Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

looking for new tool rest

Posts

looking for new tool rest

#1

looking for new tool rest

darrin hill

when i bought my nova, the only curved ones they had at the local woodcraft were the woodriver ones.. and they're soft steel…

want to get the best curved…. who makes the good ones?

oneway? powermatic? vicmark? ?? ?? ??

Re: looking for new tool rest

#2

Bill Blasic

Re: looking for new tool rest

Bill Blasic

Try here.

http://www.turnrobust.com/Robust_Tool_Rests.html

Re: looking for new tool rest

#3

Ditto

John Lucas

I seldom use a curved rest, just don't turn many bowls and when I'm usually done before I realize I might have used the rest. When I do need one I grap the Robust. It's quite rigid and has a hardened rod in the top. I do have a Bestwoodtools curved rest and sometimes it's just the right one for that particular bowl but I use the robust mostly.

Re: looking for new tool rest

#4

Re: looking for new tool rest

Dale Bonertz

I have the woodriver but I don't use it very often for the reason you mention. I am concerned someday it will snap off. I also have the vicmarc which is solid and good but as with all of them the post area gets in the way when sweeping the gouge to the bottom. The best that I have used is the oneway which is solid and gets in the way the least. Having said that I just purchased a 16" long rest from vicmarc (I won't get it until our symposium this September - Christian is bringing it with him [Woodworkers Emporium]). I can work it around and through the curve rather than having the annoyance of things getting in the way as the curved ones do. I only use the curved ones on deeper bowls since they are not needed on normal depth or shallower bowls. I am hoping this longer rest will allow me to not use the curved ones ever again.

Re: looking for new tool rest

#5

Steven Antonucci

I was just going to post "why I hate curved rests"

steven antonucci

but you beat me to it.

S

Re: looking for new tool rest

#6

Re: I was just going to post "why I hate curved re

John Lucas

I think my problem with curved tool rests is my bowls are too closed shaped or simply small enough that a good cut with a bowl gouge will allow me to go all the way to the bottom with a normal straight rest. I don't have more than about 3" of tool hanging over since the straight rest is angled in.

If I was making bowls with larger openings that were deep my curved tool rests come into play. They are also very handy for scraping bowl interiors but then I seldom use a scraper anymore.

I do use the curved tool rest on the outside some so I don't have to move the straight tool rest as often.

Does anybody make an offset tool rest for doing offset turnings. :)

Re: looking for new tool rest

#7

Steven Antonucci

Second reason...

steven antonucci

With a straight rest, the tool will move in one direction (along the rest, however you have it positioned)

With a curved rest inside of a bowl, aside from the issue with the rest interfering with the sweep of the gouge, you also have the issue that the tool now moves in two dimensions (forward and left to right to follow the curve)

I bought one years ago to solve a problem, but it is easily the least used piece of equipment I own. If I used a scraper, it would probably see more use...but gouges are impossible on a curved rest.

S

Re: looking for new tool rest

#8

Re: looking for new tool rest

Bill Howatt

I'm sure there are places where a curved rest is a good answer for some problems and we certainly don't all turn the same size/shape pieces.

When I started turning I was fixated on having curved rest(s) that would allow me to do the job. Now that I am more experienced and have more confidence I rarely give much thought to using a curved rest. Still, they can be another tool in the arsenal for problems and we all have a lot of those rarely used tools kicking around.

Bill

Re: looking for new tool rest

#9

I enjoy using curved rests

Dick Coers

Why all this hate talk? Poor curved rests! Really, there are times when the curved rests really help me out. I also have one of the Hannes "J" rests. Just consider them as other tools in the arsenal.

Re: looking for new tool rest

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: looking for new tool rest

Lyle Jamieson

I don't make a curved tool rest so I cant help you. I would look at Robust if you want a hardened rod on top.

I have a different take...I want my tool rest softer then my tools. I can file off any dings or dimpling of my tool rest. But, I do not want to damage my tools with the forces of turning on a hardened tool rest. A boring bar can get dimpled and other square profile tools like scrapers or skews can get the corners damaged from the tool rest. When the tools get damaged they do not slide effortlessly across the tool rest and makes smooth cuts and removing tool marks harder. My tool rests are made from softer cold-rolled steel.

Re: looking for new tool rest

#11

Re: looking for new tool rest

Craig Daymon

There is a good reason to have a toolrest be softer than your tools. If they were harder, they wouldn't get dents, but they would dent your tools. If soft, you can hit them with a file and smooth them. If the dent is in your tool, everytime you pass that part of the tool over the rest you will get a disruption, possibly causing your tool to stop in place and resulting in a catch or worse.

I've heard the Robust rests are very good and well liked by those that use them. Certainly, they are good for the pros who are much less likely to get a catch and generate a nick in the rest. Therefore, a hard rest is to their advantage. For those of us not there yet, a file and some wax put to use on the rest before we begin (and, if necessary during) turning is probably a better approach.

Re: looking for new tool rest

#12

Re: looking for new tool rest

robo hippy

Well, I love the bowl rests, but the inside ones can be greatly improved. The outside rests from Oneway and Robust are both used a lot in my shop. The Oneway is a flatter curve, in the 15 inch diameter range, and the Robust is a 12 inch diameter curve. I find I use the flatter curve the most.

As far as material, I prefer the hardened steel/drill rod rests by far. It is just less friction. Less friction = less work. I have never had any problems with tool damage because of the hardness of the rest. Since I don't do many hollow forms, I don't know about dents in the hollowing tools. I haven't seen any in my Kelton hollowers. The Oneway are stainless, and are not as slick as the drill rod, but are a lot slicker than cast metal.

Now, the inside rests. This is my favorite shape:

http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/p/111/4531/Apprentice-S-Curve-Tool-Rest?term=bowl%20rests

I do not like or use the other inside rests very often. this includes the Oneway (which bounces a bit if you are doing heavy roughing on the tip) or the Robust. As others have said, the tool post and end of the rest get in the way. With the blue one, you just set it up so the post is in line with the rim of the bowl, and as you turn out the inside of the bowl, you just pivot in inside. There is never a need to reposition the banjo. This is a huge time saver to me when turning bowls. You can also work the rim once it is set up, which is why there is the recurve on the outside of this rest. This also has the tool post under the rest and pretty much out of the way. The problem with this rest is that the platform is way too flat, and if you drop your handles as you make cuts, it is in the way if you drop more than about 20 degrees. It does work on the outside of a bowl, but really is a specialized rest for the inside. I am trying to figure out how to make one with drill rod. Brent figured out it would be pretty difficult, and didn't seem interested. First efforts work perfectly, but the problem is the support finger. It is a compound curve which is set at a 15 degree angle so it will fit in closer to the wall inside a 12 inch diameter bowl. This is a difficult bend to make. I am working to solve this, and see if it can be made at a good market price. Water jet cutters? Laser cutters? Die bending? 3 D printers? There has to be a solution, I just have to find it.

I do prefer the specialized bowl rests. They save work. If you have a straight rest, you do hang out too far off the tool rest, and have to reposition your banjo way too many times. The curved rests reduce this amount of time a lot. They are just more efficient.

robo hippy

Re: looking for new tool rest

#13

Re: I like my Robust Rest

Steve Criscenzo

I purchased a curved Robust rest about a year ago and use it often. I do not use it much for roughing out bowls becasue you have to start with a straight rest anyway and I just complete it that way. When finishing bowls however, I find that having the ability to put the rest where I want it and then make long sweeping cuts with a short overhang makes for a fine finishing cut with a variety of tools. Often I can position the rest so I can work the entire inside without repositioning the rest. I have not experienced any flex in the rest but then again I am not roughing with it. I believe that the curved rest can make for more controlled (and more safe) cuts.

The Robust is curved but not circular so by changing the position you can find a radius that works for the work at hand.

Steve

Re: looking for new tool rest

#14

Re: looking for new tool rest

darrin hill

i have a nova with an outrigger, and i can do up to almost 30 inch bowls… i sometimes use a scraper to smooth the inside curve, and even though it's sorby's big bowl scraper, it does catch when your tool rest is restricted by the curve of the bowl…

so this is why I'm looking for a curved tool rest..

Re: looking for new tool rest

#15

Brad Vietje

'Nuther Explanation attempt (?)

Brad Vietje

Like Steve, I usually find the the curved rests hinder as often as help -- or more often. I have the full round curve of the Oneway rest, which I don't use much. It extends quite a distance from the post, and it does tend to vibrate a little. I don't like getting vibration leading to interesting spiral patterns. I use the J-rest sold by Hannes and Andre Martel quite a lot, and often find good uses for both the straight and curved sections -- but sometimes the curved part does get in the way. I believe there are the same as the Robust J-rests, yes ?

I suspect curved rests create a clearance issue for those that work with more vertical tool angles (shear cutting or scraping), while they would not get in the way as much for those who tend to use their tools parallel to the floor. Could that be the distinction? Let me know if you think I'm on the right track here.

When I use a scraper on the inside or outside of a medium-sized bowl, I do find the Oneway curved rest quite helpful -- the tool handle is slightly above horizontal -- but I don't often remember it, or take the time to switch out the Powermatic rest. Mostly I use gouges and not scrapers, and my finish cuts or vertical shear scrapes are usually at a significant angle from the horizontal, so the curve impedes the movement of the tool handle for me.

Maybe I'm off the mark here, but I'm wondering if the "level cutters" are happier with curved rests than the "angled cutters" (?)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: looking for new tool rest

#16

Harry Robinette

Re: looking for new tool rest

Harry Robinette

I've been using the Robust curved rest for about a year. I have 2 or 3 but the Robust I use probably

10 to 1 over the others.

Re: looking for new tool rest

#17

Steven Antonucci

That is my issue

steven antonucci

Exactly.

I usually cut with the handle low, and all kinds of things start getting in the way around the banjo...

It is the fact that the banjo needs to be in the interior of the bowl that causes the issue. If someone made a bowl rest that was shaped like a question mark, it would probably alleviate the issue.