Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

optical illusion *LINK*

Posts

optical illusion *LINK*

#1

optical illusion *LINK*

John Lucas

Never have figured out how to use most optical illusions in wood turning but the fascinate me.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNe6fsaCVtI

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#2

Re: optical illusion

Keith Newton

Humm, That is interesting. I didn't pick up on them all moving in a straight line, until it was revealed, then it was similar to a template set that I made years ago for drawing ellipses, but instead of little balls, I made little UHMW slides which were T shaped in cross section.

This also reminded me of an article in FWW aver 20 years ago, where someone had a face-plate lathe set up to turn elliptical picture frames, which probably had something like this built in behind that faceplate. I don't' recall if they showed the works or not, but maybe someone with a disk can find it and report back.

I guess if you really want to understand it, you could sneak out into the garage some night and pull the front cover off the wife's turbo engine, to to study how that works.

This is a good brain teaser, thanks

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#3

Re: optical illusion

William Duffield

Keith, you're mixing up two different memories. The FWW article, Feb, 1991, Issue 86, Page 88, by Len Schmidt, uses the same eliptograph mechanism you built. It cuts the elliptical paths with a router. The lathe-mounted elliptograph at the Old Schwamb Mill, in Arlington, MA, was shown in New Yankee Workshop Season 7, Episode 7, in 1995, but there wasn't enough information about its mechanism to reproduce it. I can't find a place on the internet to watch it.

http://www.oldschwambmill.org/research/articles/articles.html

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

The "rotation" appears (to me) after fourth ball!

steven antonucci

Saw a square at that point...

I also thought about the ellipse drawing thing. It is the same, except both X and Y are the same distance, so you get a circle!

S

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#5

Re: Eureka

William Duffield

I found an explanation, with drawings, of the mechanism used for an oval lathe. It is an extension of the simpler ellipsograph with a moving cutter. There are three pages of explanations, starting here:

http://www.oldschwambmill.org/theframes/theframes.html

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#6

Re: optical illusion

Tony - Memphis

Actually, FWW had a pretty good article showing the setup. I can't find it (I'm at work darnit), but I know it was in an old one and might be in one of their books. Even with the drawings it is a head scratcher...and I play an engineer during he day.

Tony

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#7

Re: optical illusion

William Duffield

I'll have to try again to find something else in FWW. So far, the only article I found was the one I referenced. Of course, most search engines aren't nearly as smart as Google's. You often have to already know exactly what you are searching for to find it.

And sure enough, when you know the name of the mill, the FWW Archive finds the article! It starts on page 74 of the May/June, 1986 issue, and the drawings are the same as in the website I linked to, and there's lots of other material in the article.

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#8

Re: optical illusion

John Lucas

Fine woodworking and other magazines have run similar articles about every 5 years or so. I built one of those somewhere around 25 years ago to route a table top I did for my grandfather. I think I got the idea out of a router book of which I have many.

Re: optical illusion *LINK*

#9

Re: optical illusion

Bob Macgregor

It seems to me that the timing of the balls sliding along their linear tracks would be the critical factor in establishing this illusion. Is this what a radial engine would look like if viewed (exploded view) from the end?