Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

another Urn question

Posts

another Urn question

#1

another Urn question

GaryG in MD

I didn't want to hijack Brad's post, so let's start another one here.

My question is: has anyone turned an urn for themselves?

Seems to me like it wouldn't be a bad thing to do if the kids are tuned in.

I just asked my wife, and she said "make two".

Thoughts? ...GG

Re: another Urn question

#2

Steven Antonucci

I have not

steven antonucci

Personal beliefs aside about death rituals, I had thought about it prior, and do not think I will.

Cemeteries are not a great use of space, and cremation seems like a good way to overcome that. Of course, I am hoping that is after they've run me through the chop shop to part me out for anyone that might need what still worked on me at the time of my demise. No sense in running a good kidney through the fire.

Once I am gone, I don't really want to burden someone with the responsibility of looking a an old box of dust. Another thing to clean, or worse, another expense to inter in a mausoleum and back to the waste of space issue.

I am hopeful that I don't need to worry about this for a while, as I am still under warranty.

Steve

Re: another Urn question

#3

My Friend....

Barry Irby

who is a wood worker and runs a small cabinet shop had a fellow com in asking him to cut up some walnut for him so that he could build his own coffin and one for his wife. After my friend got into it, the guy had him go ahead and build them and finish them. These were coffins, not caskets. My friend is considering building his own.

Re: another Urn question

#4

No

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've made and turned a number of urns for friends and family, however I personally regard retaining cremains as an impediment to getting closure over the passing. My view is that people need to let go and move on with their lives. Holding on to ashes is a form of denial or a refusal to let go. I've told my kids to find a nice place they might like to visit again and scatter what I've left behind. Done.

Sitting on some coffee table or in a bookcase is the very lest place I'd want to end up.

Re: another Urn question

#5

Re: No

Bill Howatt

The urn and contents do not have to be kept on display or in a closet. They can be placed in a grave or whatever. Now you might wonder if making a fancy vessel is worth it if it is going to be buried but it will be there at the service and your loved on will spend eternity resting in it.

No, I haven't made one for myself or anybody else for that matter.

Bill

Re: another Urn question

#6

Ric Taylor

Re: another Urn question

Ric Taylor

Gary,

It is becoming common for long-time married couples to share one urn.

Ric

Re: another Urn question

#7

Re: another Urn question

jfox442

I've made 2: One for my mother (gave it to her a few months before she died...she put it on display in her curio cabinet until it was needed--she thought it was "cool"), she was buried in it; the other was for my brother-in-law--we spread his ashes in Puget sound on new-years day. His urn now remains empty in the workshop (garage as my wife calls it) waiting on the next (temporary) resident--perhaps me or my wife.

Or I may turn one for myself or my wife. We all look at death (and life) differently...do what makes you happy or at least content. The urn and the information to loved ones left behind on what to do with it means one less decision they will have to make when I croak.

James

Re: another Urn question

#8

Understood, Bill

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I have done full size (200+c.i.) urns as well as multi-part and small "keepsake" urns for family members of a deceased who wish to hold a portion of the cremains until it is their "turn" to pass. Each of them has told me that they plan to be cremated as well and will have the urn(s) destroyed with them, the cremains mixed, and, usually, scattered. They do not see the containers as long-term repository to be passed on in the family as they don't wish to place such a burden upon the next generation who may not even have known the decedent.

I have not, however, been asked to do an urn that would either be buried or entombed.

Re: another Urn question

#9

Dick Hines

Re: another Urn question

Dick Hines

Don,t need one. I am an organ donor. After they get all the good pieces I am going to turned into ashes and then into a trout stream. Planning on getting that last fishing trip.

Re: another Urn question

#10

Jim Evans

Another Option

Jim Evans

My Wife and I have a double decker above ground resting place. Last one to die gets to be on top.

After doing family genealogy I came to appreciate a place to know where my ancestors were buried.

Re: another Urn question

#11

Spontaneous human combustion *LINK*

John Lucas

I'm just going to burst into flames and be gone. That way they just come into my shop and sweep up the ashes along with the shavings. I remember when I was a teenager Area 51 the Bermuda Triangle and spontaneous human combustion were all big mysteries that led to many discussions.


http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_human_combustion

Re: another Urn question

#12

Please be safe and do it outside on the driveway


Re: another Urn question

#13

The one urn I sold....

Dick Coers

was to become a family heirloom. It gets used for the life celebration, then the ashes either go to a mausoleum or are spread. I want my ashes distributed at Montgomery Woods State Reserve. No more spiritual place for me than around old growth redwoods. After my family does that, they must go to enjoy that wonderful Northern California coast to enjoy life!

Re: another Urn question

#14

My Uncle

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

asked to be scattered on Pike's Peak looking down over his two sisters buried in Trinidad. So I got out a map and we decided on the exact spot on the mountain above 13,000' that fit his bill.

He does have a view


Re: another Urn question

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: No

Brad Vietje

My concern has less to do with a lack of closure (though I suspect you are right, Mark), but in placing a burden of expectation on my survivors that they are then obligated to keep me or us somewhere. I would not want family members to have to dust and display something out of a sense of guilt at "throwing it away", so to speak, through burial.

I like Mark's philosophy of get rid of the ashes and get on with life (and Steve's about still being under warranty!)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: another Urn question

#16

Re: Spontaneous human combustion

Jeff Smith

A very good friend and I were enjoying a few libations one evening when the subject turned to the inevitable end.

We both agreed that cremation was the best option. I described where I'd like my ashes scattered - a spot we used to backpack to above Yosemite.

He said that he'd like most of his there, too, but the he asked me to promise to save about a half cup of his, find the woman he had lusted after in vain for years, mist her down and scatter his ashes like a cloud of cologne in her path.

There are promises to keep, and there are those that could wind up badly...

Re: another Urn question

#17

Re: My mother-in-law

Lloyd in Mississauga

My wife asked me to make an urn for her mom after she unexpectedly passed. They do cremation then burial in a family plot, so the urn was filled with all but about a 1/4 cup that her brother wanted and then buried. It was odd because I actually had to help the Cementary keeper dig the hole as he forgot a pry bar to help remove rocks and the wife's folks live the closest to the Cementary, so he called to see if we could run one up.

The mother-in-laws family appreciated it as it looked like a cookie jar and she was well know for making cookies. It was not meant as a cookie jar, but if they were happy I was happy.

Re: another Urn question

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: No

Mike Stafford

The way I look at it is that the person who commissions the urn can do whatever they want with it and the contents. If they wish to bury it, fine. If they wish to sit it on the fireplace mantle, fine. I could care less.

Me, put me in the compost bin or directly on the garden or even better toss me in the ocean to feed the fishes and crabs I have so dearly loved.

Re: another Urn question

#19

Betty Scarpino

Re: Scattered at House of Mystery in Montana

Betty Scarpino

One of my parents' business ventures years ago was the House of Mystery in northwest Montana. They loved that area of the country and Dad always told us he wanted his ashes scattered there. So three years ago, my three sisters, Mom, one of my sons, and I traveled there, me transporting Dad's cremains. He died the previous year, four months short of 90.

We had a wonderful time honoring Dad's wishes, each of us scattering a small jar of ashes as we walked along the paths. That night, we celebrated in Moose's Saloon in Kalispell, a place I always wanted to return to to legally drink a beer.

Mom wants her ashes scattered there, too. It'll be another enjoyable family reunion.

No urn. No casket, no coffin.

Re: another Urn question

#20

Re: another Urn question

Bob Macgregor

Cremation is the referred posthumus treatment of my family members, though I haven't yet considered making urns.

I have repeatedly suggested to my family that they (we?) get the last laugh on government by refusing to claim my body when I die, thereby forcing the "state" to dispose of the remains at public expense. My wife has not agreed to this, though, and by the time the question comes up, I will no longer have a vote (or even the fraction of a vote I have now).

Bob

Re: another Urn question

#21

Donna Parrillo

Re: another Urn question

Donna Parrillo

Hi Gary,

My urn is almost done. I just have to finish turn the lid. This piece was supposed to be a cookie jar for my daughter, but when it was done all I saw was an urn... so that is what it will be.

Donna

Re: another Urn question

#22

Re: My mother-in-law

phillip Medghalchi

Loyd, where is Cementary? 8) or do they call that where you live?

Re: another Urn question

#23

And how many libations had you had...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...when he proposed this scheme?

Re: another Urn question

#24

Lots of good stories and ideas here...

GaryG in MD

...and many alternatives.

Thanks, all, for sharing your thoughts on this very personal subject. ...GG

Re: another Urn question

#25

us hillbilly's burn hotter- we are full of shine