Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

spindles

Posts

spindles

#1

Keith Tompkins

spindles

Keith Tompkins

A spindle job I just completed; there is a set of long spindles(shown), and a matching set of short spindles for a restoration job. I turned these using the method used by Jon Seigel I mentioned before. That method turns just one element of each spindle, then the next element, and so on, rather than turning each spindle from beginning to end in one take.

Re: spindles

#2

Re: spindles

James Heaston

Good job!

You gonna cut the dovetail on the base?

Re: spindles

#3

Re: spindles

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Very nicely done.

Wish I knew that method when I did my bud's restoration. Close to 100 pieces for a 2-story staircase, and he couldn't find ready-mades that either matched or even came close in stain-grade material. Made a short and a long and then mounted them close to the workpiece as references. It was funny when his contractor asked if I was interested in doing other jobs. I politely declined.

Re: spindles

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: spindles

Keith Tompkins

This might help those having trouble duplicating spindle work. I first transferred the critical dimensions from an original spindle to a story stick. (A) Since I only turned one detail/section at a time, there was no need to move the tool rest, so I used the rest as a reference point, filing "v" notches in the story stick that fit a pencil point. Since the tool rest wasn't moving, I also used it to measure diameters....I made a semaphore from thin material that fit over the rest; when it dropped into place, the diameter was correct (B). Fig. (C) shows the semaphore at the base of a cove, and a spindle gouge rolled over to complete a bead. I don't use a parting tool to set depths, it leaves a flat spot with torn grain. I turn by eye, then drop the semaphore jig to check finished dimensions. When all spindles are done to this point, I move the tool rest, and start the next series of elements. Hope this helps....Do I think this method is faster than turning each spindle to completion in one shot? Yes. Do I think it's more accurate? Yes again.

Re: spindles

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: spindles

Keith Tompkins

Hi James, thanks! I think the contractor can cut the dovetails at this point, since each dovetail is hand cut and are all different.

Re: spindles

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: spindles

Keith Tompkins

Hi Mark....thanks! :)

Re: spindles

#7

Re: spindles

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Nifty system.

I used a parting tool but left the diameters 1/32 proud to deal with the torn grain. Used a skew on the beads and v-groves but no-way am I good enough with a skew to do the coves. Went with a convex-ground detail gouge for those.

Not that I'm likely to get hooked into this kind of deal again, but I'm filing the info in this thread away for future reference.

Thanks Keith!!

Re: spindles

#8

Re: spindles

David Walser

Very interesting and very useful information.

Question 1: Do you start in any particular order? To avoid chatter, I would think you would start at the tailstock and work towards the headstock.

Question 2: These spindles have a long taper. Do you complete the beads and coves before working on the taper?

Question 3: When working on such a project, do you start out making extras in case one or two are ruined? Since you don't move the tool rest until you've completed a section of each spindle, it would appear difficult to start over on a piece should a hidden flaw in a blank require you to toss a piece when working on a later section.

Re: spindles

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: spindles

Keith Tompkins

HI David, Here are the answers:

1. I started at the headstock, turning the base of the spindles.

2. I completed all the beads, coves, tapers, etc. first, then installed a homebuilt steady rest which used skate wheels; I located it just after the last cove cut. I then turned each taper, measuring against the original in a couple of key locations. The top end was 9/16", so that had to be turned last. Light pressure using the steb center.

3.The customer supplied the materials, ripped to exact size but leaving each piece a bit long (you can see the extra in the photo). He gave me precisely the quantity he needed, nothing extra! I would have preferred to select the stock myself, ensuring straight grain, but some were not. To make things worse, some had moved and twisted a bit. In this case, I turned them all without incident, no design changes, no catches. :D