Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

What I am doing wrong sharpening?

Posts

What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#1

What I am doing wrong sharpening?

Jorge

my sharpening routine: put gouge in the jig, go to the wheel, dtarting at the nose a light pass to the end of left wing, then start at the nose and a light pass to the end of the right wing, done. It used to give me a perfect edge every time, but now it ends up with a dip near the nose on the right wing. The picture is not good but you can see what I mean:


I do a lot of shear scrapping and that dip is no good for that. What I am doing wrong?

I have done this for years, my set up is never disturbed, what may have happened is the wheels are getting smaller in one hand, in the other the flues are very short now about 3 inches, so soon the jig will not accept them.

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#2

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

robo hippy

John Lucas has a clip up on You Tube that discusses this. You need to take a little more off the nose, and/or a little more off the wing. You are grinding a bit too much off in that one spot.

I do prefer scrapers for shear scraping.... When I used gouges for that, I liked the swept back ones better.

robo hippy

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#3

here's the video *LINK*

John Lucas

What your doing wrong is hitting the nose twice. On U shaped bowl gouges it's really easy to get a dip on each side of the nose. I had that problem when I first started sharpening them. To correct it you have to sort of skip that area, or barely barely touch it while you actively grind the wing behind it and the nose in front.

It works like this. If you have an area on the gouge that is too high, you stay on that area longer on the grinder. If it's too low you either avoid touching that area or touch it as lightly as you can.

Sometimes it helps to draw a line with a magic marker to get the shape of the wings the way you want. You can grind a little and then look at the side and see where you need to grind more to get down to the line.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M9G16ylEZHQ

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#4

Thanks Reed! Thanks John!!

Jorge

This did not happen until recently, after some 1200 bowls...

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

Keith Tompkins

HI Jorge, It's also possible that the inside profile changed as you shortened the tool. (?)

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

Lyle Jamieson

If you grind the wing back a little more the area behind your dip flattens out easier.

Grind a flat on the round area behind where the flute ends so the jig can be pushed back on the flat, and use more of the tool as it gets shorter and shorter.

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#7

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

Jorge

Yes, my daughter said the same.

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#8

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

Jorge

Good idea Lyle, Thank you!

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#9

We do try to use ALL of the gouge......

JamieDonaldson

...we can sharpen by grinding a flat at the end of the flute to fit the jig. The occasional problem then becomes apparent when the entire shaft of the tool has not been hardened, as many tools today are induction hardened in smaller furnaces that do not include the entire shaft of the tool. This is often the reason that stubby tools, especially gouges, will not hold a sharp edge near the end of the flute.

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: We do try to use ALL of the gouge......

Lyle Jamieson

Another reason to use Thompson tools, they are 100 percent hardened.

Re: What I am doing wrong sharpening?

#11

Bill Blasic

Re: We do try to use ALL of the gouge......

Bill Blasic

That is one nice thing about the HannesTool Vector Grinding jig, you can sharpen your tool all the way to the bottom of the flute without doing anything extra to the tool.