Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

spindle adapter

Posts

spindle adapter

#1

spindle adapter

Thomas S Stockton

Hi all

Not much of a turner but I have an old Fay and Egan lathe with an odd ball thread size on the spindle, it's 1 1/4 by 10. I have found two ways to get it to 1 x 8 that a chuck I found cheap will fit. The first is an adapter that threads on the spindle and the second would be one that fits into the morse taper and has threads on the end, it is also held in place with a drawbar. Both cost about the same, I'm leaning towards the morse taper one, I think it would be easier to remove and might be more accurate. I've never screwed anything onto the spindle but the threads look good.

Anybody have an opinion on which would be a better way to go.

Thanks

Tom

Re: spindle adapter

#2

Re: spindle adapter

Barry Irby

I have no experience with mounting a chuck with an adapter, but I do with other gadgets. I had some face plates made, A nut welded to the back of a round steel plate. Found out that it was not the threads inside the nut that lined them up accurately. The machinist had to "face off" the exposed face of the nut so that it would pull up against the shoulder on the shaft of the lathe. Turns out that whatever it is it has to run against the end of the shaft or the shoulder on the shaft to run true. There is enough "slop" between the male and female threads to allow a considerable amount of wobble.

My guess is that the one mounted on the Morse taper might run truer it the Morse shaft runs true in the chuck.

Re: spindle adapter

#3

Re: spindle adapter

Dale Miner

In the end, trying to save a few dollars using an inexpensive chuck might prove unsatisfactory. Generally, adapters decrease rigidity and often introduce runout issues.

Oneway and probably other chuck manufactures have adapters specifically made to fit into the body of their chucks with a variety of spindle sizes. Your 1-1/4 10 is available.

http://www.oneway.ca/chucks/adaptors.htm

Re: spindle adapter

#4

Definitely threaded adapter

Dick Coers

I guess it depends on what you turn, but vibration and very high torque requirements of bowl turning would break loose a taper. You can have the tailstock up some of the time, and you can use a faceplate to turn a bowl, but if you want to hang a bowl or platter off by just the chuck use the threaded adapter.

Re: spindle adapter

#5

Re: Definitely threaded adapter

Bill Howatt

I agree. Extra torque will just try to tighten the threaded adapter and it could break the MT free. The threaded adapter must register against the shoulder on the spindle where the thread ends for it to run as true as possible.

IMO, adapters are not an ideal solution and the best solution in this case is to get a proper insert for the chuck but that is not possible for all chucks by any means.

Bill

Re: spindle adapter

#6

Re: spindle adapter

DKWalser

The answer to your question depends on things we don't know. Morse tapers are often cut more accurately than are spindle threads. So, a quality morse taper adapter may run more true than would a chuck mounted on your spindle threads. Also, Morse tapers drive spinning loads very effectively -- providing both parts are clean and true. If your spindle adapter is firmly seated in the headstock's Morse taper and secured by a drawbar, you needn't worry about being able to drive your blank.

Assuming the headstock's Morse taper is true and you have a quality adapter, that's the route I would go. On the other hand, if those things are not true, I'd go in the other direction.

Good luck!