Vacuum pumps, which one?
Philip F Duffy
What kind is best, within reasonable cost? I see pumps from $50 to 350 on ebay? All too confusing without some guidance from you experts on this site! THanks, P.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Vacuum pumps, which one?
Philip F Duffy
What kind is best, within reasonable cost? I see pumps from $50 to 350 on ebay? All too confusing without some guidance from you experts on this site! THanks, P.
Re: Vacuum pumps, which one?
Bill Boehme
Rotary vane is usually considered the best, but if it has an open port flow of about 4 CFM or greater and a blocked port vacuum of about 24 inches of mercury (that's about -12 PSI) then it ought to be just fine for almost everything. Just as important as the pump is a system with minimum leaks and good chucks.
Re: Vacuum pumps, which one?
Peter Lamb
Gast 524 ebay under Gast Vaccum Pumps
I Made The "Oil" Mistake
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
On a recommendation I opted for a rebuilt Robinair oil-lubed pump as it pulled 6 CFM. Mistake mistake! In short order I found myself working in an oil fog. I then had to bolt on an oil coalescing filter. I also had to keep checking the oil level. As I don't turn much in the way of bowls anymore I'll put it on Craig's List and buy a good oil-free pump with 4+ CFM when and if I need to use vacuum again.
Gast "23" series used widely for vacuum chucking
Rob Wallace
You can find used or rebuilt rotary vane vacuum pumps on eBay and other sites.
The "23 series" by Gast Manufacturing are a reliable performers; most opt for Model 0523, which has a airflow capacity of approx. 5 cubic feet per minute. The Model 0823 has about 8 cfm, and 1023 ca. 10 cfm airflow volume; all of these have similar "vacuum pulling" properties as to the level of vacuum pulled being around 24-26 in. Hg. which is perfectly adequate for vacuum chucking tasks for woodturning. I have three Gast Model 0523's - two in vacuum chucking service on two different lathes, and one for general "sucking" tasks, such as vacuum clamping and veneering. They are rugged and will last a very long time as long as you treat them well.
Check also with Surplus Sales in Lincoln, Nebraska, who has provided many good quality commercial grade Gast vacuum pumps at very affordable prices (some were 220V motors) over the years.
I agree with others who posted about the "horrors" of oil-based vacuum pumps - don't go there!! I have been working with commercial lab-grade vacuum pumps in laboratory settings for over 30 years, and have done my fair share of repairs and rebuilds (including electron-microscope, high-vacuum pumps), and you don't want to even get close to the problems you will have by mixing fine wood dust with oil in a vacuum pump. A non-starter component for a vacuum chucking system.
As you might suspect, your pump's design parameters will be important as to air flow level and vacuum capability, but as was mentioned, having a 'tight' system with few leaks (the wood bleeds through enough air on its own), and an adequate in-line filter to protect the pump are also very important aspects of a good vac-chuck system.
You might want to have a look at this site and do some reading before taking the plunge on a specific pump:
http://www.joewoodworker.com/veneering/vacuumchucking.htm
Good luck with setting up your system. Feel free to stop back and ask additional questions...... .......been there, done that, several times.
I have said this for years, "One you go vac, you'll never go back...."
Rob Wallace
Re: Vacuum pumps, which one?
John Stegall
Look at frugalvacuumchuck.com he came to SWAT and he must have sold 50. Five members of our club bought them and the ones who have finished theirs really like them. One buyer told me that the whole system was cheaper than a pump to rebuild his old system.
No financial interest. BTW, he was happy to answer questions when people couldn't figure out the next step. One guy was getting lower vacuum and the owner explained that higher elevations will give lower levels of vacuum. We are at about 1600 feet. But only ~1" per 1000 feet of elevation increase.
John
Re: Vacuum pumps, which one?
Jeff Smith
I've used two different pumps - the rocking piston or Wobl type - like the Thomas pumps sold by the frugal vacuum guy, and a Gast 23 series rotary vane pump. I must say - both are still chugging along. The Thomas type rocking pistom pump was my first attempt at a vacuum chuck and it worked well enough. The pump cost less than $50 on ebay and was a used pond aeration pump. I got a max of 24" with it - plenty for my uses then.
I kept looking for a Gast 23 series and finally found one brand new - as liquidated surplus inventory for $89 on ebay - too good a deal to pass up. With a better CFM than the Thomas and pulling consistantly at the gauge's maximum, it is a workhorse, and was brand new, unused when it arrived in the original packaging.
The Thomas is now used on my carving stand mounted to the bench.
If you can afford to wait, keep your eyes open, search ebay regularly and you can find deals...
Re: Vacuum pumps, which one?
Bill Boehme
I got my Gast 0523 on eBay as surplus lab equipment from a company that makes orthotics. I think that the prices was something like $30 and the cost of shipping UPS was about the same as the cost of the pump. Still a steal. After about 8 years, I installed a rebuild kit which consists of new vanes, gasket, and filter elements. It didn't really need a rebuild kit yet, but I got the kit on eBay for almost nothing.