Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

Posts

Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#1

Brad Vietje

Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Brad Vietje

OK, Now I've done it... I read here and elsewhere about using PVC plumbing fittings for a threaded top on a cremation urn, so I did (and the committal service for my mom is Saturday).

BUT, Tab A does not really fit into Slot B.... seems these fittings are tapered somewhat, so while they "fit" and the threads engage and make about 2 complete turns, then they bind up, and I can't get the finial thing in all the way. OOPS!

So, now I have to either grab the threads and turn the plastic away and try again, or maybe there's an easy way to ease the threads a bit with a pipe threader (?) I also need to clean up some of the excess epoxy :\

Practical advice will be most appreciated!

Here's Tab A:


And here's Slot B:


Here's the mis-fit:


...and the entire situation.... no photo booth these days, so a window recess will have to do for now:


Thanks in advance for all your ideas!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#2

Brad Vietje

Just to clarify -- no epoxy is on the threads.

Brad Vietje

Jus

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#3

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Guy Bratt

Your right but alass you learned to late. The threads are tapered for a water tight seal. I would suggest on the finial you replace the male threaded portion with a shorter set of threads from the very end of a new fitting so the finial closes up tight. If you miss a little the next time maybe a short collar on the vessel to could help. Better yet thread the new fitting as far as it will go and cut it flush with the vessel top and fit the ring to the finial tennon. I hope this was clear enough. Guy

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#4

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Bill Howatt

Does it have to be removable after it is filled? You could turn/file/grind away the broader threads near the finial, fill and then epoxy it closed.

Other way would be to do as you suggest and turn off the fitting, cut the fitting down so you are using only the narrow part that fits and re-glue it to the finial.

I don't know if a lubricant like Vaseline would help but I wouldn't force it without it being filled in case you can't get it off again.

Bill

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#5

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Guy Bratt

I had this same problem when I put PVC inserts in some acorns I turned.

As I recall electrical PVC threaded fittings don't have the taper that plumbing fittings have. I'd take a look at that in the future.

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#6

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That's correct on the electrical fittings, but it's not always easy finding them in larger diameters. If you've got access to a pipe tap in that diameter, and if you've got a way to remount the body of the urn, I'd consider turning off all the threads except the ones at the very bottom (measure to make sure the stub will reach those threads), then retap as needed until it fits. If you don't have a pipe tap in that diameter but can remount the body of the urn, reach in with a side-cutting tool of some kind and turn away all but the top couple of threads.

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#7

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Dale Miner

PVC is not the easiest material to thread, but can be done. If you have access to a pipe tap of the correct size, AND if the tap is sharp, you can probably thread the tapered tap into the female fitting and get the parts to screw together until the finial meets the vessel.

A downside to trying would be that the torque required to cut the threads deeper might break the insert loose from the vessel. If that happens, you could make another and tap the fitting larger before gluing into the vessel.

I've recut both male and female threads on PVC before with fairly good luck. The tools must be sharp (new is best) and a little water lubricant for cutting helps.

I don't think you will find a die that can recut the threads on the finial since there is a shoulder that will keep the die from recutting the threads smaller.

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#8

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Brad, I think that given the time element, I would do a bit of hand work on the plug. Use a hacksaw blade to deepen the bases of the upper threads, sand or file to reduce the height of the tips, and use a triangular file to re-shape the threads. It should not take very long.

Dennis

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#9

Steven Antonucci

agree triangular file on the male thread

Steven antonucci

You can use it a 1/4 turn at a time. I am guessing maybe 2-3 light strokes on the thread will get you there.

If not,I like the idea of trying to cut a short section and replacing the existing one if you can get it off? Might be hard without damaging it?

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#10

Steven Antonucci

Wait... another thought!

steven antonucci

If you can get a piece of male thread for that size in metal, grind a couple of grooves into the thread to form a crude tap. You can buy another insert and test it to make sure it cuts the threads larger before touching the vessel insert. if the top screw into the second insert, you'll be OK.

Also, you'll know how much pressure it will require to cut the insert larger, and it keeps you away from the finial so it won't break. Snowballing repairs suck.

If you know any plumbers, they may have something that alleviates the need to make your own tap. You probably only need to cut 5/1000"?

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Mike Stafford

As someone has already suggested you should only use the last 1/4-5/16" of the male and female threads to avoid this tapering problem.

Rut-row is right!

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#12

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Pete in Holland MI

My suggestion is a fresh new tap and thread the urn deeper. Slightly dull and it won't cut but displace the plastic. Check a tool supply house, or maybe the local better-than-normal hardware store. Both may let you borrrow the tap for this one instance, being the project that it is. Else, check out a local machine builder to use his tap at his place.

Forcing the threads, I would guess would eventually break the bond between the wood & PVC.

Yup....pipe threads are tapered to create the leak proof seal. Even if you do cut the threads too deep, they don't need to be leak proof.

Pete

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#13

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

John Lucas

I haven't read all the other responses but I would simply turn a collar that would slip over the threads on the finial that is thick enough to let the finial snug up against it. You could taper the collar to make it look better.

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#14

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Just a Minute now.

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Brad, we have all been bound up in technology here. Let me add that this is a very nice piece of woodturning.

Dennis

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: Just a Minute now.

Brad Vietje

Hey, thanks, Dennis. When I solve the tab A and slot B issue, I'll try to submit a better photo.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#16

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Brad Adams

The trouble is the tenon on the bottom of your finial should only be the length a about 2-3 threads. The fast and easiest thing to do is to chuck up a female connecter, then screw you finial into it. Use a parting tool to turn away the visible PVC threads down to bare wood. Then part off a bit the tenon and glue on a new shorter section of the male thread.

Hope this helps,

Brad Adams

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#17

Brad Vietje

Re: Wait... another thought!

Brad Vietje

Thanks, Steve.

I've tried deepening and widening the "grooves" on the male thread with a very fine tooth pruning saw (much sharper than a hacksaw) and a little diamond needle file (for sharpening the Martel Hook tool), without a lot of success so far.

I'll go get a triangle file (I hate buying tools I already own, but where the heck is it???), and stop by the plumbing supply dealer to see if I can ream out the female thread... Might have to get a 1" iron fitting and bugger up the threads a bit to do that, but PVC is a little gnarly to cut and clean up -- seems to grab and curl more than cut. Maybe the file will clean it up better than the diamond tool (?).

Should know in a hour or so...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Brad Vietje

Thanks, Brad -- I may do that next.

i do have another female piece that I can chuck up and use it as a drive center, plus another male thread that I could cut a lot shorter to use the smaller end of the taper where it fits as-is.... If I can get it to run true, or even close, that should work.

If that fails, I'll try the ream out the hole method, and the triangular file on the male threads. Here's the real rub of all this -- my dad was a pipe fitter in the Navy, and when he died I believe I ended up with most of his plumbing stuff. Somewhere -- somewhere -- I have a complete set of taps and dies for threading pipe, but you'll have to tour my barn to get the full gist of that :( .

Oh well, fingers crossed...

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#19

Re: Rut-Row!  Help Needed ASAP

Mike Brazeau

Nice urn Brad. Since this is a one time thing, why not just remove the threads on the finial by the easiest possible way and glue the remaining tenon when you place the ashes in the urn. Silicone caulk would do the trick or even quick epoxy. It is just short of nine years since I did one for my mom. Tough enough without these problems.

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#20

No help here but sorry about your mother.


Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#21

Brad Vietje

UPDATE:  Got the threads to fit...

Brad Vietje

... well enough to seal up and look OK.

Used the a few different files and wasn't making any real progress until I noticed a little epoxy had oozed out below the bottom of the female threads, on the inside of the top part of the urn. Was able to reach in there and beat it back a bit with a paring knife, a file, and my handy-dandy diamond needle file. That helped quite a bit. Then about 2 hrs work with filing and clearing up and scraping, and filing, and now she fits just fine.

Now to the buffing wheel. I hope to get a decent photo before we bury it.

Thanks to everyone for all the help and advice -- lesson learned!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#22

Re: UPDATE:  Got the threads to fit...

John Lucas

I have used hand chasing tools to straighten PVC pipe threads to make lids for boxes. It's easy to do before you get them glue to anything. After that it's tough which is why I didn't recommend it.

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#23

Brad Vietje

Re: UPDATE:  Got the threads to fit...

Brad Vietje

Well John, you can bet the family farm (and all your dad's straw) that I won't make that mistake again! I may (will) make others, I'm certain -- but not that one!

I'll look into electrical fittings or make sure I tap/chase the threads and they fit well before I cut them and make an epoxy commitment.

Thanks,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Rut-Row! Help Needed ASAP

#24

Re: UPDATE:  Got the threads to fit...

Don Evans

Brad:

Start the habit with epoxy (cause it's so hard) of using vasiline on them just before gluing them in.

More than likely you'll always get squeeze out and the glue will go where you don't want it.

I keep a small jar of it and toothpicks and qtips on the shelf just below the top of my woodworking bench.

All we have to do then is remember to use it!!

Really nice job on the urn, it looks great I'm sure your Mom is proud.

Don