Noise canceling
Gary clarke
Has anyone had experience with noise canceling headphones in the shop? I am looking for one that will cancel most of the noise from my dust collector and I do not need radio or music reception. Any ideas?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Noise canceling
Gary clarke
Has anyone had experience with noise canceling headphones in the shop? I am looking for one that will cancel most of the noise from my dust collector and I do not need radio or music reception. Any ideas?
Re: Noise canceling
John Lucas
I have a cheap set. All it seams to do is change the pitch. Can't tell if it actually does any good. Gets
In the way big time with my face shield so I have to wear one or the other so I just don't wear either one. 
Re: Noise canceling
Barry Irby
I bought a set of the Bose ones a few years ago. They were expensive. About $300 as I recall. I was not impressed. Not nearly as effective as my shooters muffs. The ones I had were the on the ear type rather than the over the ear type like the shooters muffs. I took them back.
Re: Noise canceling
gary clarke
I have been using Peltor hearing protection, guess I will keep using them. Good to have you back John. I had looked at the older review of hearing protection in the search area and thought there might be some new information. The Seattle football crazies have been using the cancelation type to drown out the rabid fans, go figure.
Re: Noise canceling
phillip Medghalchi
Gary, I believe what John said is true. you can not wear them in conjunction with face shield, now we may be able to give the trend some idea for them to use the noise cancellation in their design, however, when I bought mine at the SWAT, I talked to George who said he was the big guy with them he was not aware that there are threads her or on the other forum form us complaining about the battery problem. So, this may be way down the road before they catch on the idea. Now, on Mon. I have to go and see my Audiologist and I ask her if hse knows of anything that you can put into your ear to do that and at the same time wear your face shield and report back here.
Re: Noise canceling
Barry Rockwell
I've had some experience with that in the past, but I always called it a "divorce lawyer".
Re: Noise canceling
phillip Medghalchi
Barry, sent an email few days back.
Re: Noise canceling
Chuck Engstrom
Hi Gary -- I use foam-type ear plugs, always in my pocket in a little case, and over-the-head ear muffs, separately or often together for greater attenuation as with chainsaw, lawn mower and such. Harbor Freight sells a plenty effective red-and-black over-the-head set for less than $5, I think, and I bought up several sets so there's always one near at hand. The ear plugs in my pocket have been brought out for loud wedding reception bands and similar situations. All this is way cheaper than Bose stuff, which is very nice but hardly cost-effective in comparison.
Best-- Chuck
BOSE in ear
jfox442
I have a set of BOSE QC 20i in-ear (ear-buds) noise-cancelling earphones. They do hook up to your music device (ipod, iPad, cd player, etc.) and do a reasonable job for music. But they will cancel noise without being hooked up to anything else. They have a small battery pack that seems to be good for about 3 hours or so. Cost is a bit less than $300. They work well for my purposes and do fit under a face shield. There is a setting to let some of the outside world in.
Try them but keep receipt--how well they work & fit in ones ear is very subjective.
James
Re: Noise canceling
Barry L Elder
Turn off the offending device! 
Re: Noise canceling
Don Orr
I don't have the active noise cancelling devices but do use ear muffs in my shop a lot. I have the cheap HF ones on most of my machines for quick access. I use them constantly when turning to reduce the noise from my DC, which runs all the time, as you want to do. I can't hear the radio but I can hear the phone ring and I can hear what the wood is telling me while turning. I use them with a face shield often. I also use the EAR plugs on the mower. I have a loggers helmet for chainsaw/string trimmer work. I am a big fan of protecting eyes and ears-we only get 2 of each.
Funny story-I had just cut a board on my chopsaw and was hand planing it on my bench when someone came to my shop door. I had my back to the door so they knocked and I turned to answer. They looked at me kind of funny because I was still wearing my earmuffs from the saw while using a hand plane. I'm so used to haveing the muffs on I forgot they were there.
Re: Noise canceling
vamatt
For a cheaper alternative to the bose, I use Vic Firth headphones. They are designed for recording drums. They offer good sound isolation and were $50 when i got them. They are "can" style headphones, not in-ear. I've had them for a few years and they work great despite a little abuse.
Matt
Re: Noise canceling
Harry Robinette
I put my DC in a quiet room ( also put my compressor in one to) with both running you can still carry on a conversation with no problem.Both cost about
$50. or $60.
Re: Noise canceling
phillip Medghalchi
Don, good for you. people ask me why I don't use them that much, and I tell them, I don't have that much of hearing left and the darn thing is so bad that they don't bother to test it on the left side and right one is a iffy. As for the eyes, I wished that I wasn't wearing tri-focal. Oh well, I envy the guys who don't have to wear glasses or just eh reading one.
Re: Noise canceling
phillip Medghalchi
Harry, how did you get that lucky?
Re: Noise canceling
John Lucas
Wish I had the room to do that. My friends Kim winkle and her husband graham Campbell built their shop on the side of a hill. The backside was deep e ought that they put in a room and put the dust collector and air compressor under the shop. Not only do they not have any noise all the hoses run under the shop that also let's them put in floor recepticals for power tools that sit in the middle of the room.
On the front side of the shop the sidewalk goes straight In. Graham dug out on the right side so that he could back the pick up truck right up to the sidewalk to load and unload machinery and furniture projects.
Kim will be demonstrating for our club this weekend. She's a great demonstrator a d I look forward to seeing her.
Re: Noise canceling
Matt Overton
I agree, John, Kim is wonderful. She stayed at my house while she was here for the Echo Lake collaborative. She speaks highly of you as well.
Re: Noise canceling
Harry Robinette
All I did was build a wall with 2x6 upper, lower and sides then put 2x4 on 12" centers in the center. The 2x4
are stagerd one on one side then to the other side,put bat insulation weaved between the 2x4's this is what deadens the sound cover with ether dry wall or sound board. Leave 1 channel in the 2x4 open cut opening on bottom inside channel and top outside channel, filter the exhaust coming out the top opening,
opening must be twice the intake. I put a 12x12 in mine cause I can get filters cheap.
Now this box is 2 sided cause I put it in a corner. One smaller side has hinges and a caster on the bottom corner so I can open this to change the bag. the whole unit is only like 30"x40" and it has my Delta 1200 cfm DC in it.
Same thing for the compressor but smaller put mine next to the DC so only have 2 sides.DON'T put the Compressor in with the DC the dust will kill your compressor.
Hope this makes sence to you all if not ask.
Re: Noise canceling
H. Phillip Medghalchi
Harry, can you call me or email me about this plz?
Thanks, Phillip
Re: Noise canceling
Harry Robinette
Give me a call it will be much easyer cause I don't type well.
330-221-4779 EST I'm retired so anytime after around 9:00 am till 9:00pm and will chat. Mine is working great.