Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

3 new tools for the sharpening test

Posts

3 new tools for the sharpening test

#1

3 new tools for the sharpening test

John Lucas

Here's the tools I made. Got the top one from Doug Thompson, the middle one was a Henry Taylor scarper, and the bottom one I made my self from High Carbon steel hardened to 60 rockwell.

I ground the edges to 28 degree included angle. I sharpened them to 1500 grit and then stropped them. All 3 seem to be equally sharp in that they cut paper incredibly easy and shave hair. I doubt anyone sharpens their skews this sharp. Pretty close maybe but these are about as sharp as I get anything in my shop.

I'm going to send these off to a professional sharpening service that appears to sharpen things better than I can. I guess we'll see. For all practical purposes I've already proved my point and that is, you can get high speed steel and particle metal steel as sharp as High Carbon Steel. Well maybe not at the microscopic level which I hope to find out when I get them back, but for practical use in the shop I can't tell the difference. So go ahead and buy whatever you want because they will get sharp enough.

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

#2

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

Bart Leetch

Well John this should be interesting.

We will await your further research to find out if your research is skewed or not. :D

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

#3

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

David Walser

Interesting. The debate about the sharpen-ability of the various steels has raged for years. Some suggest that the size of the particles making up the steels differs to the extent that the newer steels (with larger particles) cannot be made as sharp as high carbon steels.

I've long believed that the particle size was never the problem. Instead, I think woodturners who were used to sharpening high carbon steels tried to use the same sharpening methods with the newer steels. The newer steels are more resistant to abrasion and what worked well for sharpening high carbon steel didn't work as well for HSS. With newer sharpening tools and techniques (such as CBN wheels), turners are now able to get the newer steels just as sharp they could with high carbon steels. It'll be nice to have some proof, one way or another.

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

#4

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

John Lucas

I don't think you need different tools, you simply have to sharpen long enough to get the edge on whatever steel. When you can feel the burr roll over with the grit you switch to the other side and then to the next grit.

I've sharpened the Powdered metal and HSS tools with the same tools I use for carbon steel. It might take a little longer to get to the edge but they all work.

It's the hardness of the metal that may make a difference as well as the composition. It took only slightly longer to get the same edge on the Powdered steel and High speed steel tools than it did for the High Carbon Steel.

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

#5

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

Bob Macgregor

All may start out equally sharp, but it does matter how well they hold an edge while in use.

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

#6

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

John Lucas

Well I'm going to attempt to show that if I can work out the details of the test. Unfortunately to do it right I think the test would have to be repeated several times and I probably won't do that.

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

#7

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

David Walser

John, I don't think we disagree. The sharpening methods and tools that worked with high carbon steel also work with the newer steels. However, since the newer steels are more wear resistant (which is different than hardness), it might take longer to sharpen a powder metal gouge than it would one made of high carbon steel. What might be accomplished with a few strokes of a hone with high carbon steel might require more effort with the newer steels. Thus, someone might conclude that high carbon steel gets sharper than the newer steels merely because he quits sharpening the newer tools before they're fully sharp.

Newer sharpening equipment (such as CBN wheels and Tormek's black wheel) address this issue by reducing the time it takes to sharpen HSS and powder metal tools.

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

#8

Re: 3 new tools for the sharpening test

phillip Medghalchi

John, didn't you this comparison before, or was it someone else that they showed the difference in the molecular composition under an ultra sonic magnifying glass that the sharpened edge was jaggedy on high carbon tool steel that's why it did lose sharpness sooner? I remember reading about it somewhere, but this is good to learn. It was like the distance of the molecules were much open VS newer steels.