Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Polishing gouge flutes??

Posts

Polishing gouge flutes??

#1

Polishing gouge flutes??

Ron Bauer

Do you polish the inside of your gouge flutes to get that "scary sharp" edge? Notwithstanding arguments that it is not necessary I still would like to do it to see if there is a benefit in my world. I have stumbled through a couple attempts with some promising results but there might be a better way. It seems obvious that you can do all the honing you want on the outside but you will never get a better edge than that dictated by the mill marks left from forming the flute. If you do polish the inside what is your procedure? Frankly, the time to polish is at the manufacturing stage. I would pay extra for it. TIA. Ron.

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#2

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

Michael Gibson

I polish mine with a round diamond hone and every now and then on a homemade MDF wheel used on the lathe. l have beads cut into the wheel and smear a compound over that the carvers use to hone their tools on a leather strop. Tormek also has a wheel specifically for this purpose. Michael

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#3

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Ron,

If you take a slip hone (rounded edges) and put a very slight back-bevel on the flute side of the edge, it will do 2 things. (1) it will remove the slight wire edge formed in the sharpening process and (2) it will eliminate the mill marks you're speaking about insofar as they may effect your edge. It's a waste of time to polish/hone the entire flute surface.

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#4

Steven Antonucci

Yes, for an inch or so

steven antonucci

Sandpaper with a dowel in it, unless you want to make it perfect. (this is close enough) If you want perfect, impressed the flute profile into a pine block, and use a knife to whittle a flute shaped sanding block.

It works, and takes very little time.

S

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#5

As usual, there are several schools......

JamieDonaldson

...thought here, but I do occasionally hone the flute with a Lacer diamond hone. The rounded edge of the hone gives a nice shiny smooth surface, and the adjoining shiny edge from a CBN wheel just has to be sharper. Don't shiny edges mean sharp edges? ;)

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#6

No

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Shiny bevels mean sharp edges.

If you see light reflecting off the edge, you're looking at a butter knife :D :D

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#7

OTOH

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If a mirrored smooth flute floats your boat, go for it ;)

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#8

Polish the flute no - home the edge sometimes

John Lucas

I. Ever polish the flute. That just seems like a waste of time. However I do sometimes hone the inside first millimeter. I believe Mark called this a back bevel I don't intentionally do a back bevel. What I do is take a cone shaped diamond fish hookmsharpening tool and hit the inside very lightly. U often do this instead of honing the outside bevel.

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#9

I don't "polish" flutes

Geoff Whaling

I do use the Tormek system and hone the flute on the leather honing wheel for bowl, detail & spindle gouges. "Scary sharp" is the only way to go with my very dry linear laminated small bowls & spindle work. Far less chatter & vibration producing the thin walls & thin spindle elements.

The requirement for a scary sharp edge, honing etc, all gets back to understanding the materials & application. I can not see any need for the extra effort on gouges used for roughing out our harder Australian timbers. In fact some are better scraped rather than cut.

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#10

Steven Antonucci

Restating my answer (unclear prior)

steven antonucci

I do not polish more than the first inch or so, but I only do it once. I do not bother to repolish it every time I sharpen.

If you make the flute polishing sanding blocks, it goes very quickly. I use water and start at 400, and then up to whatever the finest paper I own is? Usually, 1500... but I've also seen 2000 somewhere.

Once you do this, it is done. It does not need to be repeated, and I then grind the bevel as normal on my Tormek. I use a diamond hone in between trips to the Tormek to resharpen the edge by honing it, but not as a means of improving the edge off the grinder wheel. It is just marginally faster than walking 2 feet over to the Tormek, and convenient when I travel...

S

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#11

polished flutes

Jeff Smith

You might check out D-way Tools - Dave polishes the flutes of the gouges he sells. I do think it makes a difference. Hadn't considered the effect on the quality of the edge - but I do think they shed shavings a little easier. Particularly with woods like madrone that throws out a sticky mess when turned green. The flute doesn't clog up with shavings as badly as other gouges that don't have the highly polished flutes.

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#12

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

Bill Boehme

Alan Lacer sells a diamond slipstone that has a curve that perfectly matches most of my bowl gouges.

FWIW, I don't see any mill marks in the flutes of my Sorby and Crown bowl gouges. This means that I must have already polished them smooth or that they used to make them with polished flutes (most of my bowl gouges are fairly old -- sort of like their owner).

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#13

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

Ron Bauer

Bill, I think "in the old days" gouges were forged rather than milled. This resulted in a much smoother flute.

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#14

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

Ron Bauer

Thanks to all for your thoughts and comments. I did bite the bullet and polished the flutes of most of my gouges. Not to a mirror but they are a lot better than they started out. It was a lot easier than I expected it to be and now it is done. Sometimes I just get tired of turning and look for opportunities to improve my "system". Maybe it doesn't result in a better bowl but I just feel better thinking I improved something. This is one of those cases. Ron.

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#15

Steven Antonucci

and you are right for thinking so

steven antonucci

I talked to a vendor about it, and as a result, his flutes are now coming more and more better finished off of the factory floor. Makes my job easier, as I am still going to go one step beyond... but probably not mirror finished. (Yes it would result in a better edge, but the edges on a gouge do not last long enough to matter at that level)

S

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

#16

Re: Polishing gouge flutes??

John Lucas

Ron you just posted my entire woodworking experience. Every so often you just sort of fine tune the way you did things in the past. Whether its working on you segmented jig or tuning your saw or reshape ing carving tools. Each time you do it you prove things slightly and or get better at what your doing.