Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long
Dennis in Southern Oregon
Several threads have been posted here regarding the use of walnut oil as a finish, particularly for serving bowls and other treen. The usual issue is, does it dry and do you need a specially formulated variety, e.g., Mahoney’s to insure drying. I have been using grocery store walnut oil for years and have been satisfied by the results. However, in thinking about the issue recently, I realized that it actually is hard to tell when or whether an application of oil has actually hardened. If applied in modest amounts, the oil gets absorbed in a few hours and it is difficult to tell by touch or sight whether it is dry. Maybe I have been unjustifiably satisfied with wet bowls.
I decided to run some objective experiments to see if I could resolve these issues. I selected three examples of walnut oil, two that happened to be available in the local Safeway store, and Mahoney’s Utility Finish Walnut Oil. For the record, the Safeway oils were: La Tourangelle Roasted Walnut Oil from California, and International Collection Walnut Oil from the UK. Because of the difficulty of judging dryness of oil absorbed in wood. I used strips of paper towels as the scaffold. I reasoned that being a wood product, the paper should mimic any catalytic activity associated with wood. The advantage of paper is that when the oil dries the texture of the paper changes dramatically. It gets crisp instead of limp, and no oil will rub off on your hand when you handle it.
In early May of this year, I lightly saturated a separate strip of paper towel with each of the candidate oils and hung them in a dark closet. The temperature was generally in the 70-75 degree range. I checked the strips periodically for 12 weeks, and found them all to be limp and oily. Therefore, I decided to run another experiment, this time with a new set of strips exposed to sunlight inside my house. I hung the strips on the inside of a south-facing window that provided about 6 hours of full to dappled sunlight. Again, I checked the strips periodically. All were still oily after 5 days, but all were dry after 10 days. (Clearly I should have checked them more often as it turned out.)
My conclusions are: (1) Walnut oil will not cure in a reasonable time if kept in the dark, (2) Exposure to indoor sunlight will promote hardening in a reasonable time and (3), at least two supermarket brands of walnut oil seem to dry about as fast as the specially formulated Mahoney’s oil. I speculate that drying time would be even shorter under exposure to sunlight outdoors where the UV intensity is high.
Dennis
.jpg)



