Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

on ideas and talent...

Posts

on ideas and talent...

#1

Steven Antonucci

on ideas and talent...

Steven antonucci

Have you ever had an idea that you knew you didn't have the talent to execute?

What would you do? Execute it to the best of your ability? Hold on to it until your skills hopefully improve? Collaborate with someone that has the talent.

Please share your thoughts and reasoning.

Steve

Re: on ideas and talent...

#2

I can't get any better unless I try

jeff Willaford

If I only attempted work I knew I could do I wouldn't have a shop nor any tools. I'm a firm believer that I can do anything I try to do. Of course, it often takes me many, many tries to get there but they call that practice.

Think of where you would be if you never attempted something that pushed your limits. Sounds dull to me.

The over-riding factor... if it doesn't feel safe it probably isn't.

Re: on ideas and talent...

#3

Re: I can't get any better unless I try

Mike Potts

Steve, Whatever the mind can conceive and believe, can be achieved. Take your time, break it down one step thought thru, and tried. When your done you will have the skills for what your attempting. As always, be safe

Mike

Re: on ideas and talent...

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: on ideas and talent...

Keith Tompkins

HI Steve, Good topic! I have very little motivation to turn something I already know I can do...Even if I'm in the middle of a project, I'll put it aside to begin something new and challenging. I often make sketches of a proposed idea in order to work out details of how it could be accomplished, then make small models or samples to help visualize the result. It's good to start with a simple idea, then build upon it, getting more complex as you go.....a series of pieces. When I teach turning, I always emphasize both aspects of the craft: technical skills and design skills. Without both, I feel one is a bit handicapped. Poor technical skills keep you from progressing as a turner; forever blowing up pieces, and producing oversanded work that you are never happy with, and poor design skills often leads one to simply copy the work of others. This I think applies to all creative endeavors....I was learning a song on my guitar "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen. I was struck by a friend's recollection of finding him sitting on the floor of his apartment banging his head on the floor in frustration, trying to find just the right words for the song. To me turning is very similar, you can't experience the joy of creating something new without time, effort, even a great amount of thought and the stress that goes along with it.

Re: on ideas and talent...

#5

Re: on ideas and talent...

John Lucas

In many cases you should just go for it. Patience can often succeed when you don't have the skills. My first award was a first prize in an art competition among all types of art. I won it for a piece that was mostly carved. I had no carving skills at that time. I just had an idea that had to come out. It had baby legs on the bottom I carved it a coping saw wood rasp jewelers saw a d sandpaper glued to sticks

Even today I look back at some of the work I did 20 years ago and wonder how I did it. Obviously very careful scraping sanding and some gluing e amuse I did have the turnin skills I have today.

Even if you do build it you may find out years later that you can do it better. I have an older piece right now that I'm going to redo because I feel I can improve virtually all of it

Re: on ideas and talent...

#6

Steven Antonucci

I know how to do what I want to do

Steven antonucci

But I also know that I do not have the talent to execute it the way I see it.

Never will.

You can train for some things, and get better. However, no amount of effort will ever result in me being good at them. I will never sing or paint well. I don't see developing them, so it is either collaborate or don't produce everything you imagine.

My question was more philosophical. I have no specific issue to resolve.

S

Re: on ideas and talent...

#7

Re: on ideas and talent...

dick gerard

Excellent topic, Steve. Here is my take: we are a bit like turtles ... we never get anywhere unless we are willing to stick our necks out. This does not mean we should do something dangerous that could result in injury or worse. I think it means we should try and in trying, we risk failure. Failure is a great teacher. By failing we know what NOT to do, what will not work to help us achieve our desired or envisioned goal. It is said that Edison invented 10,000 ways NOT to create a lightbulb before he discovered the right way.

I know myself and I know that the first attempt at something new is fraught with unknowns. How do I do this, how do I do that, what if this happens or that happens? I sketch the end result, then I work backwards, to the beginning, a block of wood. from there I try to envision each step, sketch it out, anticipate problems in mounting, tool access, sanding ... every step of the way. Of course, the old saying still holds true ..."Man Plans and God Laughs!" But, with my "away from the lathe pre-turning sketch and analysis " done, i feel better able to cope with whatever may come.

Even after all of this, once i get the vision to come into reality, I always go back and look for better ways to accomplish the same end. I will do this many times (I am a slow learner), until it is so ingrained that I really don't have to analyze it any more. That usually coincides with the time I feel compelled to do something new cause i am done with that particular "series".

PS. Thank you Clay Foster for getting me addicted to this whole sketch book design ideas madness!!!!!! I now have more idea-design sketch books full of stuff than I could possibly pursue if I lived to be the age of Methuselah!