Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Threads jamming on spindle

Posts

Threads jamming on spindle

#1

Threads jamming on spindle

Ron Bauer

Lately I have been having a terrible time loosening threaded fittings (face plates and chucks) on my PM spindle (1 1/4 x 8). It is about 8 years old and has seen steady but not excessive use over that time. I have tried a drop of machine oil when putting on the fitting which did not help. What do you do to alleviate this problem? Do those washers really work and if so what is the best material? A three pound hammer and a pipe wrench does not seem to be a good long term solution! TIA. Ron.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#2

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

Ron Bauer

Sorry, I don't know where that emoticon came from. It is a 1 1/4 x 8 spindle. R.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#3

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

John Lucas

Ron Are you talking about getting chucks and faceplates back off because they are stuck against the back flange of the spindle. If so here are a few tips. First off I put my chucks on finger tight. The put the chuck key in and tighten the chuck. Thats al it takes. If you snap the chuck on with a quick twist it can lock on very securely.

I use air tool oil on the spindle flange. Just a drop or so and then wipe it off. I bought some of the nylon spindle bushings back when I had that problem. They work but I never use them anymore.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#4

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

Ralph Lindberg

Some people swear by "spindle washers".... others swear at them

They are soft plastic washers, sized to your spindle.

Personally I only use them with vacuum chucks

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#5

Sounds like a damaged thread on the ........

JamieDonaldson

....spindle, so see if you can eyeball it and repair with a small triangular file. Be gentle with the file! ;)

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#6

Re: Sounds like a damaged thread on the ........

Don Orr

I agree with Jamie-probably damaged spindle threads. Do you or did you happen to use a set screw to hold your chuck or faceplate on-maybe for reverse turning your workpiece? If you don't back them all the way out when taking something off your spindle they can mess up your threads. It's a common problem. Easily fixed with CAREFUL cleanup with a triangular file as Jamie said.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#7

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

Bill Howatt

I have used washers made from the thin plastic from the lid of a margarine container. Drill a 1-1/4" (or whatever is needed) hole and then cut out the OD with scissors.

I know the purists get excited about extra vibration but I could never really tell the difference. However, I don't use them very often now that I've been more careful on the tightening of the chuck/faceplate. Unless you are reverse-turning, the regular forces tighten the chuck anyway so there is no need to initially over-do it.

Bill

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#8

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

Ron Bauer

Guys, Thanks for the ideas. I will start applying them tomorrow. Ron.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#9

Clean is your friend.....

Barry Irby

As others have suggested, check the shaft and the female threads for damage and rough spots. If there are burs or gauling, carefully remove them. Also check the mating faces on the lathe and back of the chuck and the end of the shaft and the internal shoulder the end of the shaft mates with.

I would also suggest you clean the shaft and female threads very carefully and oil them with light oil or wax them. I am wondering if fine abrasive from the sanding process got on the threads. Wouldn't take but a grit or two to lock the threads.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#10

Never oil or wax threads

Bill Boehme

Threads on anything should never be lubricated because it very likely can cause the threads to become distorted. Threads are friction holding fasteners. If you lubricate them, you may think that will make it easier to unscrew the fastener, but it also makes it far easier to very severely over tighten the fastener.

When a screw fastener is tightened, the threads are slightly distorted. If the threads are lubricated, friction is greatly reduced and as a result of applying the same tightening force as you would apply to dry threads, the distortion is far greater. Breaking a fastener loose after it has been lubricated and tightened can be nearly impossible. The "flat face" mentioned in several posts is called a register or registration surface. The register is what provides the precision alignment of the chuck to the spindle. Threads are strictly fasteners and provide only coarse alignment. Plastic washers slightly reduce the precision, but not enough to matter. I don't use them and have never seen a reason to do so. There is no reason to tighten a chuck beyond just snugging it up to the register. I would recommend removing all traces of oil or wax from both the spindle and chuck threads as well as the register face.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#11

Never oil or wax threads +1 here

Geoff Whaling

Bills, tips are spot on. Keeping both the M & F threads clean & just firming up the chuck or face plate so both registration surfaces are aligned is all that is required.

Ron, I would be looking at cleanliness of threads; chuck installation technique; then thread damage; chuck/insert style/registration in that order.

You don't say what style of chuck or insert you are using or if you have changed anything. The length of the head stock spindle thread in combination with the style of chuck insert may possibly be an issue if you have changed something lately, though not very likely.

Have you changed chucks / inserts? It may be possible that if things have changed that you may actually require a spindle washer spacer because the inserts may be registering upon the nose of the thread when they should be registering on the shoulder. I have found some dodgy inserts where the threads (pitch/diameter) have not been manufactured well, supposedly manufactured to the same specification but will not "mix & match."

The register surfaces of face plate / chuck inserts can be different depending upon your chuck or face plate manufacturer. Vicmarc says "Insert must be firmly seated against the lathe spindle shoulder." Oneway actually say "Screw it all the way on until the adaptor face contacts the spindle shoulder. Next, lock your spindle, and unscrew the chuck just slightly so you can give it a firm swift spin, consequently snapping the chuck home." - which I have found almost always results in a stuck chuck?? So even manufacturers differ. Nova's recommendations are too long to precis.

Spindle registration - Vicmarc, use the outer surface (rear) of the chuck insert to register against the rear surface of the head stock spindle. Others i.e. Nova/Teknatool may use the inner surface or "nose" of the spindle thread to register against the chuck body. Check manufacturers manuals.

Insert/chuck registration - The face plate / chuck inserts for some, i.e. Vicmarc, use the inner mating surface of the chuck insert boss to register against the rear surface of the chuck body. Others i.e. Nova/Teknatool use the inner surface or "nose" of the insert thread to register on the machined surface inside the chuck body; Stronghold Taperlock rely upon the friction in the conical taper and nipping down the cap screws equally.

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#12

Harry Robinette

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

Harry Robinette

Get a thread file should find one at Fasnall or McMaster-Carr or places like that. I have one that's 4 sided double ended you can clean-up,straighten thread and reset the angle on 8 different thread sizes all round good tool to have around .

Re: Threads jamming on spindle

#13

Thanks for the great comments..

Ron Bauer

To follow up on my end. I am using the same two Vicmarc's that I have used for years. They seem to register to the spindle shoulder. The face plates are Powermatics which also seem to register to the spindle shoulder. I lightly touched up the spindle threads with a triangle file even though they did not seem to have burrs. I have cleaned all oil from the spindle and chuck/faceplates. I have started to diligently blow off the spindle and inserts before mounting. Without really testing the improvements (such as a coring episode) things seem to be markedly better in terms of jamming. Thanks for all your responses. I know I have improved and hopefully other beginners have learned something as well. Ron.