Horses for courses
Geoff Whaling
Sharpening is only part of the story, there is tool profile, base stock profile, edge included angle, grind profile, wood properties, "controlability", edge brittleness etc.
I read a well documented "scientific article" on which of the available tool steels held up best - only one small problem, the tool steel profile was machined and applied as a metal machinist uses tool steels and not as a wood turner does. So to my mind it only proved which tool steel lasted longer in a non typical application.
I prefer blunt angles on my skews rather than the 20 to 25 degree included angle many use. I use more like 35 to 40 degrees which I find maintains a "sharper" edge longer with more durability for the types of cuts and timbers I regularly use and results in a far more controlable tool for me.
Mostly I have used M2 in Hamlets and P&N with 2030 Hamlets and lately Thompson 10V. My preference is torn between the Thompson 10V & Hamlet M2 but for reasons other than the longevity of the edge. I know through an oops that the long point of a Thompson skew doesn't like contacting a live centre.
Edge sharpness will always be a contentious issue with so many variables that it is difficult to come up with a universal answer.