Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Cherry? Maple Bowl?

Posts

Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#1

Mike Stafford

Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Mike Stafford

This is the first bowl I have turned in the last 3 or so years. John Lucas's shop mess reminded me of why I more or less gave up bowl turning. Just too many chips to sweep up! I was shocked at how many shavings were left on the floor from this 10 3/8" diameter by 3 1/4" tall bowl.

I turned it from a very dry, very old millwork cut off that I have had in the shop for at least 7 or 8 years. I am not sure of the species. I thought it was cherry as I was turning it but others have suggested that it is maple. Regardless I was surprised when some beautiful curl showed up.

Comments appreciated....


Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#2

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Don in Central Illinois

Looks like you still have the touch.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#3

Nice, I vote maple.

Dick Coers

If that would be cherry, it would be the fastest growing one on record. Those growth rings are huge. Still say maple.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#4

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

John Veerkamp

I think it's curly cherry. I'm just finishing a mirror frame for a bath remodel, Color and figure look very much like this. I've turned a fair amount of both and say cherry.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#5

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

John Lucas

beautiful Mike. And I agree about bowl turning. I turned 12 mirrors and had one small garbage can of shavings. 3 small bowls left 4 of the same garbage can.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Brad Vietje

Beautiful bowl, Mike. Those growth rings are too large for any Cherry I've ever seen. I'd say Maple, and really soft Maple at that. Did you acquire any Big Leaf Maple from out West? Maybe even Boxelder, a.k.a. "Manitoba Maple" could have growth rings like that.

Black Cherry would tend to have small pitch pockets in the softer spring growth, and a faint zig-zag pattern (far more subtly than Am. Elm), and I don't see either in your photos. A very close inspection of the end grain would help in the ID process.

BUT -- whatever you call it, I'd call it a very handsome bowl with a nice form, great finish, and a high level of craftsmanship!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Mike Stafford

Brad, I have turned box elder, soft maple and big leaf maple and this piece of wood was much harder than that. It had a pinkish color under the rough sawn exterior. And as I said it was a cut off from a local millwork shop. I doubt they would be using some of the species you mention. I know it was not hard maple because I have some of that.

I just don't know. It was not labeled which is not normal for me but in some respects it resembled cherry. I guess it does not matter but it is hard for me to not know what it is. That disturbs my organized method of classifying thing.

Thank you all for the comments. My wife absconded with it and is using it so I guess that is all that matters.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#8

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Yeah Mike, wives tend to to that, especially when they get frustrated trying to serve salads in those little boxes you turn.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#9

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

phillip Medghalchi

Mike, I have pieces that were given to me and local to my area, but no one can tell me exactly what it is, so I am going with the name pretty bowls on what ever I have made out of it. I think as long as someone likes it that's all it matters in your case your better half is using it which is all the best.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#10

regardless of the name of the wood...

GaryG in MD

...that is one fine bowl.

Outstanding shape and beautiful wood. Very well done. ...GG

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#11

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

James Heaston

What did it smell like when you turned it?

Cherry, maple, birch all have pleasant scents that are distinctive that I enjoy while working 'em.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#12

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Dale Miner

Mike,

Put a patch of dark heavy paper about 1.5" square on the inside of the bowl and set it in a window where it will get a lot of sun. If cherry, a week in the sun will cause a noticeable change in the color compared to the covered spot.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Mike Stafford

Dale, will that method work with potato chips? My wife has been using it to serve potato chips every week to her bridge buddies.

I had thought of the sun tan method but at this point I guess it does not matter. In a few years, whether it is cherry or maple, it will be a nice rich brown color.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#14

Why does this feel like deja vue????

Barry Irby

Mike didn't you post a bowl a few weeks ago with the same questions and even the comments on potato chips? Have you made two very nice bowls? Or am I having a seizure?

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#15

Mike Stafford

Because I am an idiot.....

Mike Stafford

:(

I did post this bowl 3 or 4 weeks ago and completely forgot that I did. I am so sorry for cluttering up the forum.

I just forgot that I posted it on WC.

At least people still think that the wood could be either cherry or maple. I honestly think that I am so bothered by not knowing what it is that I had a brain fart and forgot about the previous post.

Sorry for being a dummy.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#16

Whew!!!

Barry Irby

This is what George Carlin called Vueja Dae....Nothing this weird has ever happened to anyone before.....

It was a good looking bowl before and it still is. I can't be sure about the wood. Maybe time will tell. I think the cherry will darken more than maple. I really like the form.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#17

Re: Why does this feel like deja vue????

phillip Medghalchi

Barry, I thought I had memory issues. phewwwwwwwwww. You saved me.

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#18

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

phillip Medghalchi

Can we take a vote to call this bowl and put our good friend's mind at ease, please?

Re: Cherry? Maple Bowl?

#19

Re: Cherry?  Maple Bowl?

Dale Cook

Hi Mike, if I were to take a guess on the wood type of this beautiful bowl I would have to say cottonwood which can have great figure in the base part of the tree. Very nice, what finish did you use?