Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

Posts

Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#1

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Several threads have been posted here regarding the use of walnut oil as a finish, particularly for serving bowls and other treen. The usual issue is, does it dry and do you need a specially formulated variety, e.g., Mahoney’s to insure drying. I have been using grocery store walnut oil for years and have been satisfied by the results. However, in thinking about the issue recently, I realized that it actually is hard to tell when or whether an application of oil has actually hardened. If applied in modest amounts, the oil gets absorbed in a few hours and it is difficult to tell by touch or sight whether it is dry. Maybe I have been unjustifiably satisfied with wet bowls.

I decided to run some objective experiments to see if I could resolve these issues. I selected three examples of walnut oil, two that happened to be available in the local Safeway store, and Mahoney’s Utility Finish Walnut Oil. For the record, the Safeway oils were: La Tourangelle Roasted Walnut Oil from California, and International Collection Walnut Oil from the UK. Because of the difficulty of judging dryness of oil absorbed in wood. I used strips of paper towels as the scaffold. I reasoned that being a wood product, the paper should mimic any catalytic activity associated with wood. The advantage of paper is that when the oil dries the texture of the paper changes dramatically. It gets crisp instead of limp, and no oil will rub off on your hand when you handle it.

In early May of this year, I lightly saturated a separate strip of paper towel with each of the candidate oils and hung them in a dark closet. The temperature was generally in the 70-75 degree range. I checked the strips periodically for 12 weeks, and found them all to be limp and oily. Therefore, I decided to run another experiment, this time with a new set of strips exposed to sunlight inside my house. I hung the strips on the inside of a south-facing window that provided about 6 hours of full to dappled sunlight. Again, I checked the strips periodically. All were still oily after 5 days, but all were dry after 10 days. (Clearly I should have checked them more often as it turned out.)

My conclusions are: (1) Walnut oil will not cure in a reasonable time if kept in the dark, (2) Exposure to indoor sunlight will promote hardening in a reasonable time and (3), at least two supermarket brands of walnut oil seem to dry about as fast as the specially formulated Mahoney’s oil. I speculate that drying time would be even shorter under exposure to sunlight outdoors where the UV intensity is high.

Dennis

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#2

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

robo hippy

That will confirm at least part of what Mike Mahoney and Mike Meridith (the Doctor's Woodshop) say in that the walnut oil does like UV to help it cure. I believe that the Doctor said that there is a lot of difference in the store bought walnut oils, which is probably true about any manufactured item. I have thought that the Doctor's walnut oil mix does cure a bit faster, but haven't tried a comparison drying like you did, and I don't have any of Mike Mahoney's oil any more to compare. The Doctor's mix does have his 'microagregated' carnuba wax in it, and that could be part of the 'feeling' dry part. I do get a crust/skin on the outsides of the bottles, and the grey synthetic steel wool pads I use do get rigid after a while. When I was using only Mahoney's oil, they would stay wet for a long time, but if I leave the Doctor's oil soaked pads out, they are stiff in a month or so.

robo hippy

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#3

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

don stephan

Unfortunately, more oil will be present in raw wood after a wet first application. I would suggest making three test blocks using a common bowl wood. Sand all surfaces to your usual final grit, then apply each of the oils to one block as you would a new bowl. Place each on a nail board or hang from a screw eye for a couple days, then place on clean paper towels overnight to check for oil transfer.

when I tried one of the commercial walnut oils, I was applying it like an oil-varnish blend - for the first coat, keeping wiping on until the wood seems saturated, than after a couple minutes scrub dry with a clean paper towel and let cure on a nail board. Recoat per instructions. After 3 coats and what I thought was a reasonable curing time, I put the bowl in the window. I happened to move it a week later and found an oily ring on the shelf that had transferred from the bottom of the bowl. Gave the rest of the bottle away and went back to traditional blend of mineral spirits, boiled linseed oil and alkyd varnish.

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#4

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

mjonesrdg

Here is a direct cut and paste quote from Bob Flexner's Understanding Wood Finishes[/i] "But what good does penetration do? Very little. You can totally fill a piece of wood with a linseed oil finish, and it will do nothing to protect the surface (See A, B) of the wood from damage. Coarse objects will scratch the wood, stains will stain the wood, and water will smudge the wood almost as easily as if there were no finish in the wood." believe the same would hold true of walnut oil.

So, the mistake that I made some years ago, was to top-coat the Mahoney's walnut oil with an oil varnish in order to get my bowl to quit leaking"..."bleeding" the walnut oil. Mike Mahoney advised me personally of the gravity of this error, and told me that the oil, now sealed off from oxygen rich air, could be prevented from ever drying. And, to their credit, Lee Valley issues an instruction sheet that advises about top coating short of three months drying time.

http://www.leevalley.com/us/shopping/TechInfo.aspx?type=a&p=59385

So, we ought not topcoat our bowls/kitchen ware over walnut oil applications, (short of 3 months drying time) but if we don't, the surface goes unprotected.

And I must wonder...the last coat of walnut oil applied, having the greatest access to oxygen and UV light, would have the same negative effect as any other topcoat...right? And, isn't a wax a topcoat as well?

Further, we learn that all nut, seed and vegetable oils rancidify. It's a law of nature, like gravity. The only thing that stops rancidity is complete polymerization. I wouldn't worry too much though....there must be thousands of wood bowls out there that have been saturated with rancid oils now, and there hasn't been any reported deaths or lawsuits yet (that I am aware of).

The walnut oil that I have experimented with has always polymerized to a hardness of very soft rubber. We know that when oils are added to varnish, it softens the varnish, and when these oils are used straight the product is only slightly harder than wax.

Mike Meredeth (Dr's Workshop), has helped me greatly with technical questions that I have asked of him and I believe that his web site will provide a answers to any of your questions as well.


img

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#5

Interesting

David Walser

A couple of years ago, I accidentally left out some walnut oil (Mahoney's) in a small stainless steel bowl. (I use the bowl to hold the oil when finishing on the lathe.) The bowl had about 1/4" of oil in it and sat in my shop on top of my tool chest for about a week before I noticed it. By then, the oil had hardened into a rubbery mass that I could not remove from the bottom of the bowl. (A soak in mineral spirits did the trick.)

Three observations:

1. The spot where the bowl was left does not get any sunlight. It is always in the shade. So, while UV light might help with hardening, it is not essential.

2. The oil was fairly deep (at least 1/4"), yet all the oil hardened, not just the top surface. I'm not sure what this says about whether the oil hardens below the surface of the wood or not. I suspect that the oil typically doesn't penetrate more than 1/8" and that all the oil will harden.

3. My shop is in Mesa, Arizona. It was over 80 degrees in the shop with close to zero humidity. I suspect that heat (or lack thereof) and humidity have a lot to do with how quickly the oil hardens.

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Interesting

Jesper, Denmark

Generally speaking, the speed of chemical reactions increase with temperature. So the hardening of the oil by oxidation goes faster at your high shop temperature.

That is also how you can speed up the reaction with friction on the lathe.

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#7

Re: Interesting

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Unless mistaken walnut oil for woodturners come from salad oil industry. All you need is oxygen for walnut oil to form a film or polymerization. Of course temperature and humidity will affect curing/drying time.

One reason walnut oil from salad oil, organic-health food and art supplies industries does not go rancid is perfumes & vitamin E additives. What is added, not added varies by producers often not listed on containers. The heat treatment walnut salad oil undergoes is hot pressing. Hot pressing provides the most oil from nuts.

Normally see these procedures used to make stand oil (linseed) but work with any drying oil. If want to increase viscosity and speed up drying of your walnut oil can use same technique artist use. These techniques been around since 16th century. Set your walnut oil out in the sun in a clear bottle for days or heat the oil to 140c or 284f for several hours. No idea on days or hours required!

Not aware of polymerized walnut oil available by any vendor due to cost. Have to go to patents on polymerization of drying oils process requires high temperatures, heat, pressure, and chemicals. Have to go to patents to find exactly how they do it.

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#8

Thanks for the info, Dennis

GaryG in MD

That's good to know. ...GG

===========

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#9

one thing I do know...

Chuck Jones - West Tennessee

I recently used walnut oil (the one with the French sounding name) to wet sand two bowls that were giving me trouble. Worked great, but the bowls would not dry. I put them outside in the sun for about four hours because I thought that would help. Oil came out of the end grain like a dripping faucet. I took them back in without looking at the bottoms and in a few minutes I discovered that the bottom of each bowl was covered by a gillion tiny ants.

This thread is timely and interesting to me. Because I have been thinking about switching from Maloof Poly/Oil to walnut oil... at least until I discovered the drying issues. Plus I was ready to cover the walnut oil with Maloof Oil. Hmmmm, seconds thoughts now. Thanks for all the input.

Re: Some Experiments on Walnut Oil - Long

#10

Re: one thing I do know...

mjonesrdg

I had the opportunity to talk with the Director of Quality Control at La Tourangelle Walnut Co. (Hahn Nyugen). She is a chemist and does some limited lab work there at their Stockton, California offices but outsources testing for "the record".

Interestingly, she was surprised to learn that some people use walnut oil for wood finishing. She confirmed for me that their "cold pressed" walnut oil would be expected to behave the same way that "refined" walnut oil behaves...that is, it would rancidify at the same rate and polymerize at the same rate. And, that the older the oil, the slower it would be to dry. She emphasized that the oil produced at their plant would always have a "Best Used By:" date, which is two years after expeller pressing.