Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

reverse side sharpening

Posts

reverse side sharpening

#1

reverse side sharpening

Bill Tucker

I'm sure this has already been discussed, but I didn't see it. With CBN wheels, there is less of a need for a shatter shield. With that shield removed, and using the veri-grind system, the platform can be switched to the back side of the wheel. This would allow a scraper to be sharpened on the "up" swing of the wheel as opposed to the "down" swing or rotation. This would put a cutting burr on the scraper just like using a slip-stone. Has anyone tried this? If so, how did it work? Since mine is hard mounted to the wall, I thought I'd better ask. Thanks.

Re: reverse side sharpening

#2

Re: reverse side sharpening

Col Smith

Are you referring to a "Rake or Raked Scraper" ?

Col

Re: reverse side sharpening

#3

Re: reverse side sharpening

robo hippy

Some people do sharpen scrapers up side down. I talked to Jimmy Clewes about it and he mentioned that he thought you got a better and sharper burr that way because the wheel was dragging the metal off the top of the tool. I told him I thought that when you sharpened it right side up, you got a better burr because it was closer to burnishing. He had just gotten a CBN wheel, and was going to try it out, but I haven't heard back from him yet. I tried it, and think they cut pretty much the same, but the right side up burr lasted longer. I do need to spend more time with it though...

robo hippy

Re: reverse side sharpening

#4

Scraper-who uses a scraper

John Lucas

Just kidding. I have found that different tools may require different techniques to raise the burr. I have on scraper that works perfectly straight off the grinder. My John Jordan shear scraper works better using the ceramic home that he sells. My large negative rake scraper seems to work better when I raise the burr with a ticketer or steel. I've always wanted to try one of the Veritas scraper burnishes but haven't made one yet. I have tried raising a burr with the tool upside down yet. Maybe someday.

Re: reverse side sharpening

#5

I've honed on the back side for years

Dick Coers

I made a 10" MDF honing wheel, with a leather surface, on one side of the grinder. Use the Wolverine system just how you mentioned. Took off the entire grinding wheel sheet metal cover. Of course needed to get that reverse wheel direction to work on that leather surface.

Re: reverse side sharpening

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Scraper-who uses a scraper

Brad Vietje

I've raised a burr on a scraper with the shaft of my 1/4" round skew... Might be able to get a more consistent burr with the Veritas jig, but I'm more inclined to use a pair of hardened lag bolts sticking out of a block of Maple screwed to the bench.

Call me cheap, but I'm, er..., um... FRUGAL !

Safe spinning (and glad to see you chiming in daily, John),

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: reverse side sharpening

#7

Rob Wallace

Doesn't your butt hurt after all that honing? 

Rob Wallace

:D

Re: reverse side sharpening

#8

Why don't you just turn the.......

JamieDonaldson

...scraper upside down and sharpen on the front side of the wheel? Much easier and less trouble than reconfiguring the whole grinding rig! ;)

Re: reverse side sharpening

#9

upside down

GaryG in MD

I think sharpening a scraper upside down, below center on the grinder, is a pretty common thing. Paul Fennell taught me to do it that way. You are pulling on the steel, rather than pushing on it. OTOH, a burnished burr is more consistent and lasts longer.

Doc Green mentions it in passing in his excellent article on scrapers that everyone should read:

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/scrapers1.html

Please note that this article consists of three pages; you reach the other two pages from links at the bottom of each page.

...GG

Re: reverse side sharpening

#10

Burr from Burnishing (pic)

Doc Green

Ha ha! I recently acquired something called a USB microscope, and I now can take a picture of a burr on a scraper. It takes some fiddling and the picture isn't great (especially when compressed), but even a sorry picture is worth a lot of words.

So, the following pic shows the burr produced on a small scraper by light burnishing. Essentially, the metal is pushed up to form a lip along the cutting edge. (More text below)


Here's what I did: 1. Grind the angle to 77 degrees with a 120-grit wheel. 2. Hone the bevel enough to remove the scratches from the grinding wheel. 3. Hone the top surface to remove any burr produced by the grinder. 4. Burnish lightly against a hardened steel pin.

So how does it work? First of all, the burr is very prominent and tends to be very aggressive, especially if used flat on the rest in the "handle-held-high" position recommended by a lot of people (but not me). Secondly, the burr is pushed back from the line of the bevel so that you actually need to raise the handle in order to have the top of the burr engage the wood. This is a catch 22 because used in this manner, it is very aggressive.

However, for shear scraping where the tool is rotated from being flat on the rest to maybe 45 degrees, it is possible to engage the burr without having it be so aggressive. Used in this manner, it is excellent. The shearing action produces a clean surface and it is not hard to control.

Even so, I would not use a scraper with such a prominent burr for the last finishing cuts. A burr produced by honing with a diamond hone (credit card) does the job just as well and is a lot more forgiving in case you make a boo boo.

Thanks, Gary, for the shout-out on my articles. Much appreciated.

~Doc

Re: reverse side sharpening

#11

Another pic, side view

Doc Green

The following pic is a side view of the same scraper shown in my previous post. In the highlighted area at the tip of the tool, you can see how the metal has been pushed back from the line of the bevel. This is what makes it necessary to raise the tool handle in order to have the burr engage the wood. And when it does engage the wood, it cuts very aggressively. (. . . when used flat on the rest)


Re: reverse side sharpening

#12

For comparison ...

Doc Green

For comparison purposes, here is the burr formed by a grinder using an 80-grit wheel. Note how rough and jagged it is. This is your typical burr straight from a grinder without honing or burnishing. (more text below)


The quality of the burr will be somewhat better if a 120-grit wheel is used instead of 80, but the difference is minimal.

Now, if you test the burr by feeling it with a thumb or finger, it will feel seriously sharp - prickly is a better word. However, this is an illusion. What you cannot tell from the photo is that the burr is very weak, almost as if the metal has somehow been splattered onto the top surface. By stroking the burr with a needle, you can easily just wipe the burr away.

How long will it last while actually cutting? About 15 seconds to one minute. Then back to the grinder.

On the other hand, a burr formed by honing (after the initial grinding) will last much, much longer. Sharpening requirements for a scraper with a burr produced by honing is comparable to the requirements of a bowl gouge - you sharpen it and then use it a while before it needs to be sharpened again.

Does it take a long time to produce a burr by honing? No. After the initial grinding (which you do not have to repeat very often), you can create a new burr in about 30 seconds, if you don't hurry.

Questions? Bring 'em on! I can share my experience and observations and let you know what works for me.

Incidentally, and just to clarify, I use a scraper as a cutting tool. I seldom do pure scraping. The burr does the cutting and produces "shavings that almost float in the air and if you touch them, they just disappear."

~Doc

Re: reverse side sharpening

#13

Doc, your thoughts on negative rake?

Ron Bauer

Doc, I have become a bit of a fan of negative rake scrapers because of their "friendlier" performance. Mine have always been off the grinder. In your case of honing and burnishing would a negative rake be less aggressive and yet hold up for a longer time than off the grinder? Seems like you would not have to raise the handle as high. Ron.

Re: reverse side sharpening

#14

Negative rake scrapers *LINK*

Doc Green

A negative rake scraper has two bevels that intersect to form the cutting edge. If the included angle at the cutting edge is more than 90 degrees (for HSS), no burr will be formed during the grinding process. This makes it possible to grind the tool and form a keen edge without producing a burr. Further, the tool will cut and produce shavings although considerable pressure must be applied to force it against the wood.

Such a tool might be useful for smoothing the surface of a dense, hard, gnarly wood where the presence of a burr causes an ordinary scraper to dig in and catch.

The following pic is a top view of a scraper made from an old file. The included angle at the cutting edge is more than 90 degrees, and no burr is produced.


Now, having said this, I know of several big-name turners who use and advocate negative rake scrapers, but the angles they cite for the bevels produce an included angle at the cutting edge that is less than 90 degrees. This implies that a burr will be produced during grinding.

Here is where I run into trouble. I cannot see any difference between such a scraper and an ordinary (one-bevel) scraper except that the end of the "negative rake" scraper points down. The only benefit of this that I can see is that the tool handle of the negative rake will not need to be elevated as much to get the cutting edge pointed down, as is frequently recommended (but not by me).

What I do for ordinary scrapers: 1. Grind the bevel to about 77 degrees. 2. Use a diamond wheel (convenient) to hone the bevel. 3. Use a credit card hone to remove the burr produced by the grinder. 4. Form a new, very fine burr using a credit card hone placed flat against the bevel.

To use the scraper, I approach the wood with the handle held Low (yes, Low). Once the bevel is against the wood, I gradually raise the handle until it begins to cut, then I proceed with the cut. Raising the handle further causes the scraper to become more aggressive, and if it reaches the point where it is actually pointing down, it becomes very aggressive (exactly how aggressive depends on the burr).

Two important points: 1. The 77 degree bevel angle, which is fairly steep. This angle prevents the "monster catches" that you can get if you try the handle-low approach with a smaller included angle. 2. The burr is very fine, so fine that you have to feel carefully to even detect that it is there. But the fine burr is all you need, and it lasts, and lasts, and lasts. (... and produces shavings so fine they almost float in the air . . .)

If I encounter an awful piece of gnarly wood that tends to be grabby, I either reduce the burr or remove it entirely. So, except for experimenting, I do not use a negative rake scraper. However, others do, and some swear by them.

~Doc


Doc's Website

Re: reverse side sharpening

#15

Aage Rendalen

Fat vs thin scrapers

Aage Rendalen

I have one of these really 'fat' scrapers from Sorby. It doesn't do much for me. The thinner scrapers seem to work much better. Now, I believe the thick scraper comes with a bevel that is a lot blunter than yours. Would that make a difference?

Re: reverse side sharpening

#16

Re: Fat vs thin scrapers

John Lucas

I have a fat scraper and a thin one. The fat one is many times more controllable than the thin one. They both had the same grind There is just so much less chatter a d vibration.

I have now ground the big one to a negative rake and like it even better. The downside is the be el is so long it takes a while to grind. I like Stewart Barry's tool which has a thin cutter mounted in a thick bar. Very expensive but a really nice tool

Re: reverse side sharpening

#17

Steven Antonucci

Try using your skew as a NRS

steven antonucci

works better than a NRS, and no need for another tool. You need a radius on it, but other than that...

S

Re: reverse side sharpening

#18

Re: Try using your skew as a NRS

Bill Howatt

I've used the skew as a NRS as a solution for some annoying spindle issues and it works very well.

What I don't understand is the burr is supposedly a scrapers cutting edge but where's the burr on a sharpened and honed skew?

Bill

Re: reverse side sharpening

#19

My favorite scrapers are planer knives cut in half

Keith Newton

Dulled down their former cutting edge, then sharpened to about 25 -30º, razor sharp. I then roll the burr on a burnisher, which was the shaft of a shock absorber, unhandled, laying on a bench. With it clenched in my fist, and only about 1/2" sticking out the bottom, I start with the side of my hand planted on the rod, and the steel held at about 45º as I roll it back and forth, slowly bringing it up to 90º. It will still be razor sharp when the burr is finished.

I move the tool rest back out of the way, then bring it up to the turning well below the center line, with it tilted 30 - 45º, working my way out from the lows to high, favoring the grain. Only about 1/4" is sticking out past my forefinger, and only enough pressure used to get a good cut. Trying to force it will cause chatter, but this method makes it so easy to get rid of any bumps or ridges and down to fair curves, without any torn grain. Sanding can start at 320 grit.

Back to sharpening, The tool steel in these planner knives is too hard to roll a burr on without getting it red hot when grinding the end shape. I follow that on a Cratex wheel, which is a fine rubberized wheel, requiring the cutting edge pointing away from the rotation. Mine is 1/2" wide, shaped with an elliptical rim about the same as the flute in a 5/8" bowl gouge.

This is followed with a few light touches on a 1/2" mdf wheel charged with white compound. Here again, cutting edge away from rotation. Both of these are wonderful to polishing the inside of deep gouges.

I can remove the burr on the Cratex, then go through the steps of sharpening and rolling the burr in just over 1 minute.

Re: reverse side sharpening

#20

Burr on a skew  ?

Doc Green

As the included angle between the bevels on a scraper becomes smaller, the nature of the burr gradually changes. When the angle gets as small as about 35 degrees (skew), the burr becomes what knife and plane-blade sharpeners refer to a wire edge, or a feather edge. This is basically a thin wisp of metal that is pushed away from the grinding wheel or stone, but because of the small included angle, it doesn't plant itself on the top bevel, or at least it does so to a lesser extent. It is very fragile and is easily broken off.

When it breaks off, it leaves a fracture surface between the two bevels. This surface represents a blunt edge. What is desired is to have the top bevel meet the one on the bottom to form a keen edge, a very thin line where the two bevels meet.

This is where honing comes in. Honing will remove the wire edge without breaking it off to form a fracture surface, or at least produce a fracture surface that is very small. Then, to take it to the next level, you can strop the two bevels and polish away any fracture surface that was developed. At this stage, the edge will be very sharp.

Re: reverse side sharpening

#21

Steven Antonucci

My point, Bill Howatt!

steven antonucci

The skew doesn't have a burr and it functions extremely well as a NRS. I am not convince you need a burr on a NRS.

Steve

Re: reverse side sharpening

#22

Re: My point, Bill Howatt!

Bill Howatt

When I worked in a research lab, my boss used to say when we got a good result without exactly knowing why, "You can't argue with success!". I certainly don't argue with my presumably burr-less skew's results as a NRS.

Bill