Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

This isn't wood, but it is turning...

Posts

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#2

Maybe just a little tallent and experience there.


Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#3

Lots of similarity with pottery and woodturning!


Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#4

Steven Antonucci

My potter friends argue against this :-)

steven antonucci

They like to suggest that the two are completely different.

In woodturning, you remove material to get to form.

In pottery, you start with material to construct form.

Their argument is we start with more than we need and subtract, while they start with what they need and reform it, but do not remove material.

It is an interesting conversation, and I see both sides. :)

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#5

Re: My potter friends argue against this :-)

Don Orr

I meant mostly form, shape, decoration, texture, color, etc. I agree somewhat about the subtractive vs. additive aspect. I wish wood was as easy to mainipulate as clay. Especially when you can just smush up your mistakes and start over. My wife is a potter and I know many others as well. Fun to show and tell with them.

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#6

Steven Antonucci

I usually say they are more alike then different!

steven antonucci

At least in forms... we both aim for similar vessels. I would offer this for your next debate:

In general, who do you think pays more attention to form? I've seen a lot of pots with flat spots, flat feet, or just slightly off in where the curve was in the pot. I would contend that woodturners make better forms.

You can run and duck the clay balls your wife throws at you if you say this to her ... ;-)

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#7

what if you do segmented work

John Lucas

In that instance you are adding and adding and then you subtract. Or in the case of some of my mirrors I might add, subtract, and then add more.

I had this conversation with a potter and had never thought of it that way before then. At first I agreed but then I thought about all the other process we do.

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: My potter friends argue against this :-)

Lyle Jamieson

Potters learn about the drying process too. Uniform wall thickness works for both clay and wood.

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#9

Dick Hines

Re: My potter friends argue against this :-)

Dick Hines

A potter can redo his mistakes. If they blow up a piece they can ball it up and start over. Hard for a turner to redo a blown up hollow form or bowl. :D

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#10

I watched it all the way through, twice!


Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#11

Re: My potter friends argue against this :-)

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, they add the beauty by decorating it and we cherish what is given naturaly to us and we try to make it come alive. I am sure they say oh, they make something come alive out of dust, however, I don't think they can mimic he natural grain patterns and the look of a burl in their work. Also, I wish we could redo our mistakes like they did , then again, we wouldn't get that good at it. this way we get better and better not to make those mistakes.

I do have respect for both fields and I think there are some turners that do very nice job of transforming an ugly looking log to something cherish-able.

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#12

Thank You. That Was Lovely.


Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

Keith Tompkins

Thanks Reed, very inspirational. My take is....how easy someone can make it appear when they really know what they're doing. We soon discover it's not always as easy as it looks!

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#14

..... Or piercing

Bill Boehme

The difference between piercing wood with a high speed cutter and carving clay with a knife isn't anything more than the tools used.

Like segmented turners, potters add then subtract as they make the walls thinner. Potters have what amounts to a "reset button" that allows them to start over while woodturners have "design opportunities". Not much difference.

Re: This isn't wood, but it is turning...

#15

Re: I usually say they are more alike then differe

Don Orr

I have to agree with you on this Steve. I have seen a lot of pottery vessels that are lacking the refinement that turners often achieve. The vessels in the video were exceptional in my opinion.