Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Sweet gum qsn.

Posts

Sweet gum qsn.

#1

Sweet gum qsn.

phillip Medghalchi

what's with this wood that it cracks right in front of your eyes?

After last few discussions we have had on this forum, I have been very careful about picking my blanks, so I decided to do someething with this sweet gum timber. I have brought this and two other pieces of logs from WA, on one of my last trips. The story is that when I got these logs they were very wet and soggy. They were cut from my mothers' caregiver land in March of 2013, so when she got it to me i think it was just few days that they we cut, but I didn't bring them back to San Antonio because of the weight, back then so I left them in my sister's garage in the basement (those crawl spaces under the houses in great NW. for those of you who live there, Maybe Dennis, and Robo Hippy). OK, then I went back in July of 2013 and this time I brought it back to San Antonio. I tried to turn two bowls and this one vase. this vase is one of the last two pieces left. the first two bowls blew up on me even though they were not that thin to fall apart. It just every time I left to go take a break and came back the darn thing would crack.

Now, what you see bellow is a piece I had that there were no cracks in it so I went to turn it and decided to design it to this kind of a vase shape. (please note that the log was not cut on an end grain, so that possibility is out, the grain were perpendicular to thh lathe beds)


So, I proceed and then I go inside to take a break and came back and there it was a crack opened up, So I decided to proceed to do the hollowing, and as I was hollowing which is not completely finished yet (I still have to hollow out about 3/16 or so around the inside where the belly is to make it universal) I noticed more cracks started to develop. I immediately put some thin CA glue to stop them going any further, then hollowed out some more.

I then decided to smooth out the outside and get rid of the tear out. so, I used sheer scraping with my gouge and also, used a brand new negative rake sheer scraper that I just bought form Doug Thompson, so it was very sharp ( I only used it one time to really get a slick finish on some Bradford pear, but honed it a little bit to make sure that it was really sharp)

Now, no matter what I did you notice that this darn wood will not let up and I still got tear out, so I put some soapy water and tried to sand it with 80 grit to see what happened and that made it worse, so I brought it inside the house and called it a night.

QSN. is it that because I am not sweet enough to turn a Sweet Gum? :D Or is it just the characteristic of this wood, and would you continue or just give up on this if it was you?

Any help will be greatly appreciated, and to put you guys little at ease I am taking Jamie Donaldson's Class this Fri, in Kerrville, TX and I will show it to him, but I like to get your input.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#2

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

Barry L Elder

Just a W.A.G. from the swamps of Florida! Do you think moving the wood from the Great Soggy NW to the Deserts of Texas would have a radical effect on the shrinkage rates of the wood, when turned green? :D

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#3

Steven Antonucci

On torn end grain and drying

steven antonucci

If I was buying wood or had any money tied up in shipping it, I would take an abundance of caution in processing it if it was green. For starters, the movement of wood sometimes includes to movement of its residents (bugs) too. I used to trade a lot of wood, and I really do not much any more to avoid any issues with bugs.

That said, if I do get wood from another part of the country, I burn all of the cutoffs ASAP just to avoid having them lay around. You can usually use visual inspection to see if there are any bugs in the piece you are turning. If there are, I give them a DNA bath.

Drying wood is all about releasing moisture at the rate with which it can be released without changing the stresses in the wood too quickly. When I taught at Peters Valley a few weeks ago, we wrapped EVERYTHING in plastic until it was used, and then in paper bags on lunch breaks and after hours. You should get in the habit of limiting sunlight/heat/airflow on green wood, even if you are just taking a bathroom break or answering a phone call. Keeping a paper bag close by to slip over the turning is a simple way, and I close the end with nothing more than just twisting the bag by hand.

As far as the tear out goes, it could be a number of things. First, you need to treat that area like a cove on a spindle turning, cutting from the high point down to the middle from either side no matter what tool you use. Second, if you are using a scraper, you probably need to shear the cutting edge. A flat presentation is almost guaranteed to tear out . This can be hard to do, and you may be better off with a spindle gouge (which is what I would use to cut this area).

Lastly, it is really hard to tell how proficient you are with the scraper? If you had a second, perhaps you could post a video to your Youtube channel, and it would help to "see the unseen"?

Steve

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#4

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

Rum

Limited experience with Sweet Gum (only one tree this year) so take this for what that's worth.

The pieces I didn't turn right away (within ~4 weeks of cutting the tree down) all cracked into uselessness pretty quickly. Even the ones where I'd cut out the pith (actually those seemed even worse for some reason). I didn't have anything to seal the ends with on hand (was planning on turning them all right away but life interfered). Where I'm at it was HOT (100F) and real dry during the time the uncut pieces were sitting out which sure didn't help either.

I've read (afterwards of course) of some luck wrapping the pieces in plastic while wet - which causes them to spalt as well, so there is some limit on how long until they are uselessly punky doing that.

The pieces I turned are still mostly in roughed/drying stage so some hand waving about the future here :D

They mostly seemed pretty ok while drying. I put them in a plastic garbage bag with wet shavings and took them out to turn/air (for an hour or so just to flash off the surface moisture) twice a week for the first 3-4 weeks. A couple I left out to long (which were started to develop some surface cracks which I slathered with white glue and they seemed to close back up and look ok so far, we'll see once I get them re-turned.

I've turned two pieces from that tree to finish.

One was in a spot that was just a bit punky around the one side and man was it a pain for tear out! I managed to get the outside looking ok after soaking it with sanding sealer and working it down with 80 grit. I eventually gave up on the inside because the wood had pulled up to deep and I'd have had to sand pretty much through the sides to get all the problem areas fully solved.

The other piece was better and turned up pretty nice. I had a couple of spots on the side of the inside where some small chunks wanted to "pop" out if there was any vibration while turning. Mostly solvable by taking really light finishing cuts. This was using a 5/8" thompson gouge with a modified fingernail grind.

The pieces with their best side to the camera... The vase like thing on the right is the problematic one, you can see where the sanding sealer differentially colored the wood around the bottom (the other side is worse and the inside.. well.. sigh!).


Obligatory shot of the wood haul, the saw has a 24" bar :D


Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Sorry, you have it backwards

Lyle Jamieson

OOPS, You missed the part where he showed this is a side grain orientation vessel. The cuts need to be from the low spots out to the largest diameter to go downhill or use the benefit of supported fibers to help with torn out grain. Like a bowl you go from the bottom out to the rim with any cuts you do. and small diameter to large diameter.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#6

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

phillip Medghalchi

Barry, I am sure it had some effects, because in my garage around this time of year it gets over 100 Deg. and I ma sure it bakes everything there is. But to clarify things a bit i got the wood first from the lady in March 2013, then it was soggy and it was full of water. At that time I didn't bring it to San Antonio, because it weighted too much. So,, I leeft it in its natural habitat in WA with my sister at her gaage in the basement ( Crawl space under the house in WA state area. However, I didn't have any anchor seal there so I just left it the way it was and figured that I will cut off the ends that are cracked.

Now, in July of 2013 i went back to WA again and this time I found out that it's dry enough to take it with me to San Antonio. (I didn't ship it to San Antonio, I took it as my 2nd. luggage for free on SW airline (50 Lbs. free)

Ok, now in San Antonio, I had it in my garage so it went though weather changes and dried up some. So, I go cut it in half and used one half for the first bowl, and it blows out, and the second one same thing. Furthermore, none of these bowls were too thin for them to fall apart. I try to post pic.s of them to show you guys here.

The last one in the pic.s is the one with more hope as for not having any cracks when I started, but the darn thing cracked before my eyes as I was working on it.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#7

Re: Sorry, you have it backwards

phillip Medghalchi

Lyle, let me make sure i understand you right in my case I need to go fromthe neck to the largest dis. of the belly and then form the bottom up towards the largest part of the belly like this?



ok, I can try this if I got your direction correctly. Thanks Lyle.

BTW, is this behavior of the sweet gum?

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#8

Re: On torn end grain and drying

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, I was getting the real thin wisps form the neg. rake scraper. I had Rudy Lopez form Fl to show me how he id it. Of course I may need further refinement of my technique, however, i was successful on some other turnings which resulted in much much better finish which I was very happy about,so I didn't have to start sanding form 80 grits. I went very very light almost kissing it so I don't remove very much of wood (that's to be done with another tool) so it did me some good . but not to the final satisfaction and I was going to ask that is it better to put shellac on the wood now and sand it in forward and reverse order to get the tears out of it before I go to hollow what's left?

i thought it's best that I finish the outside completely before I mess with the inside because of the inherent characteristic of this wood. So when I get to the inside I don't have to come back to the out side until I am ready to take the foot off.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Sorry, you have it backwards

Lyle Jamieson

The first arrow on the right side of the photo is the wrong way. No, it is not the wood. You have had the same problem with other woods, correct?? Im glad to see you will be working with Jamie. Im sure Jamie will spend some time on grain orientation, tool control, sanding issues, and drying problems causing cracking. Any wood would do what you show. You can not dry a tree. In the tree form it will do two things, both--not good. A tree will either rot or crack. See my YouTube clip on understanding green wood.

http://youtu.be/PrqvoGs2T_U

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#10

Do you not use a water spray bottle?

Keith Newton

I like turning green from start to finish, and always wet a piece down, then slip a plastic bag over it whenever I need to take a break. The sapwood of certain woods dry really fast compared to the heartwood, so it is really important to not let the sapwood stay exposed too long. The shrinkage process starts I think around 35% on average, although I'd imagine there some variation between species.

Then when I'm done, it goes into a paper bag, and maybe in a cardboard box to slow it down even more. Usually this only takes about 2 weeks before it can be left out.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#11

Re: Do you not use a water spray bottle?

John Jordan

Those cracks were almost certainly in the blanks before you put it on the lathe-you didn't trim enough. LOOK carefully. I think I have suggested the wood articles on my website to you before. They will make this clear-its not that complicated.

Sweetgum is a very nice wood to turn, but it does have more movement than most, which really doesn't matter if you know that.

A fact nobody asked for, but: Did you know that sweetgum (liquidamber) is marketed as two different kinds of lumber? If its a large tree with figured heartwood, its sold as "satin walnut" in veneer or lumber and can be expensive. The outer, plain white wood is sold as "sapgum" and used as secondary wood.

John

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#12

Steven Antonucci

Reverse the arrows on left and in middle


Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#13

Re: Do you not use a water spray bottle?

Rum

Not yet but your explanation makes a lot of sense!

Honestly my turn and return success has been unreasonably high, but I don't claim my process is the most efficient by a long shot :D

Have done some turn to finish but the stuff I had here was so wet it was like taking a shower when doing the initial turning (at least it was cooling :D). Not sure how easy something like that would be to turn in one pass? Have only tried partly dry wood (or at least not sopping wet wood).

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#14

Brad Vietje

Sorry Steve -- I'm with Lyle on this one...

Brad Vietje

This is a side-grain piece in "bowl" orientation, so if we consider this 3 arrows in the photo, the two on the left are fine, but the one on the right has to be reversed.

Phillip -- if you take a break when turning green wood, you are asking for trouble. I would wrap it in a plastic bag, and do what you need to do to keep it wet -- a spray bottle of water can help. Getting good at this so you can work quickly and efficiently will also help -- so you won't need to take a break, or not as many. Maybe a short break going from the outside profile to hollowing, but green wood has to be worked more quickly than dry wood. Not higher RPM's, but working efficiently and quickly from start to finish.

...and I agree that you can not dry a log -- you can split them down the center and try to dry the halves, but a full round will almost always give you trouble if you try to dry it whole.

Have fun at Jamie's class.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#15

Brad Vietje

Phillip:  Do NOT Hollow This Piece!

Brad Vietje

Hey Phillip,

Now that you know you have cracks in the piece, do your self a favor and THROW IT AWAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It is DANGEROUS to hollow a piece that is all cracked to hell. I repeat:

Throw. It. AWAY.

SAFE Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#16

Re: Do you not use a water spray bottle?

phillip Medghalchi

John, I don't remember reading your article, I apologize for missing it. I'll make sure and look into it and read it. Thanks for your suggestion. Very much appreciate it.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#17

Re: Sorry Steve -- I'm with Lyle on this one...

phillip Medghalchi

Brad, My friend your point is taken, The Darn Sweet Gum half timber was pretty much dry sitting in my shop (garage, which nowadays gets up to 110 Deg. or 115 when it is 105 heat index outside). So, you see that I brought the log back with me when it was somewhat dry and then it sat in my garage through out the winter and spring, so it dried up. Then I am turning this piece few days back in middle of the summer, which was like hellish hot down here. We have had more than 13 days of over 100 deg. just the heat and imagine what the heat index were at the time. Now, you send your wood down here to me and i dry it up in one week with this kind of weather. I told Jamie tonight that I have not had the pleasure of turning the real wet wood like you guys describe, yet. I am dying to get cooled off with the water flying off the wood, which has not happened yet. And, if I get my hands on some wet wood, by the time I get around knocking off some of the honey does on the list, they would be dry anyways. So, when I get lucky to find some I'll jump on this forum and let you guys know so, I take all the precautions to dry it up appropriately. The break I took was not long enough for it to act up anyways. I did not feel any moister as I was turning it, and as a matter of fact; I was concerned that if it dried up too much. I just went inside to show the shape to my wife which she said it looked like a spittoon and since I am not a smoker and I try to avoid to be around the smoker (because of my hearing problem) (of course no disrespect to anyone, it's their business what they want to do with their longs), so I was not aware what she was talking about so, she Googled it and showed me then I went back to the shop and changed the rim Dia. to what you see. Therefore, at the most I was out for 10 min.. Also, like I mentioned I did not feel any moister in it. Now, I wonder if I should have Sprayed it and put a bag over it and then go inside and the other mistake was that I got tired and I brought it back and put it next to my computer which under the Air conditioning dried it out further more?

Now, to put you at ease, before I saw your reply, and after talking to Jaime, I already decided to part with this piece. So, I am on the right track with your suggestions, thank you very much for being concerned abut my safety.

Also, I think the wood going to the trash or the junk pile is much cheaper than making a trip to the ER.

Oh, Brad, BTW, above explanation was not to defend my position, it was just to describe the event, so maybe the ones who have same problem and their pride will not let them ask; will read this and hopefully will not make the same mistake. I do not want to bore the readers here with my long posts, just try to explain so, the more experience turners can get the story correctly and advise us fairly, since the verbal communication of the events are not that easy for lots of people and those Cell phone pic.s are still primitive and are not the true representation of the reality.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#18

Steven Antonucci

What is the best cut?

steven antonucci

It's the one you can make :)

I'm going to stand by my original response that even cutting in the wrong direction with a bevel rubbing would yield a better result than trying to pull in the right direction. Scraping flat is going to raise the grain no matter which way you move. I agree that the wood would prefer to be cut in the orientation you and Lyle have pointed out, but that's really hard to pull a scraper in that direction.

The best way to cut it would be with the wing of a bowl gouge and the handle very low, going in the right direction, but if you can't make the cut, it won't help.

S

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#19

Lyle Jamieson

Agree kinda

Lyle Jamieson

You are correct the slicing bevel supported cut will be better then a scraping cut. But the Bevel supported slicing cut will be very close to the same as a sheer scraping cut. Both cuts would benefit from going the correct direction to bet supported grain help. If I had to rank the cuts for efficiency and getting the best surface behind on the wood, it would go like this.

1) Bevel supported slicing cut, (Always 45 degree or more slicing angle cut) Downhill to the grain.

2) sheer scraping cut, downhill to the grain.

3) bevel supported cut, the wrong way to the grain

4) Sheer scraping, the wrong way to the grain.

5) scrapping flat, downhill to the grain

6) Scrapping flat, the wrong way to the grain.

I am surprised how many folks use the #6 mode and then use dull sandpaper to try to fix the problem. I worked with a student yesterday, and he was shocked what happened when we used #1 mode and sharp sandpaper.

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#20

Re: Do you not use a water spray bottle? *LINK*

John Jordan

No need to apologize, I just think that it will simplify some of these wood questions you have. It really is simple.

There are at least two wood articles on the site.

John


http://www.johnjordanwoodturning.com

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#21

Steven Antonucci

my list only goes to 3

Steven antonucci

Flip 2 and 3.

I think bevel support is more important than grain direction. Either way you sand.

S

Re: Sweet gum qsn.

#22

Lyle Jamieson

Re: my list only goes to 3

Lyle Jamieson

I agree, I only do the top three. But I disagree and believe the grain orientation takes top priority. I "never" turn up hill against the grain with whatever cut I am using.