I like to carve feet on my turnings, but *LINK*
Keith Newton
Sometimes as I stumble along without first having had an inspiration, I'm not always pleased with the outcome. I'm still struggling with one, wishing I'd not done a couple of things.
The first one in the link below, is a good example. I have not done an end-grain turning in a long time, and was thinking about how easy it should be carving flutes, which I did before even hollowing. Then when I got down to the feet, because I've been using chisel marks in between the feet lately, I thought I would add extend the flutes below the step. I guess this falls under the heading of "Gilding the Lilly" heading, because now I'm thinking less would have been more. I think the fluting between the feet would have worked with smooth sides, or smooth between the feet with fluted sides.
Then, I sure wish I hadn't scorched the step. I'm thinking about carving that off, wondering if there might be something I can do to improve that, like more texture? Or just try to cleanly carve the scorching away, then carve the flutes away between the feet? Or should I just go drink a beverage and think about it?
Also, I know a lot of you have methods of keeping your lids from falling off. I included a shot of a simple method I've been using a long time. I turn a ring under the top, then carve / grind away most leaving two tabs on the end-grain, then cut only one key slot through the seat, off to one side of where the grain lines up. Since I turn green, both will shrink into ovals, which will limit the rotation, when they are close in size.
The two similar ones are cremation urns, for a son, and grandson for one of my friend / patrons.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/sets/72157647296922197/



