Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Georgia symposium

Posts

Georgia symposium

#1

Georgia symposium

John Lucas

Just got back and had an absolute ball. Since a lot of folks come from my part of the country I know most of them so its like a big home coming. And of course I get to see my vendor friends as well. It really kept me hoping. Did a demo of the hunter tools and it seemed to go over well

Didnt get to sit through to many demos JT's new camera hollowing system is incredible. Takes a photo of your cutter and the. Pastes this outside your hollow form with a border that lets you set the wall thickness. No more adjusting a laser to be perpendicular to the sides.

Saw Don Geigers new radius stone trying jig. It leaves a slight radius on the stone so its easier to grind exactly where you want to. He said it was developed for flat woodworkers since it grinds their tools cooler m does that for turning tools as well

Learned a new technique with the shear sealer from mike hosaluk. Can't wait to try it out He was using it to turn a bowl that was 1/32" thick. He was t familiar with out cherry and promised to turn one thinner out of madrone this morning but I had to miss that

Re: Georgia symposium

#2

I'm confused

Dick Coers

"new radius stone trying jig"

"Learned a new technique with the shear sealer"

Huh? Care to clarify or describe what these are?

Re: Georgia symposium

#3

Re: I'm confused

John Lucas

I hate typing on my phone. Auto correct does funny things and the keyboard covers up what I'm typing on longer sentences. Make that a radius trueing jig.

Re: Georgia symposium

#4

Shear scraper

John Lucas

Mike does a push cut with a flat scraper held at a shear angle and its a square nose scraper on the inside of a bowl.

Re: Georgia symposium

#5

Re: Georgia symposium

Dale Bonertz

I am also confused. Didn't Trent Bosch come up camera hollowing tool? Is JT tooling making one now?

Re: Georgia symposium

#6

Lyle Jamieson

True, Trent had the original idea


Re: Georgia symposium

#7

Re: True, Trent had the original idea

John Lucas

JT tooling claimed they have been developing and perfecting this idea for over 2 years. I don't know who was first but do know the JT tool is better. Quite a bit more expensive than cobbling one up yourself similar to Trent's

Re: Georgia symposium

#8

Mike Peace

Re: True, Trent had the original idea

Mike Peace

I also talked to the developer at the forum. After listening to him and see the system, I have to believe it took him a while to develop the hardware and software. It is very slick! And expensive.

I do believe different folks can come up with similar ideas independently.

Re: Georgia symposium

#9

How expensive?


Re: Georgia symposium

#10

Re: How expensive?

Phillip Medghalchi

Dick, it maybe that top 1% of the turners can afford that. I have to wait until they spend their money and the the developer finally figures out that the other 99% will not pay him that much for it.

There is a new hollowing tool out there that I will not mention the name, but goes for $1200+ which I have to wait until two other Christmases. then wait for the top 1% buy it; then maybe I may consider it at much lower price. Until then I have to hollow with the traditional way.

Re: Georgia symposium

#11

Not fair John

Dale Bonertz

John,

I have seen JT tools and they are nicely made, however saying Trent's is cobbled together is being very unfair to Trent. Trent has spent a lot of time and money developing his and it is a nice piece of equipment.

Re: Georgia symposium

#12

Bill Blasic

Re: Not fair John

Bill Blasic

Looked at them both at SWAT and in my opinion and this is just my opinion it is basically the same as using the laser dot on your hollowing system. Instead of looking at the piece you are looking at a monitor with your piece with the tool tip superimposed over it to show where the tool is inside. That is what the laser dot does. And that $1200 hollowing tool Phillip mentioned I'll bet if you asked someone who owns one they would tell you it is worth every penny.

Re: Georgia symposium

#13

Re: Not fair John

John Lucas

I didnt say Trent's was cobbled together. I have seen several cobbled together systems including the one I am putting together. Should have worded it differently. Trent's is a fine system but in my opinion because of the software and extremely ridged contstruction of the JT system it is definitely a step above

Re: Georgia symposium

#14

Re: Not fair John

John Lucas

I respectfully disagree. I've been using a laser for years. To be really accurate you have to constantly adjust the laser to be perpindicular to the wall of the vessel where you are cutting.

With the camera systems you either draw a line around the cutter or with the JT system the software will draw the line. On e the lines are there you can cut anywhere I side the vessel without making any more adjustments very easy to use.

Re: Georgia symposium

#15

The laser dot doesn't give you location

Dick Coers

all around the cutter. You have to stop and move the laser in the transitions near the top and bottom, and if the side profile has dramatic changes in direction. If you're making money with hollow forms, this looks like a winner to me.

Re: Georgia symposium

#16

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Not fair John

Lyle Jamieson

What happens when you move the swiveling cutter or put a different boring bar in to get the different shapes you want??

Re: Georgia symposium

#17

Re: Not fair John

John Lucas

On the JT you just hit a button and it tked a photo of the new cutter or cutter position and draws the wall thickness line around it. Really cool and relay fast. With Trent's system you draw around the new cutter. Still pretty darn quick m

Re: Georgia symposium

#18

Re: Shear scraper

Bill Boehme

"..... its a square nose scraper on the inside of a bowl"

Say what? Next thing I know somebody will be talking about using a skew on the inside of a bowl. So how do you go about not digging a corner of the square scraper into the wood?

Re: Georgia symposium

#19

Re: Georgia symposium

Bill Boehme

Trent was the first to bring his to market. I saw it at SWAT. As an engineer, my impression is that it was elegant simplicity. It may not have looked as glitzy, but a simpler design offers many advantages such as better reliability, longer MTTF (mean time to failure), lower parts count, lower cost, and easier maintenance. I also saw the JT version and it was painfully obvious that they weren't ready for prime time. I waited patiently while they tried to get it to work and finally left while they kept fiddling around with cables and software. When it did briefly work, the video was crappy. It looked like an obvious rush job and I find it unbelievable that it could be two years in development. They should have been able to design a Martian Rover in that length of time. They hopefully had their problems worked out by the time that they got to the Georgia Symposium, but what advantages does it offer?

Re: Georgia symposium

#20

Re: Not fair John

josh bowman

I don't think John was referring to Trents system as cobbled, his is build very nice. I think he might be taking about mine. After seeing Trents, I ordered several small security camara's off of ebay. I then connected them to a 19" monitor and made a fitting to hold the camera above the boring bar. The system works great. You position the camera just so the cutter is on the tv screen. After applying a clear plastic sheet to the tv screen, I trace the outline of the cutter plus the HF thickness desired. Then cut away. Alignment can be verified each time you pull the cutter out to clear shavings. If you change cutters or position, you merely retrace the new outline. It works well. JT's is much more advanced but works on the same principle and real slick, but expensive. If you "cobble" one together yourself, it will cost somewhere between $30 to $150, depends on the TV and where you buy the camera. If you like tinkering, this is pretty easy.

Re: Georgia symposium

#21

Answer to the hollowing system mentioned above

Phillip Medghalchi

Bill, I wanted to make sure that it is clear that I am not condemning the hollowing system that I mentioned, was just saying that after he sold lots of them then the price would be lower, since his cost will go down and I may consider it then. His tool is very stout and works what he wanted to do, and accurate too. all I was trying to say is that the price right now is not the norm of most turners and most of us can not afford to fork out that much money. I am friends with him and he knows that I admire his talent and innovation. At this stage of his production his cost is higher and therefore his respective price to sell is higher too. So, I just wanted to clear that out.

Most of these guys who make these tools, putting in their own time and therefore their asking price is kind of high for their respective products.

Re: Georgia symposium

#22

Bill Blasic

Re: Answer to the hollowing system mentioned above

Bill Blasic

Phillip,

By no means did I intend to demean you, I understood you completely. Just commenting on the quality and construction of the system. And as far as the laser goes I normally make three adjustments. 1. When I put in the straight tool to rough out the first section to get the swan neck tool in. 2. When i put in the swan neck tool to finish the shoulder and a little down the side. 3. When I put the straight tool back in to finish the side and bottom. If I were to aim for a 1/32" thickness I might make a few more adjustments but for 1/8"+ to a 1/4" thickness what I do works fine. Knock on wood, since I started using the laser systems I have never gone through the side or bottom of a hollow form. For 98% of the hollow forms I do I use Kelton or John Jordan hollowing tools.

Bill

Re: Georgia symposium

#23

Re: Answer to the hollowing system mentioned above

John Jordan

Bless you my son. :)

John

Re: Georgia symposium

#24

Re: Shear scraper

John Lucas

There was a very slight radius to the nose and be had knocked off all the sharp corners of the tool like many people do with rectangular skews To change the radius to match the inside of the bowl he simply increases or decreased the shear angle.

Re: Georgia symposium

#25

Joe Fleming

Re: Georgia symposium

Joe Fleming

Dumb question. Who is JT? Thanks, Joe