Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Posts

Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#1

Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

H. Phillip Medghalchi

Hi, folks, I had a wonderful time learning from a pro turner this last Fri. (yesterday)

I can describe him as a very nice, informative, patient teacher. He takes his time helping you one on one and he even helped me to get the hang of holding bowl gouge right and introducing it correctly to the wood. He is verbally capable and very clear in conveying his thoughts to his students and what I liked about him is that he has good sense of humor and can tolerate any one student at their respective level. We had a great different talents and skill levels in my class and I noticed that he was talking to each one of us at our own level w/O showing any sign of frustrations. The other great quality I liked about him is that when he comes across a common mistake or something he may think that his students may run into on their own while alone in their shop, he stops the class and asks every one to come to that particular student's lathe and take note of that mistake or the important incident w/o embarrassing the student and calling the other students as why it happens or what to watch out for and how to avoid it or what to do with it. He is a very gracious man and a great person to make friends with and he is funny.

OK, now that I took the class form here on out he is holding me to a higher standards and I am supposed to produce much better turnings. so, maybe you guys would see better Phillip's turnings form now on.

I highly recommend taking his class, and I can assure you that he will not make fun of you if you do not know all the stuff the pro turners know. No matter what your skill levels are you would benefit form his class. He asked me that not to take my turnings home and try to finish sand them or do anything further to them, but to keep them as an example and come back to them often and try to improve upon them further. so, when i put up the pic.s please do not comment as them not being sanded or having tool marks or other rings around them, because we were not supposed to take any sanding equip. with us and this was just to learn techniques. Now, later on when i go practicing to make those forms then you can comment all i can take the beating for.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#2

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Ok, that one was screwed up so I had to change my log in name, Phewwwww........... that alone is a class.

Here are the pic.s

First one is his work that he is teaching us to learn to turn it, it was a big leaf maple blank, I guess, so shame that I turned it too thin.



Next one is he and I and yes we can goof around too, at the end of the class.



On this one we are behaving



OK, first lesson:

Top of the up right wing bowl



Bottom of the up right bowl



Inside of this bowl



Side view



Next is the second class. Due to the blank thickness limitation we were limited to what we could design and I had the gooffy little super mini Jet lathe that limited me to the size of the blank. Oh, well the learning was more inportant, right? Ok this balnk was poplar. If I knew I would have taken a nicer blank with me.




and at this stage I can not finish them anyways there are no ways to re-chuck them. So, these are for me to keep and for you guys to keep my secret.

Thank you all for viewing these, and I did have a very good day, and a balst with Jamie. Now, I wish only he could take me along in his luggage to New Zealand too, But he said I am way down on the list, no chance. Just imagine what we could do with all those exotic woods? :b

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#3

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Rum

Looks like a lot of fun.

Have wanted to do one of those winged bowls for a while but haven't gotten up the courage :O

Looks like the class is a good way to get a handle on the form anyway!

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Keith Tompkins

Way to go, Phillip! Jamie is one of the "good guys"!

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#5

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Thank you Keith, I needed a class like this to have one on one to figure out what I was doing or not doing right. It paid off and I made a friend too. next we need to get you down here

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#6

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Rum, not only it was fun, but Jaime's full attention to detail makes it even more interesting.

Now, I have tried to make hose wing bowls before, however, I was going the wrong way about making it. There are more details and steps that go into it than the final object. I was not aware of those detail to yield a beautiful piece. I am glad I took this class, because not only I learned the right way of using the tool, but also, his teaching will help me to do other things with what I've learned.

I can sum it up that once you know the basics and the principles then lots of door s open up to you then all you have to dole your imagination take you where you want to go as for your designs. what I admire about him is his patient and respect to each student realizing that each one of us had a different learning curve. he was very good with that. i have mentioned in my previous threads and posting that not everyone knows how to teach adults. And there are many pros that are not good at communicating what is on there minds to some one else to produce same results. Jaime was very clear and if you really had hard time to visualize what he was conveying to you then he would draw it on your blank and help you to get to that point of design. He also taught me to understand about different noises of the toll coming in contact with the wood meaning different things were to happen and avoiding it.

Now, if you take any classes with him, keep your hands off his tools they are more than scary sharp. You can get yourself in trouble if you haven't used any sahrp tools like he does.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#7

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

BTW, I forgot to mention that on the first blank there were no signs of that bark inclusion in the blank until I got to almost the bottom of the bowl and we did not have the mixture of lacquer thinner and acetone to stabilize the wood preventing tear out and the hole that you see is that I was trying to learn if i can clean it out with sheer scraping until it got too thin.

On the second one, no sanding paper on hand as well as my hollowing tool to make the rim undercut, so it could not be completely finished.

These for the very critiques in you.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Brad Vietje

Fantastic, Phillip!

I can see great improvement already -- your cuts are smoother and you did a great job getting that subtle S-curve on the outside of the first bowl.

Square-edged turning are not easy, and a little frightening at first, but you did a great job on these. Forget the sanding -- the cuts are so much smoother than you were making just a few days ago!

I'm assuming you used gouges in Jamie's class more than the carbide scrapers? The pieces look like they were cut, not scraped. You'll get chatter on the "wings" of a thin edge, and especially on a square edge piece. This can be greatly reduced or even eliminated with practice, careful attention to the exact angle of the tool bevel approaching the spinning wood, not pressing against the wood, and sometimes a little more speed -- but ONLY if the wood is safe and sound. Gives a new meaning to "safe & sound". Still, most people have to resort to a little hand sanding on these wings (I certainly do).

You are well on your way to having a lot more success at this -- nice progress.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#9

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Brad, thank you so much for your words of encouragement. You are absolutely right. First of all we were not allowed to take any carbide tools to the shop and honestly, I was little intimidated by using the gouge on my own, since I never had a formal one on one training as how to hold the gouge or introduce it to the spinning blank. there is whole lot of different watching those you tube videos and not seeing or feeling where exactly the tool comes in contact with the wood concurrently at the same time knowing how the operator holds the handle in respect to his body and the wood. You can watch all you want and it won't make any sense until some one is watching you and catching what your body position and the tool position to your body and how you introduce it to the wood. he was able to catch me doing what I was not supposed to do and corrected me right then and there. I really appreciated his effort. now, I have to jump in there and start practicing it before my brain forgets it. ( in the past I was using EWT rougher and the round tool most of the time to shape and I think that contributed drastically to the cuts I was getting. I am glad I learned the right tool for the right job.

As for the square edge bowl turning, I tried it on my own being inspired by the design, but not knowing all the details that take to achieve that particular design I never succeeded. There is a very subtle steps to get to the final result and I think Jaime has mastered that and was able to share it with us. On the other hands, I had this Jet super mini lathe, which had a small swing so I couldn't use the right size blank ( what I mean is that you have to use a fairly decent size blank to master all the steps before you can resort to making smaller size square winged bowls); additionally, the lathe was sitting loose on the table not anchored or clamped and the tail stock and the tool rest were in my way in order to get a decent angle on the bowl gouge. I managed to focus on the lesson rather than on the lathe, and those tear outs that you notice in the first bowl was due to not having the lacquer sanding sealer and acetone on hand to stabilize the fibers to get a cleaner cuts. I was paying more attention to using the tool to get a sheer scrape cleaning than using the sanding method. I was aware that it would be available in my shop and I can do that on my won, but needed very much to learn the correct sheer scarping method.

this was a totally fun class, and he did not put us to sleep despite some other demos I attended in the past that they did that. He walks around the shop and spends time with everyone high lighting what that individual needs to improve and if he catches something that benefits the whole class then he calls everyone to that lathe to emphasize the importance of it.

I am planning on doing those wing bowls in other woods that I have to improve on them and see if I can get the whole skill under my belt. I like the design very much and he ahd all variations of them to inspire us.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Brad Vietje

Excellent -- sounds like you had fun.

Not sure if you will find the same thing, but I have found that the hardest woods are the best for turning, not the softest. For something delicate, like these square edged bowls, I like Sugar (hard) Maple, Mesquite, Eastern Hophornbeam (a.k.a. Ironwood), or a good dense wood like Osage Orange or Black Locust. Softer woods like Cedar and Boxelder are just too soft and flexible, so the chatter is worse -- at least, that's what I have found. Cherry & Walnut are OK, but harder and finer grained seem to work best for me. They also hurt more if you screw up and get whacked by a spinning corner!

I hope you can put all Jamie's good lessons to work for you, and have continued success.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#11

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Thank you Brad. Oh, BTW, I paid my dues in learning this technique. On the 2nd bowl exactly about 2-3 min. towards the end my left hand fingers swept ont he delicate feet and didn't break them, but knocked off about 1/8" fiber off the side of the feet on the top and I just got lucky that i pulled my hand away quick. Oh, well now I can say I was in a class at least.

Oh, be on the look out for a surprise on that sweet gum I was going to throw away. I did some experimentation and it came out OK. I try to post the pic. tomorrow or soon when i put finish in the inside and call it done. I think, I learned some tings form it too. It's just going to be kept in my own collection for reference. surprisingly, it held up very well, and i managed to hollow out under the big belly to the right thickness, until ................. Rest is coming up soon. Stand by for more news

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#12

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

John Lucas

Brad. Interesting thought. I haven't really experimented with different species being the culprit but part of my mirror demo includes turning away the square corners of my mirrors. I demonstrate how the pressure on the bevel and forcing the cut both affect chatter and how clean the cut is. Really light pressure on the bevel is probably the best way to reduce chatter besides a sharp tool

Of course.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Mike Stafford

I find chatter is caused most of the time by excessive pressure by the user of the tool. Newbies push the tool too hard into the wood. This is also as John said the result of using a tool that is in need of sharpening.

Dull tools are also the main reason some people find the cutting edge too hot to handle. By pressing so hard to get the tool to cut it heats up by rubbing against the wood. A tool should easily engage the wood and start cutting with minimal pressure. Just like a sharp knife will not skate across your fingernail whereas a dull knife will; a dull tool skates and a sharp tool cuts. It took me a long time to learn that turning was not only easier but also more pleasurable with a sharp tool.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Brad Vietje

Mike & John,

I agree completely -- pushing too much and a less-than super-sharp edge will cause chatter and/or torn grain every time. Going beyond that, I think the stiffness of the wood can contribute too, at least when the object gets fairly thin.

It seems counter-intuitive, but I think a hard, fine-grained wood works better than a softer species. I could be full of wax on this, too! You would think -- all other factors being equal -- that a denser wood would result in a little more cutting resistance, and set up some sort of additional vibration, but I get the sense that the added stiffness outweighs this (?)

Obviously, more data is needed; maybe when I get some decent turning time I can try something softer, like Boxelder or Basswood, vs something hard and fine-grained, like Sugar Maple. Another variable is fine grain vs coarser species, like White Ash or Red Oak. I've made some pretty thin turnings out of all of these, but haven't made side-by-side square edged pieces to test my half-baked idea. It does seem like I had a tougher time with a square-edged piece in White Cedar, but then again, that's a pretty miserable species to cut cleanly under any circumstances!

I use a 3/8 detail gouge with a long bevel and a fingernail profile for this work, honed with medium, fine and extra-fine diamond hones (down to 12 microns, I think) and make every effort to hardly touch the heel of the tool against the wood at all. I should try a 2nd bevel or a heel polishing step to relieve the hard edge of the heel of the bevel even more (and allow the bevel to get in at an even better angle), and see how much I can relieve the cutting resistance -- less is definitely better!

Getting past deferred taxes and fall chores has to come first -- turning tests will have to wait a bit at my end. If either of you get a chance to try it, please let us know what you find -- I'll take your word for it.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#15

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Brad,

I agree, in this class, the first bowl was maple ( I do not recall if hard or big leaf or which kind) but I could see it flexing unless I went too thin on it. however,, the second one was a poplar and it cut differently and I was able to work with it easier. Now, visually maple offered a more stringy fibers and it was tearing up versus poplar that cut easier. I do not consider myself as experienced as you guys, but it felt that way and I think if I try it on mesquite or harder, denser wood i would have a better luck. For the sake of this thread I will try to make few out of the woods I have and report back. I try to repeat the same design as I am turning them to see what really happens. And, I think if some other people chime on this we may get a better picture of this phenomenon. Although we already know that on some woods certain cuts won't hold up though.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#16

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

John, in the class the guy behind me and another guy across the way were both pushing the tool in harder than they should, and the guy behind me ended up messing up the corners and had to modify them and ended up having a bowl that resembled a scalloped shape. Plus the thickness got all screwed up. Luckily, inmy case Jaime was close by and caught on to the sound and stopped me and helped me to understand the cut and also, helped to understand that yo only get one shot at it and when it's screwed up then you can not go back and your square edge will not be just that. Now, your mirrors i gather are much more delicate than these and I guess you mess up the edges then your done with the project, right? But, my qsn . is that when yo get chance can you look at your pieces and see what kind of wood you seem to use the most and I am sure you'd remember which one gave yo little grief when you were making them. And, I think if you find more of one wood than the others that tells you it cuts better.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#17

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

John Stegall

I too took Jamie's class and totally agree about the benefits of taking a class like this. The first thing he did was inspect everyone's gouges and explain the whys of sharpening. He even made the statement that for most wood turners, sharpening correctly will go a long way toward improving your skill level.

Like Phillip I really appreciated how having someone of great skill (Jamie has been doing this for 28 years) watch you and then show you how to do it correctly. I actually got to take a day and a half of this class because I drove the student who discovered just how scary sharp Jamie's gouge (Flex cut carving) really was. 9 stitches later I was awarded a second day for my efforts...

I was getting much smoother cuts just by having JD show me the correct presentation of the gouge to the wood.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#18

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Well, heck. tom's loss of the day worked out better for you John. Of course, I hope that Tom's hand will heal fast. After you and him left Jaime said that he forgot to warn us to keep our hands off his tools. So, you got an extra few hours of hands on.

Of course, like you said having someone to actually watch us and tell us what we do right or wrong is a priceless lesson. Especially, now that he taught us how the gouges have to be sharp. I actually used the same gouge he sharpened on Fri, again today and cleaned up a bowl I had trouble getting the tear outs off of it. I think we both and ll the ones who attended will benefit from this a lot. Provided that we practice before the mind will forget, which is within 36 hours of the lesson, not a week, month, or maybe later. of course, he is a great teacher too.

I ahve to call Jamie and get him to send me a hunter #5 for endorsement. :D

I wish. :b

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#19

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

John Stegall

As to the free Hunter #5, remember he told us he does not sell tools ;>} Buy the new replacement cutter and pick up a 1/2" round bar then taper it down to 3/8", now tap a hole the proper distance from the end to mount your new cutter. Be sure you grind the tip of your bar underneath the cutter to match Mike Hunter's profile. See what fun you are going to have.

Tom says his hand is healing. I could have loaned him my Kevlar carving glove.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#20

Mike Stafford

That gouge is deadly....and evil!

Mike Stafford

Several years ago I was taking Jamie's 'It's Hip to Be Square' class and that same Flex Cut gouge bit me resulting in 5 stitches. Fortunately it was on the last day of class so I did not miss anything.

However, for all the years since I have been subjected to a deluge of barbs and jabs and Our Miss Kitty, SpongeBob Squarepants and My Little Pony band-aids. Jamie takes some kind deluded pleasure in watching his students skewer themselves on his surgically sharp gouge.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#21

Re: That gouge is deadly....and evil!

John Stegall

Mike, that is funny. Luckily for me I just did the driving. That is the fartherest I have ever had to drive with my flashers on...~10 miles.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#22

Re: That gouge is deadly....and evil!

Phillip Medghalchi

Mike. after I was done with my second winged bowl he asked me to hand it over to him so he can knock the nob off the bottom, so I watched him how he held the tool in his hand and he carved it away from himself not towards, and I am not sure how you or Tom figured that evil tool would be used pointing towards you.

I am sure that you and Tom will not go anywhere close to Jaime's tool again? :b

Beside the joke Tom didn't seem to have too much fun after the incident. I am hoping for a fast recovery for him.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#23

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Rum

Phillip said: "I ahve to call Jamie and get him to send me a hunter #5 for endorsement. :D"

Haha I was thinking that Jamie should have you as an official endorser, although you don't seem to be alone :)

Seriously its to bad (good?) that John C Campbell is so far away or that week long class in Jan would start looking pretty tempting here.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#24

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

Phillip Medghalchi

Rum, any class you can take, on an one on one basis is worth it.

Re: Report On the Jamie Donaldson's class

#25

For Engravers it's the Lozenge graver

charlie belden

A lozenge graver is an 1/8th inch square piece of steel, the end ground back at maybe 45 degrees. Referred to in the engraving trade as the Johnson & Johnson graver since it comes with a large box of their band aides. When one slips out of a cut - and your left hand moving the engraving block gets above the top of the jaws holding the work - this thing will go in 1/2" to 3/4" into the muscle between your thumb and index fingers. When pulled out there's a popping sound. Within 4 hours the stabbed hand will swell up like a balloon. Three days minimum before that hand is useable again.