Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Best use of wood

Posts

Best use of wood

#1

Best use of wood

ron bauer

It is my good fortune to have been given a spectacular black walnut crotch. The attached picture does not do it justice. The feather is 25" long. My question....is the full effect of the feather best maintained if the bowl/platter is turned with a contemporary (flat) rim or is it better maintained turned natural edge? I probably will never see one like this again and I don't want to screw it up at the beginning.


Re: Best use of wood

#2

Re: Best use of wood

robo hippy

The side we are looking at in the picture is what you want in the bottom of the bowl/platter, and the natural edge up. The feather figure is in the center of the log, and the closer you get to the outside of the log, the less there is of it. This does look like a spectacular piece, and solid wood as well with no bark inclusion. I got a walnut tree some years back. two 20 inch diameter branches coming into a 30 inch trunk. Not a single speck of feather in it. I was told by an old logger that trees in the forest don't get the feather because they aren't subjected to the same wind stress as a tree in the open. This one was in a fairly deep valley with tall fir trees all around.

robo hippy

Re: Best use of wood

#3

Re: Best use of wood

GaryG in MD

As Robo says, the feather figure is probably not very deep into the wood. You may be looking at the best of it already. For that reason, I would use the face you see, barely flattened as the top of a wide, flat platter. Perhaps turn enough away to leave a raised bead to define a central area like you see on very shallow burl "bowls". Something like Terry Scott's "plain bowls" would be a good model. Put a foot of your choice on the other side to lift it off the table. Or, you could display it vertically on a plate holder. ...GG

Re: Best use of wood

#4

Re: Best use of wood

ron bauer

Thanks Robo and Gary. I do have the matching piece which presents the same figure. When I cut the crotch I tried to do it in a plane that included the three pith points. As such, one of the halves is somewhat thinner than the other. Based on your thoughts I might do the thinner half as a platter (a la Gary) and the thicker as a shallow bowl (a la Robo). Wish me luck, I'm going in. Ron.

Re: Best use of wood

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Best use of wood

Lyle Jamieson

If it were mine I would cut the straight grain wood off each side loosing the piths of both branches. This leaves just the center part where the flame is. Now I would cut that in half and do two bowls 12 and 12, Or 14 and 10 sizes. That way there is a larger proportion of flame in each piece. Its hard to think smaller but I want each bowl to be spectacular. The straight grain walnut is pretty, but not as interesting as the flame. I might even consider three bowls to capture just the essence of this tree.

Re: Best use of wood

#6

Re: Best use of wood

ron bauer

Hmmmh....another great idea, and not inconsistant with the others. Lyle, just to clarify, would they be flat rim or natural? Ron.

Re: Best use of wood

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Best use of wood

Lyle Jamieson

Both would work. But both would need to have the bottom facing the pith or flame so the color and character is in the bottom visible on the inside of the bowl. I do not leave the bark on most of my natural edge bowls. I like a natural edge with the wavy edge from the crotch area. If the wings of the bowl are splayed out so the internal shape is that of a football the natural edge will be heart shaped. I have closed the rim slightly in a shallow calabash shape I like too. It is harder to finish and sand under the undercut rim, but nice if you can nail it. Or make the rim flat too, that looks good. I lean to the non-functional side of things so I am drawn to the natural edge. If you are going for a functional look, the flat rim would suggest that. In either case I like to make the bottom a shallow ark shape not flat. The best way to hold this type of bowl would be my glue block method. This will salvage as much of the flame as possible for you, not much waste. http://youtu.be/rbZXEBIHVOU

Re: Best use of wood

#8

Re: Best use of wood

Ed Larson

Ron, please keep us informed on your progress, even pictures as you progress. This would be a good learning experience for me and probably others on how to attach a spectacular piece of wood. Enjoy your experience.

Re: Best use of wood

#9

Lyle Jamieson

another option

Lyle Jamieson

Lets think hollow forms. Make a hollow vessel that is larger diameter then it is tall. Lets say 10-12 inches in diameter by 5-6 inches tall. Make a nice rounded shape like native American pottery. Make the top undercut shoulders almost perpendicular to the lathe bed. Use a large mouth opening, say 2 inches for accessibility. Now make the mouth opening right on the edge of the flame not centered on it. The flame will be the focal point in the top of the vessel. The bottom will be facing the bark side of the tree.

Re: Best use of wood

#10

Re: another option

ron bauer

Thanks Lyle, I have so many great ideas that I need to find another piece of wood! I will study it carefully before cutting. R.