Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

Posts

Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#1

Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

DKWalser

I spent the last two days at the AAW symposium in Phoenix. I'm intoxicated with all the new information. It was great to meet in person some of the people I've come to know over the internet.

With that out of the way, I'd like to ask your opinions of the various sphere turning jigs that are commercially available. At the symposium's trade show, the Vermec and the Carter jigs were on display. My impression is that the Vermec is extremely smooth. However, the base of the jig sticks up rather high, which limits the size of sphere you can turn. (With my 16" swing, I was told the maximum size sphere would be about 5.5".) The quality of the construction and the materials used make believe that the jig could be used for a long time without reducing its accuracy.

The Carter jig has a lower profile, which gives it a much larger capacity. On my lathe, I was told I could turn a sphere over 10" in diameter. However, the jig is not nearly as smooth. The jig is made mostly of aluminum and appears to use plastic bushings to allow the swing arm to rotate. (The Vermec uses ball bearings and is made of steel.) The Carter jig is well made and I think it would last a long time, but I don't think it would withstand as much use and abuse as would the Vermec jig. Overtime, I think the jig will develop a little play in swing arm.

Also, the swing arm of the Carter jig is longer (which grants greater capacity), which means you need to have the sphere farther away from the headstock (or the headstock will obstruct the arc of the jig, preventing completion of the cut on the headstock side of the sphere). Also, the cutting arm extends out further from it's holder. (This is because the swing arm has widely spaced drilled holes to change the size capacity. The cutting arm needs to be long enough to reach the distance between these holes. Vermec's jig uses a slot, instead of drilled holes, in it's swing arm. This allows the Vermec's cutting arm to be shorter.) The combination of far from the headstock and long length of the cutting arm introduces chatter that was very evident during Carter's demonstration of the jig. Not a big problem when turning with tailstock support, but it seemed to be an issue without the tailstock -- even with light cuts. Perhaps a spindle steady could be used to reduce the vibration?

My take of the two jigs is that the Vermec is superior in quality, but gives up something in capacity. The Carter jig has greater capacity, but isn't as smooth.

Any of you have opinions to share about these or other sphere cutting jigs?

David

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#2

Dick Hines

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

Dick Hines

I have the Carter system and like it, Making spheres is a great way to use scrap wood that is to small for anything else.

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#3

Thanks for your excellent review


Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#4

Vermec are built like a brick outhouse

Geoff Whaling

I have owned the Vermec Sphere Jig plus a a lot more of their gear for quite a few years now and can say with confidence your appraisal of the quality & robustness is pretty spot on - its built like a brick outhouse as we Aussies say.

I mostly turn spheres by hand and also using the jig depending upon my circumstances & mood, but rarely over 120 - 150 mm dia. According to Enzo's brochure 280 mm diameter is achievable on a 300 mm center height, 180 on a 200 mm height.

I have concerns about how light some jigs are so that was the main reason for me choosing the Vermec jig.

Plus I'm a Queenslander and so are the Vermec & Vicmarc brands - family owned businesses run by the Verrecchia families.

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#5

Re: Vermec are built like a brick outhouse

John lucas

I've been collecting data on sphere turning jigs for years e wise I thought it would make a good metal working project. I like the design of the vermec. If I remember correctly they sell come centers with slots so you can start with a square block. I really like that idea.

I borrowed a carter jig before it was made by carter. It worked well. I think I wrote a review on this board so you may be able to find it. I didn't turn anything large with it but was able to make 3 spheres a out 3" in diameter virtually identical in size. I was trying it out for a friend who needed to make spheres for a game and they had to be identical

Shush I could compare

Them side by side. I turn my spheres by hand and other than not being identical in size are quite adequate for what I do. I did buy some plastic rod to make better sphere turning comes. Been too busy to make those yet

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#6

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

Ralph Watts

David,

When I checked out the Carter I watched the demo person use two machine squares to align the center of the jig with the work piece. The Vermec has a center point that can be raised to exactly set the centerline. This is a great feature and worth the extra cost of the Vermec. Plus, as pointed out, the Vermec is a solid piece of engineering. The quality of the product will be remembered long after the purchase price is forgotten.

Best regards, Ralph

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#7

Jim Barbour

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs? *LINK*

Jim Barbour

I have the Vermec on a Nova DVR and find it to be excellent. Turning individual spheres that are accurately round and multiple spheres that are the same diameter to each is fairly straight forward. However, when it came to turning sets of spheres that were both true and of the same diameter, the difficulty by hand increased quite a bit. Thus a jig. The Vermec was used to turn the bocce set I posted a few weeks past. The balls are true and all true to size within 0.5mm, which is good enough for bocce among amateurs.


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/turning.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=24971ovpcAYZBqTSivjC1402944503;spage=1;sanc=478050;sbid=2000;md=read;id=478050#m_478050

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#8

What about the EZ Ball XL Radius Cutting Jig?

David Walser

A jig that was not on display at the AAW Symposium is the EZ Ball XL Radius Cutting Jig (http://www.threadingjig.com/blog/ez-ball-xl-radius-cutting-jig).

The jig works differently than the others we've been discussing. Rather than pivoting from a point directly under the center of the sphere you're cutting, this jig pivots from a point at the lathe's center height. Instead of the Hunter carbide cutter used by the other two jigs, this jig uses a cutter made from a 5/16" HSS drill rod. Instead of being mounted to the lathe's bed, this jig uses the banjo. Maximum capacity is a 4" diameter. It looks very easy to set up and use (judging from both youtube videos and the instructions on the website). It also looks like it is well made and should be smooth and durable. It's greatest advantage is the price -- $229, about $150 less than the Vermec and Carter jigs.

Thoughts?

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#9

Certainly worth looking at...

Geoff Whaling

as it appears to be robust enough and well made.

A couple of observations -

Requires care in setting up to avoid creating non spherical balls. But that could be seen as adding another dimension - the ability to create acorn tops for finials or ovid balls - something that is very difficult to do with other jigs.

Limited range of sizes? with cutter design. Offset of banjo controls shape. Offset of "fly cutter" controls diameter.

The banjo can be offset to create perfect torus on scamulus, beads etc on columns.

I quite like the novel approach & ability to modify the shape produced i.e. spherical or ovoid; and the ability to offset the axis of the sphere on large spindle items. Most turners doing that work would hand turn anyway but its a option.

Overall looks like another tool worth owning if you want those features.

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#10

Something more

David Walser

In my mini-review of the Vermec and Carter jigs, I should have mentioned that both jigs can be used to hollow out a semi-circle. Both booths showed off sphere-shaped hollow boxes that were made with the jigs. The EZ Ball Radius jig cannot be used for hollowing.

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

#11

Re: Opinions of sphere cutting jigs?

Steve Mushinski

Ralph,

You spent a fortune on lessons on how to turn a sphere what up the the jiggy thing.

:))