Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

Posts

Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#1

Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

charlie belden

. . . Can Make YOU Cool?

The August 2014 issue of American Woodturner devoted six of the sixty pages of content (as opposed to ads) to an article on Woodturning at the Barnes, the Barnes being "one of the most significant private art collections in the country." - "having more Cezannes than in all the museums in Paris" - "the total collection is valued upwards of twenty five billion dollars." (note: 1,000 pieces, with an average value of 25 million, would work out to 25 BILLION).

Now Picasso, Renoir, Cezanne, Matisse and Van Gough are pretty cool Artists to be hangin' around with - especially if you're a turned wooden cannister, or a mortar and pestle, or a spindle chair or a turned candle stand. There's even a connection made to Harvard - comparing a spindle chair in the collection to "The President's Chair" in the Harvard Art Museum. That's a bit of a reach IMHO, but hey, when you want to impress people, a little name dropping can't hurt ; )

It seems the American Woodturner is going BACK to promoting woodturning as ART - aiming that message at The Collectors and The Curators - not the folks who are actually doing the turning - and paying for the magazine. By devoting 10 percent of the August issue's 60 pages of actual content to "the Barnes", to what appears, at least to me, an attempt to impress non-turners by associating old wood turnings with famous Impressionists - and speculating that Barnes foresaw wood turnings someday becoming - ART.

If I wanted to keep up with The World of Art I'd subscribe to a few of the hundreds of magazines on the subject. Our magazine/journal is called American Woodturner, NOT American Wood Turning Collector. Give me articles about turning, turning tools and techniques and turners. ART stuff I can find on my own.

I hope this slip back into ART SPEAK is an aberration and not a precursor to more of the same.

Rant Mode Off

ps: anyone who puts 10 Matisses, eight Picassos, two Braques a Soutine and a large Modigliani - on one wall - is probably more into showing off than into Art Appreciation.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#2

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

mjonesrdg

I'm with you, Charlie. It was a Grand Idea....promoting wood turning as Art...and today, wood turning is often about everything but. I remember fondly those "good 'ol days" when excellent form, wonderful finish, and pretty wood, made the cover.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#3

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

John Lucas

Well I like reading about turning in all of it's forms and found that article quite interesting. I mean I can only read so many "how to articles" (and yes I did have a how to article in that magazine) I think it's refreshing trying to expand my world. I mean when most of your world and travels revolve within a few hundred miles of Baxter, TN. you need a little outside help. :)

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#4

Just When You Thought You'd Be Safe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

form all those artist types, here they come again!

How dare they intrude in our dedication to mediocrity! Challenge me to move out of my pedestrian view of the world? Oh, them's fightin' words, fer shur!

Woodturning is a hobby, y'all. That precludes others from aspiring to a greater significance in what they do with wood, Right? After all, it's all wood. It grows on trees. The material is, well, just wood. Not precious or worth anything actually. Certainly some kind of oil with different colored dirt mixed into it and splattered on a piece of fabric must be worth far more.

It's obvious that those people in charge of that Barnes place know little or nothing about art. Why else would they include a bunch of turned wood items among all those high-priced paintings? If that isn't bad enough, the Journal people take it upon themselves to rub our noses in this art-as-big-money thing? I signed up so I could find out which chuck to buy. I don't want to see how to make stuff that's valuable to somebody other than my immediate family. I paid dang good money for my AAW membership, and I expect a properly mind-numbing experience when I get that magazine.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#5

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

robo hippy

This is why Woodturning Design was so popular and in need of resurrection.

robo hippy

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#6

I get that...but,

mjonesrdg

Should we all aspire to the level of "art" that this "Great Idea" would have us to be? One of us (in the wood turning community) in one hundred is an artist that uses a wood lathe,in part or in whole, to create art. The other 99 ought not be treated like red-neck miscreants if we do not relate to what some people consider "art". And, many of the elitist that believe that their turnings have evolved to the point of "art", could not create a really good salad bowl to save their fannies.

That wood turning should be considered an art form, and that some individuals in a position to promote that idea should promote that idea, is, I think, counterproductive. Should all joggers aspire to the Olympics? Should those that enjoy strumming campfire songs aspire to do Jimmy Hendricks? Should all who like to take pictures aspire to ....(you get the idea)

One of the masters wrote these words some years past...." to be pleasing to the eye and the hand".....and this idea remains sufficiently challenging to me and my work.


img

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#7

Re: I get that

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"Should we all aspire to the level of "art" that this "Great Idea" would have us to be?"

Absolutely Not

" One . . . in one hundred is an artist that uses a wood lathe,in part or in whole, to create art. The other 99 ought not be treated like red-neck miscreants if we do not relate to what some people consider "art"."

Agreed again, but that's no reason to close oneself off from learning and exposure to the work of others. You need not argue for your choices, but argue for your limitations and they are, and always will be, yours.

"And, many of the elitist that believe that their turnings have evolved to the point of "art", could not create a really good salad bowl to save their fannies."

Careful there. You're on perilous ground that you may be hard-pressed to prove. Just because an alleged "artist-turner" chooses not to make salad bowls doesn't mean they can't make them; with or without a fanny involvement. You and I may choose to make bowls or jars or magic wands. That doesn't however, give us the right to cut others off from information that may lead them to make other choices.

"That wood turning should be considered an art form, and that some individuals in a position to promote that idea should promote that idea, is, I think, counterproductive."

Woodturning, in both tools and methods available to you and me today, is the direct result of those artist-promoters you accuse of counterproductivity. People, especially hobbyists and beginners, are routinely doing things on a lathe today that not long ago would have been thought impossible. The productivity of all turners has increased many-fold because of the continuous drive to explore and expand the goals and capabilities in order to let ideas and conceptualizations be brought into reality.

"Should all joggers aspire to the Olympics? Should those that enjoy strumming campfire songs aspire to do Jimmy Hendricks? Should all who like to take pictures aspire to ...."

"Should" is the problem as it involves a value judgment with external, cultural parameters. Focus, instead, on "Can" or "May" as personal choices. There was absolutely nothing in the Journal article that implied that readers "should" do anything more than see what others have done, and that turning, whether of simple spindles or jars or, by implication, a salad bowl, can be regarded as art if the maker chooses to go in that direction.

Take a stroll through prestigious museums of art and you'll find woodturning represented in one form or another. You'll find candlesticks, salad bowls, and a host of other objects whose makers dedicated their efforts to the pursuit of making something "pleasing to the eye and the hand".

The AAW is charged with the core obligations to educate and promote woodturning in all its forms. That includes woodturning as "art" as well as woodturning for recreation, for hobby, for utility, or any other purpose anyone can come up with. The AAW Journal does not belong to one segment of the woodturning community. It's mission is very different from regular "for-profit" publications. If you expect otherwise, you will be occasionally disappointed in what lands in your mailbox.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#8

Re: I get that...but,

John Jordan

There is significant number of members that have a lot of interest in such things as museums. Many of us have work in museum and corporate collections. I personally have forty+ pieces in 26 museums. We rarely get any coverage, and when we do, I don't see that it takes anything away from anyone, but rather adds knowledge to anyone that is willing to be open to it. I go to museums everywhere I travel, and its one of the best things I do in my life.

Those AAW Members that are too arty for some are the ones that formed AAW. Those same members are the ones that have created the work in the ANNUAL EOG Auction that have brought in hundreds of thousands of dollars. That money that is used to educate many chapters and beginning turners. Know anyone that has taken advantage of it?

The AAW has done a good job trying to give balance to the organization and have done a good job IMO. There is no way to please everyone. Betty did a great job at producing our journal to be inclusive.

If you are not happy, write some articles, get involved, build an art shelter. I would also suggest the this topic should be taken to the AAW Forum, not here on Ellis' site.

John

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

Keith Tompkins

I GOT IT! we should form an organization that only accepts "pure turners" as members. No embellishments, no added color, anyone who attempts anything but round and brown is OUT! NO exceptions. Wait a minute...I believe that's been done before. If I remember correctly, the three founding members had difficulty recruiting more members. :( Ah, the good old art vs. craft debate!

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#10

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

phillip Medghalchi

Well, I'd say that one who does the turning decide which way he wants to go. This last weekend I had chance to look at Lyle Jamison's album which I never had before, and upon asking him how he did it, he explained that he turns the main body of his work on the lathe then he sit down and carve it and all sort of woodworking techniques that he incorporates to make his final work. Now, we all know he is very well capable of making bowls and as a matter of facts, he has instructions on YOUtube about it. so, are we going to deny that he is a woodturner and artist? Look at his work (if you have done done so) his work is art and it has its own place in artistic pieces. Heck I even asked him if he ever considered teaching in Art university? He has works as bowls too. He is capable of making nice bowls, too. So, I think it's to the individual which way they want to go. If you want to make salad bowls then by all means you can be the best guy who makes bowls that no one can resist picking it up and touching it, on the other hands there are some that lack the ability of knowing the forms and yes they turn and they make shavings, but never a piece that will impress anyone. Well, look at john Jordan's work, or Michael Gibson, what are you going to call them. I put them against any of those guys that did those paintings. heck I am striving to get to that pint. Art is what you see and the emotions you get form looking at an object that took the artist some good time to create it. I don't think any one of those guys I mentioned above just get in there in the shop and crank one of those pieces in 10 min., do you? So, it is art, now wheter or not they go around and call themselves an artist is a different subject, but to me they are making ART. they should be regarded as artists. They put their imaginations and emotions into their works that's why you admire their work, otherwise they would be just like any other turners and you an I wouldn't even know about them, just like I don't know how turners what in Santa Fe (for example, don't' go shooting me for it). We only know about these people because their works are inspiring and if not you wouldn't be seeking their works as your inspiration and you wouldn't try to raise your level of turning to theirs otherwise they would be just like you and I (no disrespect).that's to me is ART,IMO. something that inspires and lifts you as you look at it. Now, if you chose you welcome go tot he shop and make all the shavings you want, and no one even would bother you. once you seek others approval of your work then you are presenting an artistic aspect of your self,and as such yes we do deserve to be respected as such, not every Jon Doe on the street can create what some of these artists can do. (just don't go killing the messenger).

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#11

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

phillip Medghalchi

Keith, I wonder what they call Sam Malloof? Just a guy who put sticks together, huh?

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#12

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

Dale Gillaspy

I started out turning round and brown only and had no aspirations to grow beyond having fun a couple of times a month and making a bowl or 2 for my family. That has grown significantly. For those who choose to stay in a certain "area" of turning, that is great to. To each his own, but people who want to grow in their work should be allowed to without being made to feel that they are not part of the "common" turner. People's work evolves. David Ellsworth (founder) is doing things other than small opening hollow forms. Should he be told to stop? Mike Mahoney had left the production nested bowl world. Should he be told he can't do anything else? The organization is as much theirs as the person who wants to turn an occasional pen or bowl.

I was in the de-briefing meetings for the last AAW symposium, and there was genuine concern on how to make such a broad organization meaningful for everyone involved. I would suggest to you that the recent article is not so much of a departure from the "hobby" turner, but a broadening. Everyone wants more from the organization....safety, insurance, education, but no one wants to pay more dues. Costs keep going up, and additional funds have to come from somewhere. If they can introduce turning to a wider audience, it can only benefit everyone in the long run in the form of greater funding.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#13

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

Curt Stivison

Dad told me if you don't like something or some one don't hang around them.

Curt

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#14

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

Bill Howatt

I admit I probably prefer tool commentary, how to, and round and brown articles but I think it is foolhardy to think the gate should be slammed shut on the more artistic articles. However, I certainly don't want a publication that has too much art vs practical information.

When we have the "Show and Tell" at our club meeting, I don't walk out when a fine piece with carving, piercing, woodburning, or air-brushing is presented. I might think it is something I wouldn't want to bother to do but I usually learn from these pieces.

While I'm on the club analogy, I probably now have less interest in another "How to turn a bowl from green wood" presentation than a presentation on some artsy technique.

It's all about balance.

Bill

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#15

Hangin' Around ALL the Kids . . .

Geoff Whaling

I must admit I see value in hanging around a wide cross section of the wood turning community. I like to learn about the purely technical aspects of our craft, but also about how it transitions into an art form. Now being a turner in Far North Queensland (Australia) I don't get many opportunities to indulge in meeting & hanging around cool & not so cool kids. So between the few accessible symposia I get my fix from the AAW Journal, UK Woodturning and the now defunct Woodturning Design magazine. Each has a niche and IMO all pretty well satisfy that niche.

After Betty hung up her keyboard as AAW editor, I wondered just what Joshua Friend would bring to the Journal and in what direction he would guide it. For the first issue under his control I believe it has a nice balance. Something for everyone but not a whole journal devoted to one "class" of turner.

I have limited exposure or access to museums or significant private collections, so I appreciate an article about a significant collection which broadens my appreciation of the wood turning world. Even if Barnes was only using the wood turnings to create a homely atmosphere they at least expose "art lovers" to their presence & quality. Exton discusses Barnes' respect for craftspeople as artists and how Barnes' developed lectures on the transition and development of our craft.

Curiously all of the well crafted wood turnings displayed in the article are by unidentified makers. Barnes must have seen value in them to collect them but to me that curious trait has a greater meaning. Surely art lovers collect "names" for their prestige. We may well appreciate a Maloof chair but what is the value of an "unidentified makers" wood turned piece? Exton postures their value to Barnes and gives a number of valuable insights into our craft in that article.

So I say - more & please maintain the balance.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#16

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

Wally Dickerman

Six page of our AAW journal devoted to an art collection? Ohmygod fire the editor!

There could have been six pages on turning yo yos or spin tops which is what we all want to see isn't it?

Well I for one enjoyed the article. From the responses here I suspect that some haven't even read the article. The many wood pieces in the collection aren't presented as works of art. They are functional craft pieces. Quoting from the article, "Why should the medium matter? Throughout the collection, with his wood, metal, and other objects, Barnes brought the different traditions of fine art and craft closely together for direct comparison and contemplation". That's basically what the article is about. I find it very interesting.

I've been a member of AAW since the very beginning. I've attended many of the symposioms including the first one in Lexington in 1987 and the last one in Phoenix. The difference in the work shown is astounding! Whether you turn functional pieces or works of art we all started at the same place. Turning our first spindle piece or our first bowl. Some have chosen to broaden their work into art pieces others have not. That's an individual choice. Articles in the Journal should reflect that. I think that this article does.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#17

WOW!!


Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#18

Thank You, Wally

John Altberg

I, too, thought from many of the responses here that the article had gone unread by some before commenting. To my reading, this article had nothing to do with "round & brown" or "art vs. craft". In actuality it was quite complimentary of craftspeople and equated them with artisans! Barnes seems to have been quite interesting and even seemed to shun the "art world". Since many did not share his vision he actually closed his collection to the public. Give it a read folks!

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

Keith Tompkins

Well said, Wally!

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#20

Betty Scarpino

Re: Want a copy of the article?

Betty Scarpino

Excellent take on the article, which like many of you, I found quite interesting. If anyone who is not an AAW member would like to read the article, I would be happy to send you a PDF. Send request to: editorscarpino at gmail.com

I'm no longer editor of the journal, but having worked with Joshua Friend during the transition, I know he will offer a balance of articles, something for everyone.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#21

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

phillip Medghalchi

wally, thank you, you couldn't describe any better. It's the individual that decides to go further in their work, and although I haven't read the article, I think all of the turners should be represented, equally. furthermore, I think we can appreciate that some of our works are considered as Art. In my previous post I mentioned some of the well known pro's works can not be considered just a turning any more with all the efforts they have put into it. they have way passed the just turning point.

Re: Hangin' Around The Cool Kids . . .

#22

I decided to add my 2¢

GaryG in MD

I usually choose not to get involved in the art vs. craft debate, but I think it's important to set the record straight with respect to Josh's new tenure as Editor of American Woodturner.

I agree completely with Wally and the others who have supported the article.

The fact of the matter is that the American Woodturner is NOT A MAGAZINE.

It is a professional Journal that is meant to represent the entirety of AAW membership. And a lot of the members are professionals who aspire to making wood art. So how could the Journal not be designed to fairly represent them, as well as representing the full spectrum of hobbiests, beginners, intermediates, and advanced round and browners? (That term, BTW, is not pejorative! Most of my stuff is R&B -- that doesn't mean I can't appreciate and aspire to something more.)

Hey, the issue in question has a great, practical article by John Lucas. Isn't that balance? With the sad demise of WD, we need to get some articles by David Reed Smith in here. What say, David? ;-)

And I'm very tired about hearing ragging about the cover art that is bold and eye catching and dares to be different and to inspire.

And while we're at it, let's give some kudos to David Fry for his string of very thoughtful and insightful review articles in this and past issues.

I thought Betty did a great job of finding the right balance, and I expect that Josh will do the same. I look forward with pleasure and anticipation to seeing future issues.

...GG