I'm having fun driving around the 127 yard sale. For those who don't know about it , it runs from Kentucky all the way down to Alabama. My girl friend lives 2 miles from it so we have to drive through a continuous yard sale just to go to the grocery And of course I have to stop. Bought 3 antique planes a rip saw a square and a large tap handle so far
Anyway the reason I'm posting this is the price of wooden bowls. One guy had mediocre closed form bowls with a bark inclusion or hole in the side. They were thick and uneven thickness especially on the bottom. The finish was plastic looking. Sanded fairly well. He was asking $220. Right down from him was a guy selling spalted maple bowls. Fairly thin rims with thicker bottoms. Sanded very well with no marks. A kind of hand rubbed satin finish. Very nice forms His prices. $30. I did get to talk to him for a minute and he was a beginner but certainly had nice work for the time he had been turning.
Now I don't k ow where the other guy was from but I thought his work was over priced for the quality. The beginner on the other hand was probably underpriced but In this area probably about right. I hope I can go back buy later this weeks d and see how their sales go
Spent last weekend in a chair at the NJ State Fair with my spoon carving gear. Brought some tops to sell too.
The spoons take 2-3 hours and I had them priced at $20-30. Sold 2, got a ton attaboys and a bunch of sticker shock faces. The wood was free from a branch pile.
The tops were $10. They can be made in 2 minutes, but I probably average 5-8 minutes. The wood might be $.50? Sold at least a dozen.
Nobody needs a $25 wooden spoon. Some people will pay it. Nobody needs a $10 top. More people will pay for it.
Somewhere there is a buyer for an ugly $200 bowl. There are probably more buyers for $30 nice enough bowls. Connecting the buyer with the object in the moment is the magic of putting yourself out there!
I guess I would rather give a bowl away compared to selling it for $30. Evidently he doesn't intend to make it a profitable endeavor. There is always the volume theory. Loose money on every piece, but make it up on volume. LOL
John, interesting subject and many folks struggle with this issue all over other forums. I have seen this discussion a lot. I gather it all depends on the buyer if he/she is willing to pay for what your are asking and if they recognize inferior product or lesser quality work from artist. I think really the artist sometimes get a big head and price themselves out of the market and once the food doesn't show up on the table then the reality hit them. Then the other flip side of it, is that if the artist doesn't rely on that sale for making a living then he can wait for someone to come along and pay for his ambition price. I can add that art is subjective to the viewer and what someone would consider something art and pay for the enjoyment of it may not look art to another person. I think this is what determines the price. Of course as I mentioned some people are really full of big head and they think they really made something extraordinary.
Hopefully, you get to talk with both of these guys and get into their head and ask them qsn. to see how they arrived at those prices.
I am interested to find out what you discover. I strive to price mine accordingly.
Steven well said. Like you mentioned, some people think why would I need to have $20 spoon when a I/ can use a cheap plastic one. Then on the other hand your spoon could have rekindled a memory of a nice dinner out somewhere in a restaurant and they used rustic spoon. then your buyer will buy it.
I dealt in sale for along time and there is very creative psychology goes into how to get your buyer to buy on impulse and therefore pricing our items according to it. Selling and pricing your goods an art in itself.
Dick, then what about the artist confidence. he may not have that much confidence about himself that he is worth that much he is asking for, or he compared himself to the others and figured he fits in that price range. of course then John came around and he judged it in his mind that this new turner didn't price his bowls right. Then look at how many thing John has seen around in turnings, so he has a better reference for what it was available out there. Now, lets go back 20 years back when we didn't have this capability of the internet interaction, I would not know anything about this yard sale and would not have any ideas about what things sell for you at your neck of the wood, so I go about pricing myself with the price range of the folks around here in my area.
I say "free", but we all know that everything has a cost. More importantly, everything has a value.
99% of the bowls I make are made from free wood.
The wood is free if you don't count the gas to drive over and get it or the depreciation on my truck. Or the gas to cut it out of the log. Or the wear and tear on my chainsaw. Or my lathe and the electricity it takes to run it.
So, I recognize that there is no free for me the maker. I haven't even considered factoring in my time yet. What is my time in a piece? Is it the time I have spent in just that piece, or the accumulation of all of the hours I have spent building skills to the point where I can confidently put work in the market?
That is where value comes in.
I do not seek to make a ton of money in doing this. I seek people who recognize the value of what I do. It is hopeless to try to account for all of the costs and put a fair price on the work. Utterly hopeless. However, putting the well made work in the hands of people who value it has value... to me.
There has to be a barrier (money), because people will take anything for free. I watched people throwing things away at the garbage can outside of our booth (pamphlets, etc) and thought "why did you take it?" The answer was simple: it was handed to them for free. They didn't want it, but because it was free...they took it.
There was a woman who bought two of my "high end tops", which I had priced at $20 ea. They were made from ebony spindles with olive discs, and I probably spent more time on them than I should have for $20. She asked how much for both, so I said I would take $35. She handed me $40, and I didn't have a $5, so I gave her back the $10 I had rather than running around looking for change.
Why?
Because it wasn't about the money. It can't be. You'll make yourself nuts.
This is a perennial issue, where one person charges too much (and I might say should refrain from selling his work until he gets better at it), while the other charges perhaps too little.
For someone producing really fine work, there's just no way we can charge enough to pay ourselves a fair wage for a rare skill set. Think of all the brake shops or auto repair shops that charge $75/hr or more, but there are a hundred of these shops in a small travel radius, but perhaps only 3-4 turners who can turn our really fine work in the same area. Who's work is more specialized? The turner, of course, but everyone is convinced they need to drive, and very few are convinced they need a $200 bowl or $2,000 piece of art for their display case.
The real damage can come from the retired old duffer who "just wants to cover his expenses", and sells his well-executed work for $30, while you are trying to sell similar quality work for a more reasonable $100.... happens all the time, and some of these guys are splendidly nice people.
For really well-made bowls, with good form, great finish, and good execution, I think somewhere in the $10/inch area is a pretty fair price -- and more for rare wood, spalting or great figure -- but many people won't or can't pay that, and in many areas that's a lot of money, especially when a 10" plastic bowl costs about $8.99 at Wal*Mart.
We need to remember we are selling finely crafted, hand-made work, not Chinese injection-molded crap, and stick to our guns at times. Beautiful craftsmanship -- or even fine art, in some cases -- is never going to compete for low price with the mainstream stuff -- nor should it! A roadside community yard sale might be the wrong venue for well-made work -- I don't think you'll see John Jordan or William Hunter setting up a booth at that venue!
So, there you have it -- selling & pricing stuff is very difficult, very regional and sometimes very frustrating. The better your work, the more difficult the battle -- until you get into the upper-level shops and galleries. If we have stuff that's nice enough, the solution might be to sell it in a better market in another area -- a nicer gallery or craft shop that attracts the customer you're looking for, though that also means giving up 30% - 50% in commission, and having to raise your (retail) prices quite a bit to get paid what you believe you are worth.... and so, the plot thickens!
Steven, you couldn't describe it any better. Exactly that is the point. Putting it in the hands of people who will appreciate what you have accumulated over time to make something like that.
Brad, beautifully put" "but everyone is convinced they need to drive, and very few are convinced they need a $200 bowl or $2,000 piece of art for their display case."
The main need and the purpose of a purchase dictates the price. If the guy doesn't drive he can not work and feed the family, but he can feed them off a Chinese crap for $2.00 bowl (or better yet look at what they are selling at Target under wooden bowl- w/ all the glorious stickers of Wooden then it's machined made bowl. mass production nicely cut, crappy glue joint......... ) however, this is not getting any easier.
Brad, you are right on the mark. This year I started showing at what I call high end juried shows. I was sick of not getting my price on my product so I decided to go to a better market. Two weeks ago I was at a show where I moved $2000 worth of bowls/vases/etc one of which went for $450 by itself. If you want to get fair value for your work you have to go to that market. Go to the best shows, get a nice booth set up, decorate it well, engage your customers. Don't expect people to pay a good buck for your product just because you think you put a lot of work in to it. And don't eff up the market by giving it away. This of course is IMHO. Ron.
What a timely thread for me. I've got to that point where I had three options, since i'm getting a lot of my work taking up space. 1) Quite turning, yea right I'm addicted, 2) build an addition on the house, not going to happen, 3) try to sell my work. I opened an ETSY shop on line. Trying to figure out the price to ask has been on of the most difficult parts of listing my items. Right now I'm that retired old duffer, I'm in a position that I really don't need the income from sales of my pieces. I've always valued my time and skills, and would keep what I have rather than dump it cheap.
Question: have any of you used ETSY and what was your experience? I see $10.00 per inch for bowls, for example I listed a salad bowl set where the salad bowl was 12 1/2" with 4 Serving bowls that where 6 1/2" this was made from flame box elder, I'm asking $450.00 does that seem right?
thank for any help
Mike
Hope you guys have a great week-end, I'm heading to Lake Erie to catch some Perch
I've worked with artists for 26 years photographing their work. You have to find the venue a d location that will pay the prices you need to get
The 127 yard sale I was describing is not a place for $200 bowls. On the other hand the guy who was learning to turn had a good market for his learning bowls a d they were priced pretty well for what they were a d where they were. He and his wife had lots of other stuff as well.
Well, Dang it anyway!!! While youse guys are sweating your life away turning the perfect bowl into a perfect piece of art to sell for a perfectly tremendous price to maintain the "market price" for all those other guys, I turn for FUN!!! And I don't care whether you like it or not,(No offense intended) but it really tickles my ego when someone buys one of my less than perfect bowls, or whatever, vase, pen, plate, "art piece"! That "feel good" feeling is why I go on to the next item, and why I sand the snot out of every one of them, and why I spend the time and money to finish them (Bowls and Plates and Platters) with Tung Oil as it makes them usable in the kitchen and dining room, not put away somewhere to keep off the fingerprints. And other than the 90+ temps, I would still do it every day if I could hide it from my Cardiologist! Dang, it's awesomely FUN!!!
Selling is a whole different art form. I remember looking at Etsy years ago, and saw some excellent bowls for almost nothing and some real junk for way too much. I said no thanks. I sold one piece at our local Saturday Market for $350 which blew me away, and a visiting turner who was sitting with me at the time said, "that would have sold for $3,000 at any gallery in New York City". Another client would come up from LA, and buy, happily, at my retail prices, and take them to his up scale store and easily double my price. To get good prices, you have to get to good shows with a reputation for bringing in buyers. There are craft fair review guides, but they only tell part of the story. I have found some that are way over priced and over rated. Some that were the other way around. I do think it is important for people to be able to pick the bowl up and hold it. For me, 6 inch bowls go for $10 to $30. 14 inch bowls from $60 to $200, depending on a lot of different things. There is no exact formula, no matter where you are.
Mike, it is not your price in my opinion, then read the discussion above. Plus, your challenge are the other guys that post their prices for way too less, and would you really need to eat off of a $450.00 bowl to feel full and satisfied, or your feed your children form it when their whole attention is to gobble up the food and get back to their video games or on line. Your audience for those prices will not look on ETSY for that kind of stuff. They would be the couple who has enough discretionary money so when they sit together to eat they enjoy visiting and savoring the food rather than chumpping it down. Like some of us mentioned their is a lot of psychology of selling and fulfilling ones need that dictates the pricing. for that kind of price you need to go where the buyer is. Like, in Robo, instance, it may very well be that the guy would pay Robo's price at his asking place and take it back to CA and sell the same thing for 5 times what he paid for. Just because he drinks with those guys that pay $5000 /night at hotel to enjoy themselves. I had the feeling that this thread is not going to be that easy to discuss. There are so many angles to look at it. if I did what Robo, did providing the quality of the work is the same at a Sat market around my area I wouldn't be able to get $350 for it, we don't have the general public in that kind of range going to the market. Look at our housing prices in San Antonio, a comparable house to mine in LA, CA area would go for $400K, I didn't pay that much for mine. so, you see where I am going with this? Your particular market dictates your pricing. Now, if you contact a well known gallery in your area who caters to well to do then you can sell it for that price. Wehn you go on ETSY, you see the guy from other side of the world whose cost of living is less, prices his for what he thinks his work is worth in his currency. I don't have to tell you how fancy you can live with your retirement salary in Mexico, or even some of the African country, now do you think if you took your hobby and made the same thing there you can sell it for $350? ( that country)
The problem is that they don't actually appreciate it unless they pay full price for it. It is like war stories, or other extremes. Don't personally have the former, but do have my share of the latter. Why tell someone what it was like to go through it, they will never see what you see. When people get famous like Maloof, conceptually making better stuff, more complex and refined than the rest of us. Is it all of a sudden the case that people understand the higher level work, and jump right past understanding the lower level work? No, they don't get any of it. And if you don't charge what work is really worth, they you are part of the problem because you don't get it either, and are not willing to make others stop long enough to one day figure it out.
Of course, one does not have to be an advocate for a craft, or stand up for others and the work they do as well as one's own. Seriously. Wood turning is a hobby and you have to move the waste to the curb. The waste includes the masses of product we don't know what to do with. But the process through which it rises to it's true value is understandable, we jusst can't be bothered. I was never really willing to sell my work either. It is a whole other thing. And turning is a very productive means of making stuff, probably the fastest we have in woodworking, but I am not going to fool myself that the peasants get it.
Whats happening down here is we have a new buyer in the market
Not only are the Chinese plundering our Swamp Kauri .Tons and Tons are being shipped out of the county all because they found a loop whole .Any Kauri has to be processed before it is allowed out
So what are they doing water blasting giving a coat of varnish and calling it a statue.
What this has done is pushed the price up of Kauri and also means the average jo woodturner cannot go onto a site or land anymore and help yourself .A subdivision down the road that normally Id be able to go in and get 2 or 3 tonne has been fenced and trucks are going in as its been lifted out of the ground With Asians standing at the gate paying the owners of the land big dolaros and I mean thousands for a truck load
Then we have Asians wanting finished items .Last week I had a group come up and they wanted 200 bowls yesterday . They had to be floor-less with no defects .I had only 3 that suited them in stock .
"We want discount" ,Sir I only sell wholesale (I only have one price same for Galleries or individuals ) My Big Salad bowls are $300 each in the end I did knock of $100 Then The how much for 200 started I said the same Price as you just paid .(To much like hard work this bartering) woodturning is my hobbie so I said heres a mates number he is doing the 200 For $90 each he says hes never made so much money To Me it just wouldn't add up .Plus turning 200 bowls would drive me nuts .What he doesn't realize he will end up turning 250 so they have a choice.
Had another mate that runs his own Gallery/craft shop 2 months ago Asians walked in and wanted all his stock in one go .
He wouldnt budge on the price ,his theory was if they took everything how long would it take him to make up enough product so the regular tourists had something to buy.
No Stock the buses would stop coming as the drivers here get a cut to make them stop A con but no pay no visit
Wow, Terry, I don't have lots of hair on my head ,b ut this on one is making me lose some more. those clowns haven't gotten through depleting the earth yet. I heard something on the World news about it. How in the world you r government allow this massacre of ancient wood. Are they that desperate too? Fi they regulate the darn thing the individual has no say so, about it. Evidently. in New Zealand, it's all different?
What I don't think has been mentioned is whether a bowl is designed for production. We all know that a 6" bowl 2" deep can take 10 minutes to turn and allow power sanding when dry, or take 30-40 minutes to turn and require hand sanding. How tight is the radius in the transition, does it have bead or band at the rim? How much time was spent blocking out blanks from a plank so that the flat cut growth ring pattern is perfectly or nearly perfectly centered in the bottom of the bowl? Is the growth ring pattern quarter cut, meaning the blanks are individually cut from the log, with greater waste than using planks? Does it have the quickest possible finish, or 4-5 wipe on coats of varnish for great durability and usability?
I suspect your set might be worth $450, but not on Esty. I had the same impression Robo had, and I suspect it's just not the place to get what a piece is really worth.
Mike, I recently had a discussion with an artist (not a turner tho) that uses Etsy. She said it is a pretty good market for items selling for less than $100, but after that, not so much. I have played with the idea of using it, but can't get off my butt to photograph every item, and then monitor the sales. I do mostly regional art shows and the Saturday market around here.
I've only got one data point, which is a set like yours in cherry, with the smaller bowls being slightly larger and the larger bowl being larger by a couple of inches. I did not charge anywhere near that much, but it is all subjective.
Of note, I would likely omit the reference to "firewood pile save", as it probably doesn't help the cause (Hey! I got nothing into this, but I want $450 for it...)