Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

sharpening *LINK*

Posts

sharpening *LINK*

#1

sharpening *LINK*

John Lucas

This is part of why I want to do a test some day when I have time, of the Carbon steel, vs HSS, vs Particle metal steel. If I can get them anywhere near as sharp as those knives then I might be able to tell the difference, if there is any, of the steels we use. I'll have to grind 3 tools Identically with the same bevel angles and then I guess I'll go through the scary sharp procedure and go to really high grits with a strop at the end.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZHx_uNRCR0

Re: sharpening *LINK*

#2

Steven Antonucci

only part of the equation

steven antonucci

Sharp is good. However, for turning applications, toughness and wear probably actually matter more. You probably lose any gains in sharpness the minute you touch the wood, even with good wear and toughness.

I've been theorizing that sharpness of an edge has very little effect on the end result for a while now. I still get a pretty good surface out of a tool that is as dull as a bag of hammers.

S

Re: sharpening *LINK*

#3

Re: only part of the equation

John Lucas

Steve that goes back to Terry Martin's latest article about how long an edge stays sharp. He says, and it was backed by the article in Woodturner, that a sharper edge stays sharp longer than one that is less sharp. In other words they are claiming that it takes longer for a really sharp edge to wear down compared to one that is less sharp.

I talked to the guy at Burrbenders and he's willing to sharpen some tools for me. I'm going to be searching for the 3 steels to grind them to an edge and send them to him. He should be able to give me an answer to the question will carbon steel sharpen better than HSS and Particle metal or will they all be equal.

Don't know how to answer the question about wear or how long the edge will last. That would have to be a more controlled experiment than I'm probably willing to test.

Re: sharpening *LINK*

#4

Re: only part of the equation

Bill Jacksonville, NC

JMHO, like carbon steel tools for final cuts convinced leaves better wood surface. Have sharpen those tools away and wish could find a few quality carbon steel turning tools. Unfortunately read an article on turning tool steels that disagrees with my belief. I also believed HSS steel left a better wood surface than exotic steels until got a Thompson bowl gouge.

Tool makers & vendors hype wear resistance, know my M2 HSS skew held and edge better than my KYRO skew. I prefer Crown M2 HSS over their Pro-PM tools.

Have read both scientific & unscientific steel wear resistance studies for different turning tool steels. Nice to know information if take it with a grain of salt. Several years ago read an article that say you can make HSS twenty one different ways.

All turning tools need sharpening when they are dull. Some wood species defy cutting cleanly regardless of how many trips to the (dry or wet) grinder or steel used to make that turning tool.

Re: sharpening *LINK*

#5

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: only part of the equation

Dennis in Southern Oregon

John, I believe that you and Terry Martin are correct. For a given bevel angle and type of steel, the sharper edge will last longer. This is illustrated in the figure where you can see that you progress from scary sharp to dull by eroding the leading edge so that its average width gets larger and larger. The uncertain issue is how many turns of the spindle does it take to erode from scary sharp to sharp. Note that as the edge is made sharper, the thickness of the blade becomes thinner. At some point, the edge will begin to fracture under load rather than simply abrading. Trying to sharpen past that point would be useless.

Dennis

Re: sharpening *LINK*

#6

Re: only part of the equation

John Lucas

Dennis it's the fracturing of the edge that makes this interesting. The theory is that carbon steel will simply get sharper than particle metal or HSS because of the metallurgy. This may or may not be true and think microscopically there will be a difference. However at the magnifications that are practical for carving or turning I still have my doubts.

I think it's well established that Carbon steel will not hold this keen edge nearly as long as HSS or particle metal. It seems to be documented that the sharper edge will hold an edge longer.

The one question not answered yet and I hope to do that with this experiment is will one steel actually get sharper than another.

In reality this is all just fun for the sake of playing. In reality we are all going to sharpen when the tool seems dull to us ( which will vary dramatically from turner to turner) and the minor differences in which grit we use to sharpen or how sharp we actually get the tool will be extremely minor.

Re: sharpening *LINK*

#7

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: only part of the equation

Dennis in Southern Oregon

As I understand it, the main limit to sharpness is the grain size of the steel. Each grain is a tiny crystal which is a regular lattice of iron, carbon and perhaps other atoms. The grains are bound together in a jumbled orientation in the composite steel and the bond between grains is less than the bond between layers of a given crystal. Therefore, the forces of sharpening tend to break off grains rather than shaving down individual grains. Grain size depends both on the composition of the steel and on the heat treating (and mistreating) applied to the steel.

Dennis

Re: sharpening *LINK*

#8

Horses for courses

Geoff Whaling

Sharpening is only part of the story, there is tool profile, base stock profile, edge included angle, grind profile, wood properties, "controlability", edge brittleness etc.

I read a well documented "scientific article" on which of the available tool steels held up best - only one small problem, the tool steel profile was machined and applied as a metal machinist uses tool steels and not as a wood turner does. So to my mind it only proved which tool steel lasted longer in a non typical application.

I prefer blunt angles on my skews rather than the 20 to 25 degree included angle many use. I use more like 35 to 40 degrees which I find maintains a "sharper" edge longer with more durability for the types of cuts and timbers I regularly use and results in a far more controlable tool for me.

Mostly I have used M2 in Hamlets and P&N with 2030 Hamlets and lately Thompson 10V. My preference is torn between the Thompson 10V & Hamlet M2 but for reasons other than the longevity of the edge. I know through an oops that the long point of a Thompson skew doesn't like contacting a live centre.

Edge sharpness will always be a contentious issue with so many variables that it is difficult to come up with a universal answer.