Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Posts

Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#1

Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Blondterror

I run a small one man woodworking business (Tables, Stools, and Segmented Bowls) in my basement shop.

I am expanding my basement shop and installing a larger dust collection system with drop down connections for my table saw, bandsaw, planer, jointer, router table, and 2 lathes. I was thinking that my Drill press could go w/o a connection but am not sure on this... I expect to use grounded PVC pipe with Y joints and gate valves for each machine. I am relocated my dust collector to an outside shed to get the noise outside and make emptying the collection barrel easier and get the fine dust outside. I need to buy a new cyclone/dust collector to mount in this outside shed ... I do not want the unit to be too tall (6-7' at most) to keep my wife happy because the shed will be outside of our dining room bay window.

Any recommendations on a good unit that meets these constraints?

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#2

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Gary clarke

I am sure you know that this will draw heat out of your work place. I like my Oneida , still works well after 10 years.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Rob Wallace

I have been very happy with the Oneida Air Systems cyclone system that I use in my basement shop. You might want to check-out their range of cyclone systems. They are efficient and are very well built, with a number of different options for filtration components. You will want to return the filtered air to your shop after it goes through the cyclone/filters, particularly if your shop is heated or air conditioned (or both). The outdoor "cyclone shed" is a great idea, and I wish I could have done that, but in my situation it was not an option.

I might suggest that you re-think the use of "grounded" PVC pipe and "Y" fittings..... most plastic pipe fittings are not designed for good air flow characteristics (especially Ell's; DWV fittings have too narrow a radius), and despite your desire to have a good cyclone unit to drive the system, you will be starting with a system that is compromised from the very beginning. I have had several friends go the "PVC route" with their DC system, and ultimately have been disappointed in the performance of it, even after going through the time, effort, and expense of installing the PVC ductwork. Using metal pipe with fittings that are deliberately designed for proper air flow parameters will allow you to have an optimal system given your size and space constraints as best possible without the "built-in" compromise of PVC duct systems. Also, use the largest diameter pipe that your cyclone will handle for as much of the pipe runs as possible; stepping from 6" to 5" to 4" over the needed distances is far better than running all 4" diameter pipe (PVC or metal), with HUGE static pressure losses due to system resistance. (BTW - whatever you do - DO NOT use "corrugated" or "ribbed" tubing of any kind - they are the worst for increasing air flow resistance and greatly reducing efficiency of any system where they are used.)

The extra expense of properly designed metal ductwork pays off HUGE dividends in system efficiency, not just for static dissipation (you can't "ground" PVC, since it is a non-conductor), but more importantly, for system air flow efficiency. If you go plastic, you are likely to soon wish you had invested in metal ductwork. I have seen this happen all too frequently with fellow woodworkers over the last 20 years....

Rob Wallace

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#4

A Vote for PVC

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Rob is correct that standard el's form a too tight radius for PVC turns. This problem can be eliminated by using a pair of 1/8th bends (45°) and a short piece of straight pipe. The idea is to make your turns with a radius more than 150% of the diameter of the straight pipe to minimize the flow restriction. It's also a good idea to clean up the inside edges of the cut pipe.

I piped my basement shop with 6" D/W from a 1500+ CFM blower in my garage. Velocity of the airflow at the end of my longest run (60' including 4 90° turns) is 780 FPS. Close enough to optimal for me.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#5

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Blondterror

Thanks for the feedback... I just called Randy @ Oneida to help design a system around one of their 5 HP cyclones using their designed 6" metal pipe and 4" drops.

I have been happy with my Super Dust deputy and bet their custom system design will be even better... esp with the vac unit located outside in a shed attached the the outside wall of the shop.

I think the grounded metal pipe with the piping designed by people who do this for a business is a no brainer for me... I take a while to get down the learning curve-

Chris

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#6

Re: A Vote for PVC

Barry Irby

I agree with Mark. I used PVC and used two 45's for a ninety. Six inch mains and 4" drops.

I ran metal foil tape inside the pipe in the top and grounded it for part of the runs to cut static charge. Can't tell the difference. Static does not appear to be a problem.

I have my unit in a shed. Mine is not a cyclone, but a delta one bag unit. As far as heat loss goes, not a problem, but I only run the unit when I run a tool. I have the blast gates with the micro switches that turn the unit on. One thing though is I have a dog door at the end of my shop and when the unit runs, the door swings in. I suspect that there is a "tunnel" of cold air between the tool and the dog door. So It does not suck the heat out of the whole space, just the path to the door.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#7

Check That

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

with some colored smoke. Put the source outside the little door then turn on the DC and watch the smoke as it comes and moves (or doesn't) toward the open DC outlet. Interesting idea.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#8

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

robo hippy

With the pleated paper filters, there is no dust greater than 1 micron that goes back into the air, unless there are serious leaks in your pipe system. I would think you could get away with a 3 hp system, which should be capable of running 2 machines at one time. It is what I have in my 24 by 36 shop. Oneida is excellent. Clear View is another company that many seem to like, but I don't really know anything about them.

robo hippy

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#9

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Blondterror

My shop is about the same size as yours and I will only be running a max of 2 machines at one time (Jointer/TS) so the 3 HP Oneida system should work fine for me as well. I agree that making larger access in my TS (change from 4 to 6") makes a lot of sense.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#10

Re: Check That...I like it

Barry Irby

Good idea....I might try that. Wonder how I can generate some smoke?

My experience is that shop time is limited and sporadic. I seldom get to spend a day in the shop or any extended period of time. I have a window air conditioner and electric heaters. (cheap and not efficient, but inconsequential because the shop is small and the time limited.)

So, when the shop is either warmed or cooled, I find the DC has little impact on the condition. It may be the "dog door effect" or the fact that I only run the DC when a tool is on. I suspect that most of the heat or "cool" is stored in the thermal mass of the tools, walls and ceiling etc. Air does not hold a lot of heat so flushing some out sporadically may not remove as much as you might think. Turn the DC off and the temperature recovers rapidly from the surrounding materials and the fact that the heater or AC is running.

Another factor may be that I am relatively unconcerned about the comfort factor. If the air is above sixty and below about 80, I'm OK. In the house I am a little more touchy, but in the shop as long as I am moving around, I don't care. If I am going to spray or do a glue up, I let heat run long enough to reach a good temp for that. I leave the temp up (or down) long enough for the finish or glue to cure.

I don't generally run the DC while doing a glue up or spraying, But, come to think of it I did use it on my down draft table while spraying.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#11

Table Saw Dust Collection

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

going from a 4 to 6" port on your table saw may not be the best solution. Most often I find a 2-draw rig, 4" below and 3-4" above pulling from a blade guard is the most effective. This is what I have

I find it works quite well.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#12

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Dale Miner

Run a return line from the shed back to the shop. If the shed is fairly air tight, the air returning will be filtered and still contain most of the btu's that it had when leaving the shop.

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#13

Don't Forget

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The video. YouTube awaits!!! ;)

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

#14

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Dust Collection Upgrade... Need Input

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Bigger is not necessarily better in dust collector piping. Too large a pipe at any given point will lead to an inadequate flow velocity and allow dust to collect and perhaps clog the pipe. If Oneida is designing your system, they will take this into account in the design.

Dennis