3 new tools for the sharpening test
John Lucas
Here's the tools I made. Got the top one from Doug Thompson, the middle one was a Henry Taylor scarper, and the bottom one I made my self from High Carbon steel hardened to 60 rockwell.
I ground the edges to 28 degree included angle. I sharpened them to 1500 grit and then stropped them. All 3 seem to be equally sharp in that they cut paper incredibly easy and shave hair. I doubt anyone sharpens their skews this sharp. Pretty close maybe but these are about as sharp as I get anything in my shop.
I'm going to send these off to a professional sharpening service that appears to sharpen things better than I can. I guess we'll see. For all practical purposes I've already proved my point and that is, you can get high speed steel and particle metal steel as sharp as High Carbon Steel. Well maybe not at the microscopic level which I hope to find out when I get them back, but for practical use in the shop I can't tell the difference. So go ahead and buy whatever you want because they will get sharp enough. 




