be sure of that until a chemist in us will prove me wrong.
I decided to run a test on my own. Will using accelerator weaken the joint when using a glue block and CA glue?.....
Using one of my glue blocks I glued it to a secure piece of wood using med CA and accelerator. I waited about ten minutes then started whacking the heck out of it with sideways blows using a heavy hammer. Made a mess of the glue block but it's still glued to the piece of wood.
If a CA glue block joint fails it's almost always due to not using enough glue....I always want some squeezeout.
Wally I've done the tests myself many times to prove it. I glue pieces together and then break them apart. Without the accelorator it often pulls a piece of the wood out. With accelorator it virtually always breaks at the glue line. In fact I can hit the wood real hard without using a prying action and it will come apart at the glue line.
I use the accelorator when gluing my mirrors so that it won't damage the wood or the glue block when I break the joint. When I teach I do the same thing. If I have a heavy handed turner who knocks pieces off I will tell them not to use the accelorator and it always stays on.
Not only will it break apart at the glue line but frequently the separation will be accompanied by a spray of glue dust/powder because of the crystalline nature of the glue when it sets up.
Back when my son was in Odyssey of the Mind, a creative problem solving competition, we did tests on the breaking strength of CA with and without accelerator. Time after time the bond without accelerator was stronger. Not only that but the bond actually strengthened overnight and seemed to be strongest after 12 hours or so.
I wonder if the two persons doing the testing did them the same way. Having experience in that realm, testing things etc.
I going to guess they were done differently as follows:
They each used different wood.
They didn't have glue surfaces the same
They didn't apply glue the same nor the accelerator
The didn't use the same weight hammer
Nor the same force etc etc etc
So my conclusion is this doesn't answer the question! Agree? or Not I'll continue to use yellow glue, I don't mine clamping and waiting one night. I only use regular formular Titebond not II or III
Gary I would disagree. I think to well mated surfaces give more glue surface. Unless you use excessive pressure and push out all the glue you should get a good glue joint. Fine woodworking did a test one time and found out with normal clamps it was impossible to squeeze a glue joint to the point of starving a joint of glue.
Also glues like yellow woodworking glues or Gorilla glue are not gap fillers. I'm wondering in this case if Gorilla glue would be a better choice for gluing 2 flat surfaces together, one being green wood. You add moisture to one surface when using Gorilla glue to help it set. So it would seem like the moisture in the green wood would do that. You would have to let it sit overnight.
IMO not true. I've been using the flat and true surfaces with squeezout for a lot of years and it certainly works for me. Yes, some folk use the concave surface and that works for them.
Gary, it seems obvious that the flat and true glued surface method gives a stronger joint because there is more glued surface. Tell someone who does flatwork that his glue joints should have concave surfaces and he'd think you were joking.
We used to be able to edit our posts...I can't find a way to do that anymore. Can anyone point me in the right direction?
Wally, if you don't see the option to edit your posts, it's because you came back and signed in with a similar name than you first signed up. When I look at your posts there is no email connection in front of your name. I had this problem happening to me for a long time between "H. Phillip Medghalchi" and Phillip Medghalchi". Ellis finally pointed out the problem.
You have to find the exact way you registered your name very first time you registered here in WC, otherwise you will not be able to edit your post.
I wish Ellis or the admin. will do something about this that the site will not let you post if your handle on the site is not correct, however, it does and this creates head ache.
I hope this will help. Remember, you go to the top of your screen and click on My Profile button, then yo ucome back and try to rmember how you first registered your name on line then after yo reenter your password it will go back to what your profile wa when you registered. If correct then you can not go back to all the posts that you made under the wrong wally Dickerman and edit them back. It won't let you just the ones that were posted under your correct registered name and emails are the ones you can edit.
If correct registered name is restored then at the bottom of your post you will see' Mnage posts with a window in front of it (drop down arrow) with choices of Edit, delete and then another one asking you to put in your passwrod.
I have been using the thick but general consensus is that med will be better so I will change to that. My main concern was the moisture effect which is nil so I won't worry about that. I like the activator because it DOES make the joint brittle hence easier to split off with a chisel. I don't have (or won't take ) the time to wait 12 - 24 hours for yellow glues to set. I always bring up the tail stock when I can for coring which is where most of the probs are. But that is not always possible with the smallest center core. I generally have good luck with CA but did still have some failures that get exciting. Hopefully those are behind me. I have no comment on ability to edit. Ron.
and using medium CA fills the subtle gap I'm referencing.
Obviously "flat" works well for others, but I've always done the subtle curve and always had good results too. As usual, there's more than one way... :-) ...GG
Phillip, thanks for trying to help. Fact is our system is very simple. Here is a recap for you and Wally and anyone else who was wondering....
If you want to be able to edit posts, post pics from your computer, format text, etc., you must register a profile.
Registering a profile is easy. If you don't have one, click My Profile and follow the bread crumbs.
If you have already registered a profile, AND you want all the perks of registration, you must post with the same profile name and e-mail address that you registered. No differences in spelling, punctuation, capitalization, etc. This is why I usually recommend that people use their actual name when creating a profile. Wally's profile, for example, is Wally Dickerman in Arizona. When he posts with the username Wally Dickerman, our system can't recognize him. You can always tell when someone is posting with an unregistered name, because it is in black instead of blue, and his email address doesn't appear.
If you've deleted or lost your cookies or you're using another computer or browser, you may have to tell our system who you are before you will be recognized. All you need to do is go to Set Preferences and type in your correct profile name and email address and hit save changes. Whe you go to post, you will be recognized.
I have the edit function set to two hours. That is how long a time window you have to make changes to your post. Beyond that, send me a note and tell me what you meant to say and I'll make the change for you.